View Full Version : The Official Movieland Massacre Game Thread
Pages :
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
[
17]
18
19
20
21
Kobe1724
08-04-2010, 10:36 PM
I know we should get that fixed asap! We could call it "the law of Kobe!" haha
Only for you everyone else figured it out abour 4 days ago.
Oh oh I'll help gladly!!
Fixed. I think she's finally getting it everyone!! praise the lord it's a miracle!! *Lifts arms and shouts* Praise Jesus!! Praise him! :D
There is nothing to support any of your claims.
That's all.
BHK1978
08-04-2010, 10:36 PM
I will not give my ability in the night phase. If there is pressure on me during the day phase I may feel the need to put it out there. I will give you one more character hint though, killing someone in my position is not a good thing just ask Charles J. Guiteau.
Edited because sure did not make sense in what I was trying to say.
Kobe1724
08-04-2010, 10:38 PM
Edited because sure did not make sense in what I was trying to say.
Link for others:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Charles_J._Guiteau
BHK, please share your thought on the fives posters I listed.
Rebelliousangel
08-04-2010, 10:39 PM
BHK, please share with us your ability.
Also, what do you think of the following posters:
There is nothing to support any of your claims.
That's all.
*shakes head* I don't think you understand this game.
Max Peck
08-04-2010, 10:40 PM
Edited because sure did not make sense in what I was trying to say.
I got it....and I think I know who you might be BHK.
Kobe1724
08-04-2010, 10:40 PM
Not confirming nor denying this but, you think she's Rose?
And Paws. :)
It hadn't been where I was going with it, but of the six Rose candidates she (RA) would the most likely one if there were in fact a Rose.
BHK1978
08-04-2010, 10:40 PM
Link for others:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Charles_J._Guiteau
BHK, please share your thought on the fives posters I listed.
Look we used the day ability to its fullest. I am sorry but I will not talk game during the night phase. People made it clear to me that they do not like it when there is a ton of night phase chatter and therefore I will not be a part of it after this post.
Paws7297
08-04-2010, 10:41 PM
Link for others:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Charles_J._Guiteau
BHK, please share your thought on the fives posters I listed.
/Facepalm.
BHK1978
08-04-2010, 10:42 PM
Look we used the day to its fullest. I am sorry but I will not talk game during the night phase. People made it clear to me that they do not like it when there is a ton of night phase chatter and therefore I will not be a part of it after this post.
Sorry I am making typos left and right here. I tend to do that when I type fast.
Kobe1724
08-04-2010, 10:44 PM
*shakes head* I don't think you understand this game.
If we assume that this game has a princess then your claim is admittedly strong. Neither Paws nor Max's claims have any support, however.
Kobe1724
08-04-2010, 10:45 PM
Look we used the day ability to its fullest. I am sorry but I will not talk game during the night phase. People made it clear to me that they do not like it when there is a ton of night phase chatter and therefore I will not be a part of it after this post.
BHK is almost certainly scum, but I don't want to pressure him. :(
Paws7297
08-04-2010, 10:46 PM
If we assume that this game has a princess then your claim is admittedly strong. Neither Paws nor Max's claims have any support, however.
There's not much that can back you up when you're miller or Vanilla.
Kobe1724
08-04-2010, 10:50 PM
There's not much that can back you up when you're miller or Vanilla.
This is why these are convenient scum claims, and why it's so important to vet them. Before you can be believed you have to be more thoroughly questioned than anyone else because with the exception of investigation results (of which we currently have no reliable ones) there is no night action that can test your claim. Of course, the absence of any action could be one way of supporting this, but if you're part of a cult not necessarily.
Please understand that I must know who Rose is before I am convinced you're town Paws. Concerning Max Peck, I'll know at the end of this phase one way or another.
Max Peck
08-04-2010, 10:51 PM
Concerning Max Peck, I'll know at the end of this phase one way or another.
I call Bovine Feces on this one. All you are gonna find out is that I come up not town, unless you have some ability that you haven't said.
Scumtell imo
BHK1978
08-04-2010, 10:52 PM
If we assume that this game has a princess then your claim is admittedly strong. Neither Paws nor Max's claims have any support, however.
Okay Kobe since you put this out here I just want to say this one last thing. It is never good to out certain roles because there may be a chance that the Scum did not get that and now they have it and can use it to their advantage.
Look I stink at this game but even I realize this. Now if you are Scum (which I doubt) this is great. However, if you are town you are doing more damage to us. As cliché as this saying is, remember there is no I in team and if you are town (which I believe you are) you need to stop doing stuff like this.
Rebelliousangel
08-04-2010, 10:55 PM
Okay Kobe since you put this out here I just want to say this one last thing. It is never good to out certain roles because there may be a chance that the Scum did not get that and now they have it and can use it to their advantage.
Look I stink at this game but even I realize this. Now if you are Scum (which I doubt) this is great. However, if you are town you are doing more damage to us. As cliché as this saying is, remember there is no I in team and if you are town (which I believe you are) you need to stop doing stuff like this.
/nod. That!
Paws7297
08-04-2010, 10:55 PM
This is why these are convenient scum claims, and why it's so important to vet them. Before you can be believed you have to be more thoroughly questioned than anyone else because with the exception of investigation results (of which we currently have no reliable ones) there is no night action that can test your claim. Of course, the absence of any action could be one way of supporting this, but if you're part of a cult not necessarily.
Please understand that I must know who Rose is before I am convinced you're town Paws. Concerning Max Peck, I'll know at the end of this phase one way or another.
All will be said soon enough I am sure. I don't care if you confirm me or not. Longer I live.
Kobe1724
08-04-2010, 10:56 PM
Okay Kobe since you put this out here I just want to say this one last thing. It is never good to out certain roles because there may be a chance that the Scum did not get that and now they have it and can use it to their advantage.
Look I stink at this game but even I realize this. Now if you are Scum (which I doubt) this is great. However, if you are town you are doing more damage to us. As cliché as this saying is, remember there is no I in team and if you are town (which I believe you are) you need to stop doing stuff like this.
I understand this theory. However, as scum work in teams of 4 or more the likelihood of scum not knowing information that has been posted in the topic is slim to none. Not sharing information with the town because of some fear that the scum might obtain something new is misguided and harms the town since it keeps some members in the dark.
So I respectfully disagree.
Btw, if Paws claim about Rose existing is true she is almost certainly scum at this point.
Kobe1724
08-04-2010, 10:57 PM
I call Bovine Feces on this one. All you are gonna find out is that I come up not town, unless you have some ability that you haven't said.
Scumtell imo
Heh... :cool:
Paws7297
08-04-2010, 10:57 PM
/nod. That!
@Kobe: I am 13 and stink at this game as well and I also know this (you'd think we'd be a three person mason lol)
Kobe1724
08-04-2010, 10:57 PM
I understand this theory. However, as scum work in teams of 4 or more the likelihood of scum not knowing information that has been posted in the topic is slim to none. Not sharing information with the town because of some fear that the scum might obtain something new is misguided and harms the town since it keeps some members in the dark.
So I respectfully disagree.
Btw, if Paws claim about Rose existing is true she is almost certainly scum at this point.
*She* being Rose.
Kobe1724
08-04-2010, 10:59 PM
@Kobe: I am 13 and stink at this game as well and I also know this (you'd think we'd be a three person mason lol)
I had no idea you were so young tbqh (That isn't meant as an insult, I just thought you were older).
Paws7297
08-04-2010, 11:00 PM
I understand this theory. However, as scum work in teams of 4 or more the likelihood of scum not knowing information that has been posted in the topic is slim to none. Not sharing information with the town because of some fear that the scum might obtain something new is misguided and harms the town since it keeps some members in the dark.
So I respectfully disagree.
Btw, if Paws claim about Rose existing is true she is almost certainly scum at this point.
That makes no sense at all.
Paws7297
08-04-2010, 11:02 PM
I had no idea you were so young tbqh (That isn't meant as an insult, I just thought you were older).
........
How old did you think I was?
Kobe1724
08-04-2010, 11:06 PM
That makes no sense at all.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=47LCLoidJh4
Show this video to one person and he may or may not be aware of ____________________ the 1st time.
Show it to a room full of people and someone is much more likely to see it.
A groups powers of perception are much stronger when they freely share information and resources. People see things from different angles. The more angles something is attacked from the more likely someone is to spot inconsistencies.
This is why I never look at people the group is looking at btw. i.e. there were already enough people looking at Rev/Mareo the other day. I'll look at the people no one is looking at and try and get others to help so that we can spot inconsistencies.
Kobe1724
08-04-2010, 11:07 PM
........
How old did you think I was?
18, 19?
Paws7297
08-04-2010, 11:09 PM
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=47LCLoidJh4
Show this video to one person and he may or may not be aware of ____________________ the 1st time.
Show it to a room full of people and someone is much more likely to see it.
A groups powers of perception are much stronger when they freely share information and resources. People see things from different angles. The more angles something is attacked from the more likely someone is to spot inconsistencies.
This is why I never look at people the group is looking at btw. i.e. there were already enough people looking at Rev/Mareo the other day. I'll look at the people no one is looking at and try and get others to help so that we can spot inconsistencies.
I was talking about the 'Even if Paws is telung the truth she's scum' part.
Paws7297
08-04-2010, 11:11 PM
18, 19?
Yea, I do type more literately than most my age ^.^ And I'm super intelligant. Thanks Kobe. :)
But I still don't trust you.
Kobe1724
08-04-2010, 11:12 PM
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=47LCLoidJh4
Show this video to one person and he may or may not be aware of ____________________ the 1st time.
Show it to a room full of people and someone is much more likely to see it.
A groups powers of perception are much stronger when they freely share information and resources. People see things from different angles. The more angles something is attacked from the more likely someone is to spot inconsistencies.
This is why I never look at people the group is looking at btw. i.e. there were already enough people looking at Rev/Mareo the other day. I'll look at the people no one is looking at and try and get others to help so that we can spot inconsistencies.
Don't read this if you haven't watched the video
If you give that above test to one person they may or may not spot the dancing bear the first time. But if an auditorium of people are watching that video together at once then someone seeing the bear the 1st time through is a forgone conclusion.
My point? In a game in which the goal is to spot the dancing bear, why would you instruct people in the auditorium not to share with others when they see the dancing bear? There is another auditorium full of people (scum) who are sharing with one another when they see the bear, and by not doing the same in your own auditorium you're handicapping your group.
Kobe1724
08-04-2010, 11:15 PM
I was talking about the 'Even if Paws is telung the truth she's scum' part.
You mentioned that Rose said to you via pm earlier that she didn't think that she could be turned because she was part of a mason group. The way you phrased it sounded fishy to me, and it made me think that if "Rose" exists that she is already part of a cult. This would also explain why she hasn't outed herself even though at this point there is no good reason for her not to do so.
Paws7297
08-04-2010, 11:18 PM
You mentioned that Rose said to you via pm earlier that she didn't think that she could be turned because she was part of a mason group. The way you phrased it sounded fishy to me, and it made me think that if "Rose" exists that she is already part of a cult. This would also explain why she hasn't outed herself even though at this point there is no good reason for her not to do so.
:confused:
Me and her are mason together......
There is danger of outting her and if there wasn't she would have herself by now.
Kobe1724
08-04-2010, 11:21 PM
Don't read this if you haven't watched the video
If you give that above test to one person they may or may not spot the dancing bear the first time. But if an auditorium of people are watching that video together at once then someone seeing the bear the 1st time through is a forgone conclusion.
My point? In a game in which the goal is to spot the dancing bear, why would you instruct people in the auditorium not to share with others when they see the dancing bear? There is another auditorium full of people (scum) who are sharing with one another when they see the bear, and by not doing the same in your own auditorium you're handicapping your group.
Lecture/theory continued.
All of the hints in mafia (be they player hints, write up hints or night information) are their own miniature dancing bear events. People will notice various ones while missing others. And when they do notice them, people will interpret different events to mean different things when they observe them. As a result, the more takes/interpretations you get on an event the more likely you are to be able to parse something useful from the event as it pertains to winning the game.
But if a person that might have a unique insight on an event doesn't notice the event (because they were more focused on the guys passing the ball than looking for a dancing bear) then you've missed out on a valuable insight. The argument that you shouldn't point out the bear to people that missed it because then scum that may have missed it will then have the information as well is flawed logic.
The scum will always see the "dancing bears" because the scum are playing as a team an utilizing their collective intelligences and resources. Elitism and refusal to help other players interpret events that they may have missed or misunderstood only hurts the town.
Anyway, that's my two cents.
Max Peck
08-04-2010, 11:23 PM
Lecture/theory continued.
All of the hints in mafia (be they player hints, write up hints or night information) are their own miniature dancing bear events. People will notice various ones while missing others. And when they do notice them, people will interpret different events to mean different things when they observe them. As a result, the more takes/interpretations you get on an event the more likely you are to be able to parse something useful from the event as it pertains to winning the game.
But if a person that might have a unique insight on an event doesn't notice the event (because they were more focused on the guys passing the ball than looking for a dancing bear) then you've missed out on a valuable insight. The argument that you shouldn't point out the bear to people that missed it because then scum that may have missed it will then have the information as well is flawed logic.
The scum will always see the "dancing bears" because the scum are playing as a team an utilizing their collective intelligences and resources. Elitism and refusal to help other players interpret events that they may have missed or misunderstood only hurts the town.
Anyway, that's my two cents.
Or its the collective wisdom of your scum buddies, a la a ventriloquism act...
Paws7297
08-04-2010, 11:24 PM
Lecture/theory continued.
All of the hints in mafia (be they player hints, write up hints or night information) are their own miniature dancing bear events. People will notice various ones while missing others. And when they do notice them, people will interpret different events to mean different things when they observe them. As a result, the more takes/interpretations you get on an event the more likely you are to be able to parse something useful from the event as it pertains to winning the game.
But if a person that might have a unique insight on an event doesn't notice the event (because they were more focused on the guys passing the ball than looking for a dancing bear) then you've missed out on a valuable insight. The argument that you shouldn't point out the bear to people that missed it because then scum that may have missed it will then have the information as well is flawed logic.
The scum will always see the "dancing bears" because the scum are playing as a team an utilizing their collective intelligences and resources. Elitism and refusal to help other players interpret events that they may have missed or misunderstood only hurts the town.
Anyway, that's my two cents.
I'm not reading these.
Kobe1724
08-04-2010, 11:27 PM
:confused:
Me and her are mason together......
There is danger of outting her and if there wasn't she would have herself by now.
I'm trying to understand the danger.
Based on my understanding of the lover role, if one dies then the other commit suicide the following night. As such, in a Rose/Jack situation then Rose dying would see the same result for Jack.
The same holds true for Rose, however. If Jack dies then Rose dies.
The logic that: "Rose shouldn't reveal herself because that increases her odds of dying since then the scum know who both lovers are" is flawed. The scum only need one lover to kill both, and once the scum know who one is then the other has nothing to gain from hiding him/herself beyond trying to create doubt in their very existence.
This has the doubled edged sword of also creating doubt within the town, however. The town must simply take the word of a single half of a lover group claiming to be town under this scenario. If they do this without question, then it makes it an ideal claim for scum to make.
Kobe1724
08-04-2010, 11:28 PM
I'm not reading these.
I don't imagine you would.
Max Peck
08-04-2010, 11:29 PM
I'm trying to understand the danger.
Based on my understanding of the lover role, if one dies then the other commit suicide the following night. As such, in a Rose/Jack situation then Rose dying would see the same result for Jack.
The same holds true for Rose, however. If Jack dies then Rose dies.
The logic that: "Rose shouldn't reveal herself because that increases her odds of dying since then the scum know who both lovers are" is flawed. The scum only need one lover to kill both, and once the scum know who one is then the other has nothing to gain from hiding him/herself beyond trying to create doubt in their very existence.
This has the doubled edged sword of also creating doubt within the town, however. The town must simply take the word of a single half of a lover group claiming to be town under this scenario. If they do this without question, then it makes it an ideal claim for scum to make.
Suppose its not a sure thing the lover dies though. If it's random, which I think somebody has said before, killing jack wouldn't necessarily cause Rose to die, and would give the impetus to stay silent in this case.
Kobe1724
08-04-2010, 11:32 PM
Or its the collective wisdom of your scum buddies, a la a ventriloquism act...
Of course, the danger of group think is the biggest weakness scum have. The same wisdom that allows them to see all the angles can also get them bogged down in seeing things one way. It's a balancing act that good scum and town alike must navigate.
Kobe1724
08-04-2010, 11:34 PM
Suppose its not a sure thing the lover dies though. If it's random, which I think somebody has said before, killing jack wouldn't necessarily cause Rose to die, and would give the impetus to stay silent in this case.
How so? In either case, if the scums goal is to kill the two lovers (one bird, one stone) they don't need both Rose and Jack to do so. They only need one.
Paws7297
08-04-2010, 11:34 PM
If you'd have read peoples hints and informations tontheir characters you might know who she is.
Max Peck
08-04-2010, 11:36 PM
How so? In either case, if the scums goal is to kill the two lovers (one bird, one stone) they don't need both Rose and Jack to do so. They only need one.
Holy Cat, did you even READ what I said? Let me get the chalkboard and chalk out.
If its RANDOM that Rose kills herself if Jack dies, say its a 50/50 shot, that gives Rose a good reason to stay hidden, because even IF they kill Jack, she's got a 50% survival chance, vs a ZERO PERCENT chance if the scum know who both are.
Does that make sense now?
Paws7297
08-04-2010, 11:39 PM
Holy Cat, did you even READ what I said? Let me get the chalkboard and chalk out.
If its RANDOM that Rose kills herself if Jack dies, say its a 50/50 shot, that gives Rose a good reason to stay hidden, because even IF they kill Jack, she's got a 50% survival chance, vs a ZERO PERCENT chance if the scum know who both are.
Does that make sense now?
/nod
Kobe1724
08-04-2010, 11:40 PM
Likely Town:
Oliver
C-Bot
Kobe1724
Glotnot
Teh Showtime
Likely Scum:
Paws
MNN
BHK
Smart Bomb
RA
Max Peck
Ambiguous:
SuperOwens
Blue Star
Gabbo
I-mac
Jaded
Jman2k3
Inadvertant
No read/Ambivalent:
Max Peck
08-04-2010, 11:40 PM
Likely Town:
Oliver
C-Bot
Kobe1724
Glotnot
Teh Showtime
Likely Scum:
Paws
MNN
BHK
Smart Bomb
RA
Max Peck
Ambiguous:
SuperOwens
Blue Star
Gabbo
I-mac
Jaded
Jman2k3
Inadvertant
No read/Ambivalent:
Sweet, another list
Paws7297
08-04-2010, 11:42 PM
Likely Town:
Oliver
C-Bot
Kobe1724
Glotnot
Teh Showtime
Likely Scum:
Paws
MNN
BHK
Smart Bomb
RA
Max Peck
Ambiguous:
SuperOwens
Blue Star
Gabbo
I-mac
Jaded
Jman2k3
Inadvertant
No read/Ambivalent:
not this again
I had an adorable picture for this... Not on my dsi though :(
/facepaw
Kobe1724
08-04-2010, 11:44 PM
Holy Cat, did you even READ what I said? Let me get the chalkboard and chalk out.
If its RANDOM that Rose kills herself if Jack dies, say its a 50/50 shot, that gives Rose a good reason to stay hidden, because even IF they kill Jack, she's got a 50% survival chance, vs a ZERO PERCENT chance if the scum know who both are.
Does that make sense now?
Why do her odds of survival drop to 0 if scum know who she is?
The scum already know that she's town even if they don't know who her character is.
If they suddenly knew who Jack and Rose both were it still wouldn't change the fact that killing one of them resulted in a 50% survival rate.
Basically:
Scum know that person A is town (or at least not part of their scum group).
Scum know that person B is town (or at least not part of their scum group).
Person A is Rose
Person B is Jack
Scum know that person B is Jack.
If Jack dies then the probability that Rose will die is 50% (and vice versa).
If the scum want to kill Jack so that they can kill Rose then knowing that Rose is person A changes nothing for them. They already know that person A is not part of their scum group and plan to kill her eventually.
Olivier le Fou
08-04-2010, 11:45 PM
Hey all.
Just got back from work.
Saw the lynch.
Hopefully he was the one doing the recruiting now, so that they're set back another few nights, recruitment wise.
I'm just glad it worked out the way it did. A piece of my heart broke a little, by lynching James Bond. But the cult needs to be stopped from spreading.
"It's a little 'bloodthirsty." /Bond-esque Witticism
Though we've still got Bald Assasin running around, and that probably doesn't bode well for us... And the Corleone's should be able to kill again, unless they just happened to make Sweeney Todd/Tha Black Phenom their Don before I killed him (which would be hilarious), so I'm anticipating two night kills. And hopefully zero recruits.
Expect to see me kicking doors in and asking questions, again.
:cool:
Kobe1724
08-04-2010, 11:45 PM
^^ I tried to spell that out for you as simply as I could and without getting frustrated like I normally do when people can't understand simple things. Please reward my patience with understanding. :)
Max Peck
08-04-2010, 11:47 PM
Why do her odds of survival drop to 0 if scum know who she is?
The scum already know that she's town even if they don't know who her character is.
If they suddenly knew who Jack and Rose both were it still wouldn't change the fact that killing one of them resulted in a 50% survival rate.
Basically:
Scum know that person A is town (or at least not part of their scum group).
Scum know that person B is town (or at least not part of their scum group).
Person A is Rose
Person B is Jack
Scum know that person B is Jack.
If Jack dies then the probability that Rose will die is 50% (and vice versa).
If the scum want to kill Jack so that they can kill Rose then knowing that Rose is person A changes nothing for them. They already know that person A is not part of their scum group and plan to kill her eventually.
Sigh....
Look EVERYTHING you just said is true, however you ignore the fact that if the scum don't know who Rose is they CANNOT be sure to kill her with their kills....its a freaking crapshoot when they go to do a nightkill on her if they are gunning for her, what part of this don't you get? oh wait, all of it I forgot....
Seriously, reading comprehension is your friend....
Kobe1724
08-04-2010, 11:47 PM
Hey all.
Just got back from work.
Saw the lynch.
Hopefully he was the one doing the recruiting now, so that they're set back another few nights, recruitment wise.
I'm just glad it worked out the way it did. A piece of my heart broke a little, by lynching James Bond. But the cult needs to be stopped from spreading.
"It's a little 'bloodthirsty." /Bond-esque Witticism
Though we've still got Bald Assasin running around, and that probably doesn't bode well for us... And the Corleone's should be able to kill again, unless they just happened to make Sweeney Todd/Tha Black Phenom their Don before I killed him (which would be hilarious), so I'm anticipating two night kills. And hopefully zero recruits.
Expect to see me kicking doors in and asking questions, again.
:cool:
Good read btw.
Kobe1724
08-04-2010, 11:49 PM
Sigh....
Look EVERYTHING you just said is true, however you ignore the fact that if the scum don't know who Rose is they CANNOT be sure to kill her with their kills....its a freaking crapshoot when they go to do a nightkill on her if they are gunning for her, what part of this don't you get? oh wait, all of it I forgot....
Seriously, reading comprehension is your friend....
I'll try this another way:
The scum don't care about a freaking vanilla mason townie.
Their only interest in killing Rose would be that killing her would also kill Jack (A two for one kill). They don't need to know the identity of both lovers to do that, however. They just need the identity of one lover.
Paws7297
08-04-2010, 11:50 PM
Sigh....
Look EVERYTHING you just said is true, however you ignore the fact that if the scum don't know who Rose is they CANNOT be sure to kill her with their kills....its a freaking crapshoot when they go to do a nightkill on her if they are gunning for her, what part of this don't you get? oh wait, all of it I forgot....
Seriously, reading comprehension is your friend....
Obviously isn't her friend or it'd be helping her.
Max Peck
08-04-2010, 11:51 PM
I'll try this another way:
The scum don't care about a freaking vanilla mason townie.
Their only interest in killing Rose would be that killing her would also kill Jack (A two for one kill). They don't need to know the identity of both lovers to do that, however. They just need the identity of one lover.
Logical Fallacy in RED....How do you know Rose is a vanilla mason townie?
How do you know what Rose's ability is without her saying one freaking word on it.
If they know both, the scum would be well advised to take out both masons, just to be sure....like nuking something from orbit.....
Kobe1724
08-04-2010, 11:52 PM
Hmm, let me re-word it just in case.
1. The mafia want to kill townies.
2. Ideally they want to kill power townies.
3. They would also love to kill other townies, but power roles and vets/leaders are most important.
4. Their only interest in killing a vanilla townie like "Rose" over other more powerful townies would be they get a potential 2 for 1 in Jack.
5. But they can do that with the identity of just one lover (Jack). The scum have no reason to "gun for" Rose. What would be the purpose?
Max Peck
08-04-2010, 11:53 PM
Hmm, let me re-word it just in case.
1. The mafia want to kill townies.
2. Ideally they want to kill power townies.
3. They would also love to kill other townies, but power roles and vets/leaders are most important.
4. Their only interest in killing a vanilla townie like "Rose" over other more powerful townies would be they get a potential 2 for 1 in Jack.
5. But they can do that with the identity of just one lover (Jack). The scum have no reason to "gun for" Rose. What would be the purpose?
Again, you keep saying Rose is vanilla
How in the blue Hades do you know that 100% for sure?
You don't do you?
Kill em both is a sure way to make sure the mason group isn't a threat for ANY reason, if I was scum I would be looking for a sure play like that....
Kobe1724
08-04-2010, 11:55 PM
Logical Fallacy in RED....How do you know Rose is a vanilla mason townie?
How do you know what Rose's ability is without her saying one freaking word on it.
If they know both, the scum would be well advised to take out both masons, just to be sure....like nuking something from orbit.....
http://67.19.230.90/~arles/forum/showpost.php?p=1116203&postcount=3280
Reading comprehension Max? :)
Paws7297
08-04-2010, 11:55 PM
Hmm, let me re-word it just in case.
1. The mafia want to kill townies.
2. Ideally they want to kill power townies.
3. They would also love to kill other townies, but power roles and vets/leaders are most important.
4. Their only interest in killing a vanilla townie like "Rose" over other more powerful townies would be they get a potential 2 for 1 in Jack.
5. But they can do that with the identity of just one lover (Jack). The scum have no reason to "gun for" Rose. What would be the purpose?
:rolleyes:
If only you knew.
Kobe1724
08-04-2010, 11:56 PM
Again, you keep saying Rose is vanilla
How in the blue Hades do you know that 100% for sure?
You don't do you?
Kill em both is a sure way to make sure the mason group isn't a threat for ANY reason, if I was scum I would be looking for a sure play like that....
http://67.19.230.90/~arles/forum/showpost.php?p=1116203&postcount=3280
Here, I'll post it for you:
Quote:
Originally Posted by Jaded View Post
Paws - do you and/or Rose have any night ability?
No.
What was that about reading the topic and all that?
Kobe1724
08-04-2010, 11:58 PM
Seriously, Jaded asked:
Paws, do you or Rose have any night ability. Paws says no. Now she says:
:rolleyes:
If only you knew.
Surely she will elaborate?
Probability Paws is scum: 90%
Kobe1724
08-04-2010, 11:59 PM
:rolleyes:
If only you knew.
Btw Paws, do you remember when I said I would catch you if you were lying about your role?
:cool:
Olivier le Fou
08-04-2010, 11:59 PM
I guess the only thing I've got to say on this matter, before going to bed, is that Scum DO care about killing off Mason Members. In fact, they often top out the list of their targets.
Why?
Masons can confirm one another. Someone claiming a power role could very well be lying, and late enough in some games, there's no way to confirm they're telling the truth about who they are or what they do or who they're aligned with. Scum love working with those situations.
Masons know for sure, because they can talk outside the thread with one another. They know their partner's role-titles, they know their partners are town, and they know their partner's abilities.
The quicker scum can destroy a Mason/Partnership, the quicker the game can be turned into a "This person's lying, because the only person who can vouch for them is themselves." You're not giving enough credit to the fact that Masons/Partners are aware of each other, and can vouch for one another.
To say that the Mafia doesn't care about Masons, regardless of ability or lack thereof is just foolish.
Max Peck
08-05-2010, 12:00 AM
Kobe, honestly...you seem like a smart girl...but your real problem is you are too rigid in your thinking.
If I am hiding or attempting to hide from scum, who would be hunting for power roles, you think I would say "Oh yeah, I have a doozy of a night ability, I can kill/investigate/block" ???
Seriously, that would be the dumbest thing for Paws to do. Ok second dumbest, the dumbest would be outting Rose....
Paws7297
08-05-2010, 12:02 AM
I guess the only thing I've got to say on this matter, before going to bed, is that Scum DO care about killing off Mason Members. In fact, they often top out the list of their targets.
Why?
Masons can confirm one another. Someone claiming a power role could very well be lying, and late enough in some games, there's no way to confirm they're telling the truth about who they are or what they do or who they're aligned with. Scum love working with those situations.
Masons know for sure, because they can talk outside the thread with one another. They know their partner's role-titles, they know their partners are town, and they know their partner's abilities.
The quicker scum can destroy a Mason/Partnership, the quicker the game can be turned into a "This person's lying, because the only person who can vouch for them is themselves." You're not giving enough credit to the fact that Masons/Partners are aware of each other, and can vouch for one another.
To say that the Mafia doesn't care about Masons, regardless of ability or lack thereof is just foolish.
At least someone gets it.
Max Peck
08-05-2010, 12:03 AM
I guess the only thing I've got to say on this matter, before going to bed, is that Scum DO care about killing off Mason Members. In fact, they often top out the list of their targets.
Why?
Masons can confirm one another. Someone claiming a power role could very well be lying, and late enough in some games, there's no way to confirm they're telling the truth about who they are or what they do or who they're aligned with. Scum love working with those situations.
Masons know for sure, because they can talk outside the thread with one another. They know their partner's role-titles, they know their partners are town, and they know their partner's abilities.
The quicker scum can destroy a Mason/Partnership, the quicker the game can be turned into a "This person's lying, because the only person who can vouch for them is themselves." You're not giving enough credit to the fact that Masons/Partners are aware of each other, and can vouch for one another.
To say that the Mafia doesn't care about Masons, regardless of ability or lack thereof is just foolish.
This.
OLF gets it:D
Kobe1724
08-05-2010, 12:04 AM
I guess the only thing I've got to say on this matter, before going to bed, is that Scum DO care about killing off Mason Members. In fact, they often top out the list of their targets.
Why?
Masons can confirm one another. Someone claiming a power role could very well be lying, and late enough in some games, there's no way to confirm they're telling the truth about who they are or what they do or who they're aligned with. Scum love working with those situations.
Masons know for sure, because they can talk outside the thread with one another. They know their partner's role-titles, they know their partners are town, and they know their partner's abilities.
The quicker scum can destroy a Mason/Partnership, the quicker the game can be turned into a "This person's lying, because the only person who can vouch for them is themselves." You're not giving enough credit to the fact that Masons/Partners are aware of each other, and can vouch for one another.
To say that the Mafia doesn't care about Masons, regardless of ability or lack thereof is just foolish.
Actually, several times in this topic I've said that Paws has one of the most valuable roles in the game if she is in fact a mason because she can confirm her towness simply by having her partner confirm her. Of course, before she does that she isn't a confirmed townie and has nothing that she can point to in order to prove it. Seems like the ideal scum cover to me...
That said, I think it was a good post all things considered. Please read the past few pages, however. Paws seemed to imply that Rose has some sort of ability just now, but earlier said that she didn't.
Kobe1724
08-05-2010, 12:05 AM
Kobe, honestly...you seem like a smart girl...but your real problem is you are too rigid in your thinking.
If I am hiding or attempting to hide from scum, who would be hunting for power roles, you think I would say "Oh yeah, I have a doozy of a night ability, I can kill/investigate/block" ???
Seriously, that would be the dumbest thing for Paws to do. Ok second dumbest, the dumbest would be outting Rose....
Are you really going to overlook what I just posted?
Paws7297
08-05-2010, 12:06 AM
This.
OLF gets it:D
/nod
It's like the perfect explanation
Kobe1724
08-05-2010, 12:06 AM
Wait wait wait you aren't overlooking what I said at all:
Lynch all liars, remember?
Max Peck
08-05-2010, 12:07 AM
Are you really going to overlook what I just posted?
Overlook, no
Chalk it down at this time as Paws protecting herself from scum like you, yes.
You need to think outside the box, real life isn't lists and stats and probabilities.
Kobe1724
08-05-2010, 12:07 AM
Okay:
1. Paws is claiming mason. Nothing supports this.
2. Paws flat out said Rose or her had no night ability. Now she is saying that at least one of them do.
This is okay?
Max Peck
08-05-2010, 12:09 AM
Okay:
1. Paws is claiming mason. Nothing supports this.
2. Paws flat out said Rose or her had no night ability. Now she is saying that at least one of them do.
This is okay?
Lets flip it around
Paws is claiming mason. Nothing refutes this.
Kobe1724
08-05-2010, 12:10 AM
Overlook, no
Chalk it down at this time as Paws protecting herself from scum like you, yes.
You need to think outside the box, real life isn't lists and stats and probabilities.
Max, I'm disappointed in you.
That said, I'm sure that someone has to see an issue with Paws getting caught in a lie about her ability and/or "Roses" ability in light of the fact that their is no evidence supporting the existence of this Rose.
Even I'm aware of this lynch all liars thing you guys have going on, and frankly I'm probably the least interested person in traditional play that there is.
I'm curious to hear Oliver's thoughts on this.
Kobe1724
08-05-2010, 12:11 AM
Lets flip it around
Paws is claiming mason. Nothing refutes this.
Okay:
Paws is claiming mason. Nothing refutes this except that she apparently lied about the alleged ability of her fellow mason
Max Peck
08-05-2010, 12:12 AM
Max, I'm disappointed in you.
That said, I'm sure that someone has to see an issue with Paws getting caught in a lie about her ability and/or "Roses" ability in light of the fact that their is no evidence supporting the existence of this Rose.
Even I'm aware of this lynch all liars thing you guys have going on, and frankly I'm probably the least interested person in traditional play that there is.
I'm curious to hear Oliver's thoughts on this.
Hey you bring me proof, and I mean gold top, copper bottomed proof that Paws or anybody else is scum and I will get the rope faster than you can say boo....
You however haven't brought me anything that points to Paws being scum.
Max Peck
08-05-2010, 12:13 AM
Okay:
Paws is claiming mason. Nothing refutes this except that she apparently lied about the alleged ability of her fellow mason
Chop Logic grasshopper...
Lying isn't exclusively a scum tactic, nor is it 100% foolproof scum tell.
Kobe1724
08-05-2010, 12:14 AM
Max you're either scum badly miscalculating by hitching your wagon to Paws here, or else your ego is preventing you from acknowledging that regardless of your thoughts concerning me, there is something wrong with this claim of hers/this situation.
Kobe1724
08-05-2010, 12:14 AM
Chop Logic grasshopper...
Lying isn't exclusively a scum tactic, nor is it 100% foolproof scum tell.
Let me try this another way:
Why do you believe Paws's claim?
Kobe1724
08-05-2010, 12:15 AM
I really want to hear Jaded and Oliver's thoughts on this sequence of events.
Kobe1724
08-05-2010, 12:16 AM
Likely Scum (Most to least likely):
Paws
MNN
BHK
Smart Bomb
Max Peck
RA
Max Peck
08-05-2010, 12:18 AM
Likely Scum (Most to least likely):
Paws
MNN
BHK
Smart Bomb
Max Peck
RA
And again with a list....
As to why I think Paws is telling the truth....do you play poker Kobe?....do you know how to read a situation?
My RL job requires me to assess situations all the time, some that may have repercussions on my continued breathing.
Kobe1724
08-05-2010, 12:22 AM
And again with a list....
As to why I think Paws is telling the truth....do you play poker Kobe?....do you know how to read a situation?
My RL job requires me to assess situations all the time, some that may have repercussions on my continued breathing.
I'm a very, very good poker player, actually (I've made more than 25k playing). :cool:
Max, I have to admit that your rationale here is not compelling given your issues with me "playing from the gut" and "using my intuition".
More importantly, though, there will be some serious egg on face action going on with one of us in the near future.
Finally, I would say that if you're scum I would recommend you kill me tonight. If you don't, I will definitely have nailed Paws and you by the end of phase 7.
Olivier le Fou
08-05-2010, 12:23 AM
I'm curious to hear Oliver's thoughts on this.
My thoughts?
I believe the claim. A game this size is bound to have Lovers. Especially because the game is 'Movie' Themed.
Paws/Jack is Town.
Whoever Rose is, is Town, unless she was recruited into the Vampire Cult on Night Five.
They're Lovers.
Let's not out Rose. If scum were interested in taking the gamble of killing off two lover roles by hoping they're suicidal, Jack'd be dead. They're obviously waiting for Rose to surface. Once they know both members of the partnership, they'll be able to work around it, instead of taking the gamble of going through it.
As for the abilities 'lie' you've found Paws in? I had no idea she claimed both of them were vanilla. I could have sworn at some point in time, she was very open that one of them had an ability. Though, if you quote the post where Paws claimed they were both vanilla, there'd be a little bit more to your argument. Though even then, if Paws is a Suicidal Lover Role with whoeveer Rose is, faking not having an ability would have probably been ideal at the time.
Anything to avoid scum's nightkill. Though again, not sure Paws ever blatantly said both her and Rose were vanilla's.
At this point though, the only person they need to be wary of, is the Bald Assasin. He has more to gain from the '2 for 1' Kill, than the Corleone Family do, at this point. They're shrinking too fast.
My last thought? I'm ready for bed. Hope Glot decides to use his silence, tonight. Only to prove his ability. And maybe quiet the game thread up, a bit. I'm still not a huge advocate for your lists. If Glot silenced you, you'd be helping the town by proving he's not lying about his ability. Heh, that's equally, if not more, helpful than your consistant lists.
;)
Kobe1724
08-05-2010, 12:25 AM
I'm just thinking back over this entire game...
If Paws comes up scum (and she likely will) it will be my favorite/proudest mafia moment ever.
If Max also comes up scum I'll be so happy I might not finish the game. ^_^
Paws7297
08-05-2010, 12:25 AM
I'm a very, very good poker player, actually (I've made more than 25k playing). :cool:
Max, I have to admit that your rationale here is not compelling given your issues with me "playing from the gut" and "using my intuition".
More importantly, though, there will be some serious egg on face action going on with one of us in the near future.
Finally, I would say that if you're scum I would recommend you kill me tonight. If you don't, I will definitely have nailed Paws and you by the end of phase 7.
Nah. I think, when I come up town, that will make you scum and Max Peck town. You'd be lynched directly after.
Max Peck
08-05-2010, 12:26 AM
I'm a very, very good poker player, actually (I've made more than 25k playing). :cool:
Max, I have to admit that your rationale here is not compelling given your issues with me "playing from the gut" and "using my intuition".
More importantly, though, there will be some serious egg on face action going on with one of us in the near future.
Finally, I would say that if you're scum I would recommend you kill me tonight. If you don't, I will definitely have nailed Paws and you by the end of phase 7.
If I am wrong I am wrong. I am man enough to admit when it happens and admit that it could happen again.
And I don't think you are playing from the gut, although it is connected to the body part that I think your lists come from....
Kobe1724
08-05-2010, 12:29 AM
My thoughts?
I believe the claim. A game this size is bound to have Lovers. Especially because the game is 'Movie' Themed.
Paws/Jack is Town.
Whoever Rose is, is Town, unless she was recruited into the Vampire Cult on Night Five.
They're Lovers.
Let's not out Rose. If scum were interested in taking the gamble of killing off two lover roles by hoping they're suicidal, Jack'd be dead. They're obviously waiting for Rose to surface. Once they know both members of the partnership, they'll be able to work around it, instead of taking the gamble of going through it.
As for the abilities 'lie' you've found Paws in? I had no idea she claimed both of them were vanilla. I could have sworn at some point in time, she was very open that one of them had an ability. Though, if you quote the post where Paws claimed they were both vanilla, there'd be a little bit more to your argument. Though even then, if Paws is a Suicidal Lover Role with whoeveer Rose is, faking not having an ability would have probably been ideal at the time.
Anything to avoid scum's nightkill. Though again, not sure Paws ever blatantly said both her and Rose were vanilla's.
At this point though, the only person they need to be wary of, is the Bald Assasin. He has more to gain from the '2 for 1' Kill, than the Corleone Family do, at this point. They're shrinking too fast.
My last thought? I'm ready for bed. Hope Glot decides to use his silence, tonight. Only to prove his ability. And maybe quiet the game thread up, a bit. I'm still not a huge advocate for your lists. If Glot silenced you, you'd be helping the town by proving he's not lying about his ability. Heh, that's equally, if not more, helpful than your consistant lists.
;)
I wanted your assessment so I could gauge how trustworthy you are as town. You've been the person I've considered most likely to be town so far, but now I'll need to reassess that given your response.
http://67.19.230.90/~arles/forum/showpost.php?p=1116203&postcount=3280
Where Paws claims that neither has an ability. A blatant lie given her comments tonight.
Btw, you're nowhere near good enough to be taking the constant pot shots at me that you have this game. I've ignored it up until now, but it needs to stop. :)
Paws7297
08-05-2010, 12:30 AM
Max I'm trying not to laugh at that. ^^
Kobe when I come up town will it be your most embarassing mafia moment ever?
Kobe1724
08-05-2010, 12:30 AM
If I am wrong I am wrong. I am man enough to admit when it happens and admit that it could happen again.
And I don't think you are playing from the gut, although it is connected to the body part that I think your lists come from....
We'll see how good my list are at the end of the game. :cool:
Props on the bolded part btw.
Olivier le Fou
08-05-2010, 12:31 AM
Oh, one more thing I feel that it's important I say;
I do think that Kobe is town.
I just think she's in over her head, and trying too hard to lead something.
I'd have no intentions of lynching her, because she's trying so hard to get Paws to out Rose.
Her methods are wrong. But her intentions are there, and they're good intentions.
Just think she should tone things down, a bit.
Max Peck
08-05-2010, 12:31 AM
Max I'm trying not to laugh at that. ^^
Kobe when I come up town will it be your most embarassing mafia moment ever?
Yeah it was pretty funny....
Notice how she has to "reassess" OLF because he disagrees with her?
Kobe1724
08-05-2010, 12:32 AM
Max I'm trying not to laugh at that. ^^
Kobe when I come up town will it be your most embarassing mafia moment ever?
No. It would have been but having caught you in a lie while I'll feel terrible about it it's actually reached the point where anyone reasonable would assume you were lying at this point. :cool:
If I go 0 or 1 for 5 on my current list though I'll be incredibly embarrassed. I'll probably disappear for a long time. :o
Paws7297
08-05-2010, 12:32 AM
I wanted your assessment so I could gauge how trustworthy you are as town. You've been the person I've considered most likely to be town so far, but now I'll need to reassess that given your response.
http://67.19.230.90/~arles/forum/showpost.php?p=1116203&postcount=3280
Where Paws claims that neither has an ability. A blatant lie given her comments tonight.
Btw, you're nowhere near good enough to be taking the constant pot shots at me that you have this game. I've ignored it up until now, but it needs to stop. :)
O le F has killed two scum and given us a vamp. If you think him thinking I am town is scummy, you best get help with these games.
Kobe1724
08-05-2010, 12:33 AM
Yeah it was pretty funny....
Notice how she has to "reassess" OLF because he disagrees with her?
To be fair to OLF, he seemed to have missed the part where Paws lied when he first posted that. Given his accuracy this game, I'm wondering what his assessment of that is.
Kobe1724
08-05-2010, 12:34 AM
O le F has killed two scum and given us a vamp. If you think him thinking I am town is scummy, you best get help with these games.
Again, he's played well this game. But he's nowhere near good enough for me to continue to take his insults. If he was Derek_b or something, maybe... but then again players that good don't tend to denigrate others. ^_^
Paws7297
08-05-2010, 12:36 AM
No. It would have been but having caught you in a lie while I'll feel terrible about it it's actually reached the point where anyone reasonable would assume you were lying at this point. :cool:
If I go 0 or 1 for 5 on my current list though I'll be incredibly embarrassed. I'll probably disappear for a long time. :o
Good bye in advance then.
Kobe1724
08-05-2010, 12:37 AM
You'll notice I'm no longer asking for your assessment Paws. I finally have everything I need from you, and so will no longer be asking you any questions this game. :cool:
Kobe1724
08-05-2010, 12:37 AM
Good bye in advance then.
:):)
Paws7297
08-05-2010, 12:38 AM
You'll notice I'm no longer asking for your assessment Paws. I finally have everything I need from you, and so will no longer be asking you any questions this game. :cool:
So you've realized I am true blue, town then?
Olivier le Fou
08-05-2010, 12:40 AM
Two more things, actually. Then I'm off to bed for real, this time.
Kobe, the post you linked me to has Paws saying neither Jack nor Rose have an active night ability.
I didn't have them down for an active night ability.
Unless Paws has now suddenly said that one of them has an active night ability, Paws wasn't technically lying.
And you're telling me that I need to stop with the potshots?
Didn't you say the point of your constant list posting is to get under the skin of those you're after? You can troll with your lists, but I can't take potshots? Your lists recently haven't really gotten us anything, yet. So is it really an insult to say that they haven't really helped the town? That sounds more like the truth, to me.
Not that I could even call them potshots. If I wanted to really slander you, I would have. I've said it before, and I'll say it again. I don't like your lists. They're under my skin, and you think I'm among one of the most likely to be town people here.
With that, I'm off to bed. Kobe, if you don't want the 'insults', don't ask for my thoughts, next time.
*Closes Laptop, Opens Window, And Sleeps.*
Kobe1724
08-05-2010, 12:40 AM
So you've realized I am true blue, town then?
:o .
Kobe1724
08-05-2010, 12:45 AM
Two more things, actually. Then I'm off to bed for real, this time.
Kobe, the post you linked me to has Paws saying neither Jack nor Rose have an active night ability.
I didn't have them down for an active night ability.
Unless Paws has now suddenly said that one of them has an active night ability, Paws wasn't technically lying.
http://67.19.230.90/~arles/forum/showpost.php?p=1118639&postcount=4057
Beyond that, though I'm more fascinated by the fact that both Max and Paws seem to recognize that it's a lie. It makes me wonder if they're together, somehow.
And you're telling me that I need to stop with the potshots?
Didn't you say the point of your constant list posting is to get under the skin of those you're after? You can troll with your lists, but I can't take potshots? Your lists recently haven't really gotten us anything, yet. So is it really an insult to say that they haven't really helped the town? That sounds more like the truth, to me.
I'd say that my general posting style is designed to get under skin/ruffle feathers. While I acknowledge my list get under some people's skin, one of their purposes is actually information sharing.
My list haven't helped the town because no one is using them. Both Astil and hellshock were on them, and they were town harming indy's. I'm giving good information, but very few people are using it.
Not that I could even call them potshots. If I wanted to really slander you, I would have. I've said it before, and I'll say it again. I don't like your lists. They're under my skin, and you think I'm among one of the most likely to be town people here.
With that, I'm off to bed. Kobe, if you don't want the 'insults', don't ask for my thoughts, next time.
*Closes Laptop, Opens Window, And Sleeps.*
Their is criticism, and then there is constructive criticism. Dish it out however you please, but I give as good as I get.
That's all. :)
Max Peck
08-05-2010, 12:45 AM
Personally Kobe, I don't dislike you. Your playstyle is somewhat annoying, and will most likely keep getting you potshots.
That being said, I hope instead of just taking your ball and going home if you are wrong, you use this as an impetus to up your playstyle.
When one person tells you something, its an opinion.
When a half dozen say the same thing about you, it's a fact.
Paws7297
08-05-2010, 12:49 AM
Personally Kobe, I don't dislike you. Your playstyle is somewhat annoying, and will most likely keep getting you potshots.
That being said, I hope instead of just taking your ball and going home if you are wrong, you use this as an impetus to up your playstyle.
When one person tells you something, its an opinion.
When a half dozen say the same thing about you, it's a fact.
Awww Kobe thinks you're my Rose :o
Kobe1724
08-05-2010, 12:50 AM
Personally Kobe, I don't dislike you. Your playstyle is somewhat annoying, and will most likely keep getting you potshots.
That being said, I hope instead of just taking your ball and going home if you are wrong, you use this as an impetus to up your playstyle.
When one person tells you something, its an opinion.
When a half dozen say the same thing about you, it's a fact.
I think my play style is probably a bit annoying. Hard to debate. :p
Where I disagree with others is on its efficacy. I've read a lot of games where the town lost precisely because they didn't bring enough aggressiveness to games. I think relying on night actions to catch scum is a terrible idea. Most players do that. They are good players and understand how to use the night to their advantage very well.
But they're missing half the game.
Kobe1724
08-05-2010, 12:51 AM
Awww Kobe thinks you're my Rose :o
Still playing that "Rose" card?
Cute. :)
Max Peck
08-05-2010, 12:52 AM
Awww Kobe thinks you're my Rose :o
If I told her I was Rose, would she be quiet about it?:p
Paws7297
08-05-2010, 12:53 AM
If I told her I was Rose, would she be quiet about it?:p
lol probaby not.
Kobe1724
08-05-2010, 12:53 AM
If I told her I was Rose, would she be quiet about it?:p
Oh my gosh I wish I was a vig so much right now. :cool:
Max Peck
08-05-2010, 12:54 AM
I think my play style is probably a bit annoying. Hard to debate. :p
Where I disagree with others is on its efficacy. I've read a lot of games where the town lost precisely because they didn't bring enough aggressiveness to games. I think relying on night actions to catch scum is a terrible idea. Most players do that. They are good players and understand how to use the night to their advantage very well.
But they're missing half the game.
This is true I suppose. I just wouldn't take anything said in the game thread personally. I don't care how sideways or upside down you come at me, at the end of the day if you played to win its all good, lets go get a beer.
Kobe1724
08-05-2010, 12:54 AM
lol probaby not.
Of course I wouldn't, he's already claimed Dr. Kimble silly. :rolleyes:
Max Peck
08-05-2010, 12:54 AM
This is true I suppose. I just wouldn't take anything said in the game thread personally. I don't care how sideways or upside down you come at me, at the end of the day if you played to win its all good, lets go get a beer.
Or a soda in Paws case:p
Paws7297
08-05-2010, 12:56 AM
This is true I suppose. I just wouldn't take anything said in the game thread personally. I don't care how sideways or upside down you come at me, at the end of the day if you played to win its all good, lets go get a beer.
But.... but.... I'm too young! Let's get some soda and crabs :cool:
Yea I just play for fun. Everything I say for the most part isn't serios I don't not like you Kobe.
Kobe1724
08-05-2010, 12:57 AM
This is true I suppose. I just wouldn't take anything said in the game thread personally. I don't care how sideways or upside down you come at me, at the end of the day if you played to win its all good, lets go get a beer.
I'm not just like this in mafia. :cool:
In pretty much any competitive game I turn it upside down, sideways etc. and try and approach it differently with the idea that I can gain an edge by seeing things in a different light than others.
That said, I'm used to ruffling feathers and getting a little heated during games of any sort, but I leave it with the game so yeah, I can feel you there. :)
Kobe1724
08-05-2010, 12:58 AM
Good night everyone. :)
My current list:
Likely Town:
Oliver
C-Bot
Kobe1724
Glotnot
Teh Showtime
Likely Scum:
Paws
MNN
BHK
Smart Bomb
RA
Max Peck
Ambiguous:
SuperOwens
Blue Star
Gabbo
I-mac
Jaded
Jman2k3
Inadvertant
No read/Ambivalent:
Paws7297
08-05-2010, 12:59 AM
But.... but.... I'm too young! Let's get some soda and crabs :cool:
Yea I just play for fun. Everything I say for the most part isn't serios I don't not like you Kobe.
Serious not Serios.... I happened to be thinking about spanish at the time.
Paws7297
08-05-2010, 01:08 AM
Am out for 6 hourse. tired. good night.
SmartBomb
08-05-2010, 02:22 AM
Okay I thought he claimed both. Nevermind...:o
Lol, a milling 50/50 nexus. Doesn't make sense.
And to anyone who says that my roletitle sucks, I tell you this: What exactly is a roletitle?
If you want it, of course, this is how it's set out in the PM.
Clark Griswold, Good Aligned Clumsy Fool
(National Lampoon's Vacation)
But roletitle = the part at the top. Part at bottom = extra bit if you've never heard of him (I haven't, had to youtube him before the game started.)
That's how I thought it, and left the bottom bit out.
Glot, I wasn't kidding.
Now everyone, shut up, it's night phase. The next person to talk will get lynched.
BHK1978
08-05-2010, 02:54 AM
Lol, a milling 50/50 nexus. Doesn't make sense.
Yeah I thougt someone else (besides Destiny) said they were a miller and for some reason I thought it was you. I should have just read your posts first and then posted. So I am sorry about that.
Gabbo
08-05-2010, 07:57 AM
COME ON! Nice one, OLF! :)
And I felt bad for voting on Rev! Great catch OLF!
and Gabbo, I was pushing for Rev to be lynched big time. :(
You want the next culty? C-bot.
Regardless of that it has to be between C-bot and Owens for lynch tomorrow anyway, in my eyes at least.
Hopefully he was the one doing the recruiting now, so that they're set back another few nights, recruitment wise.
:cool:
He probably wasn't. Not least because the write-up doesn't make any mention of it, well there's something you could construe as ending the vampires but it's a Hell of a stretch.
I'd say that my general posting style is designed to get under skin/ruffle feathers. While I acknowledge my list get under some people's skin, one of their purposes is actually information sharing.
My list haven't helped the town because no one is using them. Both Astil and hellshock were on them, and they were town harming indy's. I'm giving good information, but very few people are using it.
I don't want to sound condescending but I'm thought of pretty highly around here and your playstyle baffles me as I'm sure it does others. I've let you post what you want for a while because I know your intentions are good, but the way you couple it up with blinding arrogance is really unbecoming. You seem to believe you've reinvented mafia playing and you haven't, you just don't understand the errors of what you're doing.
I don't want to have a go at you, because you seem a nice person with wells of enthusiasm. But maybe tone it down and understand a good mafia player shows only what they have to show not what they have.
I've read a lot of games where the town lost precisely because they didn't bring enough aggressiveness to games. I think relying on night actions to catch scum is a terrible idea. Most players do that. They are good players and understand how to use the night to their advantage very well.
But they're missing half the game.
Go read Star Wars Mafia 3 for the blueprint on how town should play. They ripped through the scum with ease, a big scum team full of 'great' players all without lists upon lists, faux-investigations and spelling everything out in thread. :)
Jaded
08-05-2010, 08:08 AM
Go read Star Wars Mafia 3 for the blueprint on how town should play. They ripped through the scum with ease, a big scum team full of 'great' players all without lists upon lists, faux-investigations and spelling everything out in thread. :)
Agreed - as scum in SWM3, that was painful. We had some incredible players on our team and town just murdered us (without even a mislynch, IIRC?)
Gabbo
08-05-2010, 08:28 AM
I think so, we came close though. People pushed for Destiny to be lynched, but myself and Shape fought his corner.
Bless him, 'ol Desters.
SuperOwens
08-05-2010, 08:34 AM
I think so, we came close though. People pushed for Destiny to be lynched, but myself and Shape fought his corner.
Bless him, 'ol Desters.
So, for the third time of asking ;)
Have you been going out at night?
Gabbo
08-05-2010, 08:38 AM
Answered it, no I haven't.
My role depends more on what happens to me than what I do, in order to 'activate' something else.
SuperOwens
08-05-2010, 08:43 AM
Answered it, no I haven't.
My role depends more on what happens to me than what I do, in order to 'activate' something else.
So, something we can help you out with?
Olivier le Fou
08-05-2010, 10:12 AM
So, I was reading through the Night Phase Two Write-Up, when I re-realized something. I don't think there was technically a recruit on Night Two. There were two deaths in the write-up, belonging to MLT, and The Shape. MLT was frozen earlier on, by someone with Dialouge matching that of Shape's Dr. Evil, and then splashed/killed by The Two's Judge Doom, but the only other part of the write-up that shows anything kill-worthy is the Bald Assasin and his blades. Obviously though, as the write-up says, the assasin was fought off by a masked man, saving his intended target. So where did The Shape die? I think Masterded targetted him for a recruitment, but since he was scum, Shape died. Usually, the Cult Leader dies when he targets Scum, but I guess in the overall flavor of the game, Dr. Evil VS Supreme Vampire, the vamp's going to win every time. So unless the Vampire Cult started the game with two members, the only other member we should have left is the female recruited on Night Five (Comradebot, SuperOwens, or RebelliousAngel). With the way this last Day Phase went, I'd still say SuperOwens is our best bet. But it's obviously still something we'll need to look a little deeper and more thorough into, before reaching any hasty decisions. Let's just hope Masterded didn't start the game with a Minion/Back-Up Recruiter Vampire, or we can expect the cult to continue to grow until we find him/her.
I'd say there's probably only two or three Corleone Family Members left, hopefully only one more Vampire, and that damned 'Agent 47' Indy. That'd put us at, or around, a [3 VS 1 VS 1 VS 13 Set-Up]. If both of the expected night kills (Corleone's and Assasin's) go through, we'll likely be at a [3 VS 1 VS 1 VS 11 Set-Up], which isn't too bad of a position to be in. But again, that's hoping that the Vampire Cult didn't start with two members right off the bat, and that there weren't more than six people in the Corleone Family Alignment, too. If that turns out to be the case, though, we'll have our work even more cut out for us. We'll just say that things could certainly have been worse. We're in fairly good shape, still.
And just out of curiosity, but did we ever figure out the whole MichiganHero/Destiny/Jman2k3/Midnightnick debacle from Night Three? You know, the one where MichiganHero was killed by the person they chose to hide behind, that the Tracker/Watcher seemed to think was Destiny, but then the Bus Driver/Jman told us that he had been switched with Midnightnick, who's a proven alignment cop in it's most literal form? Did we ever figure out how in the bloody world MichiganHero got killed, in all of this?
Jaded
08-05-2010, 10:51 AM
And just out of curiosity, but did we ever figure out the whole MichiganHero/Destiny/Jman2k3/Midnightnick debacle from Night Three? You know, the one where MichiganHero was killed by the person they chose to hide behind, that the Tracker/Watcher seemed to think was Destiny, but then the Bus Driver/Jman told us that he had been switched with Midnightnick, who's a proven alignment cop in it's most literal form? Did we ever figure out how in the bloody world MichiganHero got killed, in all of this?
Nope. I still think MNN is scum (he COULD be scum with that ability, yeah?) but we went after rev instead last phase. (Not that I'm complaining with the result we got!)
Olivier le Fou
08-05-2010, 10:59 AM
Nope. I still think MNN is scum (he COULD be scum with that ability, yeah?) but we went after rev instead last phase. (Not that I'm complaining with the result we got!)
Well, you can technically be scum with any ability, no doubt.
But that's a huge stretch.
What use do Scum have, for a specific Alignment Cop? Haha, they know they're all scum, and I find it hard to believe that scum are going to go out of their way to find the Indy's or Cult Members. They have to outnumber, in most cases. Alignment often means very little, to them.
The only way MNN is Scum, is if the mod gave the scum group a pure alignment cop, (Actual Word For Word Alignment VS Threat/Non-Threat) to be a brilliant distraction/cover. But that's waaay too unlikely in my books. Just seems broken. His character's a breaker of the fourth wall. The ability fits with the flavor. I just don't know how MichiganHero ended up dead, after the dust settled...
Only soloution I've got? MNN is a Mafia Thief Role. He can only use his investigation every other day, because on the off nights, he has to retarget someone, and steal their alignment investigation ability. That'd solve his true results, his every other day ability, and why MichiganHero died when hiding behind him. But this too's a stretch. I just have a hard time seeing him as Scum. If he is scum, he's playing a good game. If not, he's getting caught up in some bad circumstances.
SuperOwens
08-05-2010, 11:06 AM
Nope. I still think MNN is scum (he COULD be scum with that ability, yeah?) but we went after rev instead last phase. (Not that I'm complaining with the result we got!)
But Inda saw MH target Destiny did he not? So either Inda is lying or our mod has allowed bus driving to affect a trackers results.
dont you find it strange that Inda has gone quiet, I mean where did he go?
Also, Gabbo is scum. Im 87% sure of it now.
SuperOwens
08-05-2010, 11:08 AM
Well, you can technically be scum with any ability, no doubt.
But that's a huge stretch.
What use do Scum have, for a specific Alignment Cop? Haha, they know they're all scum, and I find it hard to believe that scum are going to go out of their way to find the Indy's or Cult Members. They have to outnumber, in most cases. Alignment often means very little, to them.
The only way MNN is Scum, is if the mod gave the scum group a pure alignment cop, (Actual Word For Word Alignment VS Threat/Non-Threat) to be a brilliant distraction/cover. But that's waaay too unlikely in my books. Just seems broken. His character's a breaker of the fourth wall. The ability fits with the flavor. I just don't know how MichiganHero ended up dead, after the dust settled...
Only soloution I've got? MNN is a Mafia Thief Role. He can only use his investigation every other day, because on the off nights, he has to retarget someone, and steal their alignment investigation ability. That'd solve his true results, his every other day ability, and why MichiganHero died when hiding behind him. But this too's a stretch. I just have a hard time seeing him as Scum. If he is scum, he's playing a good game. If not, he's getting caught up in some bad circumstances.
A role cop (read alignment cop) is a traditionally scum role. This has been said many times in this thread. We had one in the last game, iot was MJ. He was scum.
Olivier le Fou
08-05-2010, 11:10 AM
Last time I checked, a Role Cop works with abilities though.
MNN is an Alignment Cop, no?
If MNN is getting their word for word alignment, rather than what it is that they're ability is, that's obviously too seperate things.
Unless you folks do things WAAY differently over here on GDS.
Scum have a lot of use finding out people's abilities. But having a cop that searches alignments? Definitely not as much use, to them.
Paws7297
08-05-2010, 11:13 AM
Last time I checked, a Role Cop works with abilities though.
MNN is an Alignment Cop, no?
If MNN is getting their word for word alignment, rather than what it is that they're ability is, that's obviously too seperate things.
Unless you folks do things WAAY differently over here on GDS.
Scum have a lot of use finding out people's abilities. But having a cop that searches alignments? Definitely not as much use, to them.
It helps them if they are trying to get rid of vampires or prove they're town. If MNN finds red scum I'll believe him.
Rebelliousangel
08-05-2010, 11:17 AM
Likely Town:
Oliver
C-Bot
Kobe1724
Glotnot
Teh Showtime
Likely Scum:
Paws
MNN
BHK
Smart Bomb
RA
Max Peck
Ambiguous:
SuperOwens
Blue Star
Gabbo
I-mac
Jaded
Jman2k3
Inadvertant
No read/Ambivalent:
Hmm, let me re-word it just in case.
1. The mafia want to kill townies.
2. Ideally they want to kill power townies.
3. They would also love to kill other townies, but power roles and vets/leaders are most important.
4. Their only interest in killing a vanilla townie like "Rose" over other more powerful townies would be they get a potential 2 for 1 in Jack.
5. But they can do that with the identity of just one lover (Jack). The scum have no reason to "gun for" Rose. What would be the purpose?
But Inda saw MH target Destiny did he not? So either Inda is lying or our mod has allowed bus driving to affect a trackers results.
dont you find it strange that Inda has gone quiet, I mean where did he go?
Also, Gabbo is scum. Im 87% sure of it now.
I'm 98% sure someone won't understand half this post. Or at least one sentence of it. :p
SuperOwens
08-05-2010, 11:17 AM
Last time I checked, a Role Cop works with abilities though.
MNN is an Alignment Cop, no?
If MNN is getting their word for word alignment, rather than what it is that they're ability is, that's obviously too seperate things.
Unless you folks do things WAAY differently over here on GDS.
Scum have a lot of use finding out people's abilities. But having a cop that searches alignments? Definitely not as much use, to them.
Nah mate. He gets role title.
So he got Masterded as Vampire Cult Aligned Supreme Vampire
Take that looking at a townie it would be Good Aligned Streetwise Cop
Very useful for scum
Paws7297
08-05-2010, 11:20 AM
Nah mate. He gets role title.
So he got Masterded as Vampire Cult Aligned Supreme Vampire
Take that looking at a townie it would be Good Aligned Streetwise Cop
Very useful for scum
I just realized that......
yea I really think he's scum. I also think Jman was telling the truth meaning, MH died because MNN is scum.
SuperOwens
08-05-2010, 11:26 AM
I just realized that......
yea I really think he's scum. I also think Jman was telling the truth meaning, MH died because MNN is scum.
I should clarify this, as I was typing in a hurry.
MNN has told us he only gets alignment. But if you were a scum role cop you would say that.
Im not convinced MNN is scum - simply because of Inda. The guy hasnt posted for 6 days and its on his word that we thought MH targeted Destiny
We now know that MNN and Destiny were switched. How then did MH end up at Destiny? He didnt.
Olivier le Fou
08-05-2010, 11:26 AM
I stand corrected.
I just looked at the GDS Terms Thread, and you guys went deeper into the Role Cop Ability than I think Neo has ever really cared to have gone. Or at least the Role Cop Roles I've had, or worked with, anyway.
I'm used to the whole 'Getting information on target's ability' or telling physical description of the target and what they're doing, but actually going as far as to get Role-Titles or Alignments? That was either done before I started playing over there, or I just haven't come in to contact with any of the roles, like that.
If the GDS Role-Cops typically have an ability that links directly to role-titles, then yes, I'd say the chances of MNN being scum just raised, significantly. Role-Titles would be definitely helpful for scum to receive, as it may have also hinted at their target's ability. Just can't get over the fact of how bad I was thrown off by you continuing to refer to him as a Role Cop. Turns out, that's technically the correct term over here, on GDS.
Jaded
08-05-2010, 11:30 AM
Inda's disappearance looks BAD, but his character's all but confirmed as being in the write-ups and there's zero chance of the character being scum - recruited?!
Jaded
08-05-2010, 11:30 AM
Inda's disappearance looks BAD, but his character's all but confirmed as being in the write-ups and there's zero chance of the character being scum - recruited?!
Which doesn't fit with OLF's 'only 2 recruitments' theory, which is starting to win me over...
Hmmm...
Olivier le Fou
08-05-2010, 11:37 AM
Yeah, I'm with you on Inadvertant being clean.
He hinted at "Outback Steak House" in the earlier phases. His write-up appearances have him with an Australian Accent, and wearing a Hat. His tracking ability is fitting for his character.
And, if he was making up his results, what were the odds of him saying that MH hid behind Destiny, and Destiny having been one of the targets switched around by Jman/The Bus Driver?
Something's obviously fishy there.
But I don't think it's Inadvertant or his results.
And yeah, Jaded, it took me a couple of read throughs, but I can't find anywhere else where Shape could have died in that Night Two Write-Up, so I'm fairly certain that there wasn't a Vampire Cult Recruit, on Night Two. I mean, it's a fairly plausible theory.
SuperOwens
08-05-2010, 11:38 AM
Inda's disappearance looks BAD, but his character's all but confirmed as being in the write-ups and there's zero chance of the character being scum - recruited?!
Yep, why I trusted him a lot to start off with.
To be honest, its a situation that's down to mod preference. Taker may have decided that bus driving would interfere in tracker results. If that's the case, MNN looks tied on scum
Paws7297
08-05-2010, 11:40 AM
Yep, why I trusted him a lot to start off with.
To be honest, its a situation that's down to mod preference. Taker may have decided that bus driving would interfere in tracker results. If that's the case, MNN looks tied on scum
/nod
SuperOwens
08-05-2010, 11:47 AM
And Gabbo. He's scum as well
Paws7297
08-05-2010, 11:47 AM
And Gabbo. He's scum as well
I Think Gabbo killed MLT. Just sayin'
Rebelliousangel
08-05-2010, 11:51 AM
I Think Gabbo killed MLT. Just sayin'
/nod...Oh what's that you weren't asking me. Sorry. :p
Olivier le Fou
08-05-2010, 11:51 AM
Heh, and so the question beckons...
"Next Day Phase, Who Do We Want To Look In To, Most?"
Our Formal Attired Assasin...
Our [Hopefully] Last Vampire...
Our Now-Likely Mafia Role Cop...
There are a few more avenues, I'm sure, but those appear to now be the big three.
Personally, I'd rank finding Bald Killer as my biggest priority. Unless of course, N5 Vampire Recruit Female is shown recruiting, tonight. The way I see it, the quicker we get rid of the Cult and any remaining Indy's, especially those with kills, the quicker we can buckle down, and sift through all of the remaining players and claims, hopefully weeding out the bad ones, and eradicating the Corleone Family.
Jaded
08-05-2010, 12:06 PM
Is Bald Killer the guy with blades in earlier recaps? I've been reading them as the same but now I'm starting to wonder...
Olivier le Fou
08-05-2010, 12:48 PM
I'm pretty sure they are the same guy.
Because on the nights that there is no Blades Kill, there's a Fiber Wire Kill, or a Sword Kill or something.
He's being painted as a man who's got several ways to kill you, and he does it silently, and effortlessly.
I think his kill on Antithesis is the most telling though, because he actually has a bit of a struggle, but you get to see all of the weapons he goes through.
Jaded
08-05-2010, 12:53 PM
I'm pretty sure they are the same guy.
Because on the nights that there is no Blades Kill, there's a Fiber Wire Kill, or a Sword Kill or something.
He's being painted as a man who's got several ways to kill you, and he does it silently, and effortlessly.
I think his kill on Antithesis is the most telling though, because he actually has a bit of a struggle, but you get to see all of the weapons he goes through.
Good point.
Jaded
08-05-2010, 12:57 PM
I know I made the comment about Glotnot silencing Kobe tonight; if he targets ANYONE and there's a kill then at least it would mean we could rule him out as baldy. I THINK I trust him, but that'd remove doubt. (And yes, you CAN silence me if you want, Glot.)
SuperOwens
08-05-2010, 01:18 PM
I Think Gabbo killed MLT. Just sayin'
Nah. Doesn't fit.
Anyway, I know Gabbo isnt the blades killer
Olivier le Fou
08-05-2010, 01:33 PM
If you know Gabbo isn't Blades, then I'm pretty sure that leaves one person.
Unless someone here is lying about their role and ability, BHK1978 has to be our guy.
I hope Glot chooses to silence someone, so we can rest easy knowing he's not our Assasin, but with all the claims out there, the only person who I see fitting as Baldy, is BHK.
Unless he claimed somewhere and I completely overlooked it, I'd wager that it's him. Actually, what I remember from his hint, it contained 'Charles Guiteau', and it may or may not be a conincidence, but that's an assasin. Just sayin'.
Don't tell me you know for sure he isn't Blades, too...
:rolleyes:
If TehShowtime didn't see the Assasin last night, in that last write-up bit, pretty sure that means Inadvertant did. Hopefully he gets online, and can spell things out, for us.
Anyway, that's it for me, this Night Phase. Be back after the Write-Up, hopefully.
Jaded
08-05-2010, 01:36 PM
98% sure BHK's clear.
Olivier le Fou
08-05-2010, 01:39 PM
Well...
That's upsetting.
I'm almost ready to just say "I killed two scum, and helped give us Vampire Bond", pack up my things, and go home. I'm to the point where mentally, I'll be running on empty fairly soon.
Let's wrap this game up soon, guys.
Jaded
08-05-2010, 01:48 PM
Guys who could POSSIBLY be the bald killer
Smartbomb - My number 1 suspect.
Glotnot - So hopefully he silences someone tonight to prove himself.
Max Peck - Tending to believe him, but he's a possibility.
Paws7297 - Trust her atm, but there's no actual proof for her claim.
Teh Showtime - is there any actual clear evidence he's got the ability he's claiming?
OLF (or anyone else), anything I've missed that conclusively clears any of them? SO seems sure it's not Gabbo, who was the other one on my list.
Paws7297
08-05-2010, 01:50 PM
Guys who could POSSIBLY be the bald killer
Smartbomb - My number 1 suspect.
Glotnot - So hopefully he silences someone tonight to prove himself.
Max Peck - Tending to believe him, but he's a possibility.
Paws7297 - Trust her atm, but there's no actual proof for her claim.
Teh Showtime - is there any actual clear evidence he's got the ability he's claiming?
OLF (or anyone else), anything I've missed that conclusively clears any of them? SO seems sure it's not Gabbo, who was the other one on my list.
Nah, sounds good to me.
Jaded
08-05-2010, 02:00 PM
Paws, other than talk to each other, anything else you and Rose can do in the day? DON'T SAY WHAT IT IS, just a yes/no would be really helpful.
Paws7297
08-05-2010, 02:02 PM
Paws, other than talk to each other, anything else you and Rose can do in the day? DON'T SAY WHAT IT IS, just a yes/no would be really helpful.
I don't think so...
Jaded
08-05-2010, 02:04 PM
I don't think so...
Thanks!
Paws7297
08-05-2010, 02:05 PM
Thanks!
Your welcome! :D
Max Peck
08-05-2010, 02:08 PM
Night phase not over?
Goes back to the bottle....
Paws7297
08-05-2010, 02:10 PM
Night phase not over?
Goes back to the bottle....
In 4.5 hours. You're early
BHK1978
08-05-2010, 02:27 PM
If you know Gabbo isn't Blades, then I'm pretty sure that leaves one person.
Unless someone here is lying about their role and ability, BHK1978 has to be our guy.
I hope Glot chooses to silence someone, so we can rest easy knowing he's not our Assasin, but with all the claims out there, the only person who I see fitting as Baldy, is BHK.
Unless he claimed somewhere and I completely overlooked it, I'd wager that it's him. Actually, what I remember from his hint, it contained 'Charles Guiteau', and it may or may not be a conincidence, but that's an assasin. Just sayin'.
Don't tell me you know for sure he isn't Blades, too...
:rolleyes:
If TehShowtime didn't see the Assasin last night, in that last write-up bit, pretty sure that means Inadvertant did. Hopefully he gets online, and can spell things out, for us.
Anyway, that's it for me, this Night Phase. Be back after the Write-Up, hopefully.
The name was brought up because of who Charles Guiteau killed or actually what the job was of the man that Charles Guiteau killed.
Glotnot
08-05-2010, 04:47 PM
The name was brought up because of who Charles Guiteau killed or actually what the job was of the man that Charles Guiteau killed.
Jesus christ.
You're a president.
We get it.
HEY EVERYBODY BHK IS CLAIMING TO BE A PRESIDENT!
I considered making the font incerdibly large as well as bolded, but decided against it.
You're going to make such increidbly obvious hints over and over and over but not say what they actually mean? It took three seconds and Wikipedia to figure it out.
That doesn't mean I believe you, and even if I do believe you it doesn't make you Town.
There have been many instances of "evil" presidents. And even if there weren't, that doesn't mean you weren't recruited.
You're scum.
You're whole attitude and set of mannerisms scream it to me. I really hope I'm not wrong, pretty sure I'm not, or you just act like you're scum when you're town and don't care about whether or not you lynch a townie as long as you yourself stay alive ("I'M NOT SCUM YOU'RE SCUM!"), which is just terrible, terrible play. Regardless of alignment, really.
Kobe1724
08-05-2010, 05:27 PM
Glotnot is right
Undertaker666
08-05-2010, 06:33 PM
Night 6 is over! Writeup to follow shortly.
Undertaker666
08-05-2010, 06:38 PM
Night 6.
***********************
'Open up, Police.'. There was no reply. 'Here we go', the man said as he was about to kick the door. But then he noticed that the door was already hanging off it's hinges. 'Hmmmm...'. He entered the room and began searching for clues. 'Gotcha.'.
***********************
The man burst through the door, his weapon held high. Having been abruptly woken up, the occupant screamed. 'Shhhhhh! Sorry, I thought you were someone else.'.
***********************
Sat in the darkness of his room staring at his laptop, he watched intently. 'I know you're up to something.'.
***********************
There was a tapping on the door. 'Who is it?', but the question was only met with silence. Cautiously they opened the door... 'Awww, you're adorable!'
***********************
The man knocked on the door but there was no answer. Quietly he crept inside and began to look around.
***********************
The boy was keeping a watchful eye when someone tapped him on the shoulder.
'Hi, what're you doing?'
'Uh, nothing.'.
'You shouldn't be wandering the hallways, it's not safe.'.
'Thanks for the advice but I'm quite busy, so if you don't mind...', he said as he gestured for the man to go away.
'Sorry, I was just trying to help.'.
The boy turned around to resume his task, a fatal mistake. The man took the cheese-wire out of his pocket and a short while later, the boy lay dead. 'I warned ya, kid.'.
***********************
Sat in his room his stomach gurgled. 'I'm so hungry', he thought to himself. Opening the mini-bar he was met with a glorious sight. In no time at all he'd stuff his face with all the available candy.
***********************
Teh Showtime is dead, he was Kale Brecht, Good Aligned Nosy Neighbour
Night phase pm's will be sent out shortly.
Undertaker666
08-05-2010, 06:51 PM
All night phase pm's have been sent out. If you think you should have one and don't, send me a pm.
It is now Day 7, with 17 left it takes 9 to lynch. You have until Sunday 12:30am August 8th BST (Saturday 7:30pm August 7th EST) to achieve a lynch. If a majority has not been reached by the deadline, a No Lynch will be declared.
Olivier le Fou
08-05-2010, 06:53 PM
SuperOwens, I do believe I can clear you as the Last Vampire. Not 100% sure, but I'm pretty sure I can clear you.
Comradebot or RebelliousAngel.
Methinks one of you is our last vampire.
But luckily, the write-up didn't show any signs of recruitment, so getting rid of James Bond last phase must have been the right vampire.
Other than that?
Let's catch us a Bald Assassin. First avenue to look into?
Vote: Glotnot
Glot... Why didn't you silence anyone, and at least just prove that you're not lying about your ability? There were numerous people you could have chosen to silence, and the write-up appearance could have even helped us decipher who someone was, depending on who you targetted. Refresh our memories, your claim is something of a skilled killer, no?
Undertaker666
08-05-2010, 06:55 PM
Vote Count:
Glotnot: 1 (Olivier le Fou)
It is now Day 7, with 17 left it takes 9 to lynch. You have until Sunday 12:30am August 8th BST (Saturday 7:30pm August 7th EST) to achieve a lynch. If a majority has not been reached by the deadline, a No Lynch will be declared.
Max Peck
08-05-2010, 06:56 PM
Ok Kobe, come tell me what I already know.....
Jaded
08-05-2010, 06:57 PM
Vote: Glotnot
As OLF says, you REALLY should have silenced someone. (I even volunteered!)
Also, I roleblocked C-bot. That may, or may not, have something to do with the lack of vampire recruitment - just thought I'd mention it.
Jaded
08-05-2010, 06:59 PM
BTW, Taker, write-up says it was night 5 not 6. Any chance you can change it to avoid confusion?
Undertaker666
08-05-2010, 07:08 PM
Vote Count:
Glotnot: 2 (Olivier le Fou, Jaded)
It is now Day 7, with 17 left it takes 9 to lynch. You have until Sunday 12:30am August 8th BST (Saturday 7:30pm August 7th EST) to achieve a lynch. If a majority has not been reached by the deadline, a No Lynch will be declared.
BTW, Taker, write-up says it was night 5 not 6. Any chance you can change it to avoid confusion?
Done. :cool:
Comradebot
08-05-2010, 07:18 PM
Vote: Glotnot
As OLF says, you REALLY should have silenced someone. (I even volunteered!)
Also, I roleblocked C-bot. That may, or may not, have something to do with the lack of vampire recruitment - just thought I'd mention it.
Seeing as how I'm not a vampire, I'll say it didn't.
Midnightnick
08-05-2010, 07:19 PM
SuperOwens, I do believe I can clear you as the Last Vampire. Not 100% sure, but I'm pretty sure I can clear you.
Comradebot or RebelliousAngel.
Methinks one of you is our last vampire.
But luckily, the write-up didn't show any signs of recruitment, so getting rid of James Bond last phase must have been the right vampire.
Other than that?
Let's catch us a Bald Assassin. First avenue to look into?
Vote: Glotnot
Glot... Why didn't you silence anyone, and at least just prove that you're not lying about your ability? There were numerous people you could have chosen to silence, and the write-up appearance could have even helped us decipher who someone was, depending on who you targetted. Refresh our memories, your claim is something of a skilled killer, no?
I'd like to tell you something about one of your choices about the last vampire.
One of them is Corleone Aligned.
Here's helping you narrow it down.
One of them likes Russia.
Olivier le Fou
08-05-2010, 07:27 PM
Also, I roleblocked C-bot. That may, or may not, have something to do with the lack of vampire recruitment - just thought I'd mention it.
I don't know... Masterded was lynched Day Three, and James Bond didn't appear to begin recruiting until four nights after he was recruited, two phases after Masterded died. I wouldn't expect our newest vampire to be able to recruit until Night 8, or so.
And on that note, I don't really have anything concrete, but if I were to choose between Comradebot and RebelliousAngel as to which one I think has the higher chance of being the last vampire, I'd say RebelliousAngel. If only because of circumstance. Plus, with who I thought RebelliousAngel was hinting at, I could totally see her having the mannerisms of the woman recruited on Night Five. But again, that's completely an opinion, based off of very little.
Glot's our biggest avenue for pressure, right now. If not for any other reason apart from his lacking of proving he can silence, and his character being something of a fighter/killer/assasin-esque guy, right?
Pre-Edit: Wait... Comradebot's Corleone Aligned!? RebelliousAngel is probably our last Vampire, then. What does that say about Paws? We've ran out of people to be Rose, right?
Haha, Kobe's probably beaming right now.
Midnightnick
08-05-2010, 07:29 PM
I don't know... Masterded was lynched Day Three, and James Bond didn't appear to begin recruiting until four nights after he was recruited, two phases after Masterded died. I wouldn't expect our newest vampire to be able to recruit until Night 8, or so.
And on that note, I don't really have anything concrete, but if I were to choose between Comradebot and RebelliousAngel as to which one I think has the higher chance of being the last vampire, I'd say RebelliousAngel. If only because of circumstance. Plus, with who I thought RebelliousAngel was hinting at, I could totally see her having the mannerisms of the woman recruited on Night Five. But again, that's completely an opinion, based off of very little.
Glot's our biggest avenue for pressure, right now. If not for any other reason apart from his lacking of proving he can silence, and his character being something of a fighter/killer/assasin-esque guy, right?
Pre-Edit: Wait... Comradebot's Corleone Aligned!? RebelliousAngel is probably our last Vampire, then. What does that say about Paws? We've ran out of people to be Rose, right?
Haha, Kobe's probably beaming right now.
That's what I got for my result.
So, barring Bus Driving.
Jaded
08-05-2010, 07:30 PM
Pre-Edit: Wait... Comradebot's Corleone Aligned!? RebelliousAngel is probably our last Vampire, then. What does that say about Paws? We've ran out of people to be Rose, right?
We have?
Comradebot
08-05-2010, 07:33 PM
That's what I got for my result.
So, barring Bus Driving.
Well, I'm NOT Corleone Aligned...
JMan busdrove me last phase to protect me from a kill.
Which would also mean Jaded didn't actually block me. :p
Midnightnick
08-05-2010, 07:34 PM
Well, I'm NOT Corleone Aligned...
JMan busdrove me last phase to protect me from a kill.
Which would also mean Jaded didn't actually block me. :p
Well whoever he busdrove you with.
Corleone aligned.
Olivier le Fou
08-05-2010, 07:35 PM
Guess we'll be waiting on Jman to confirm or deny whether or not he targetted one of them.
I mean, it kind of makes sense.
But I don't know. Let's just see what all happens.
Pre-Edit: Haha, Rose would be female, and we've run out of female characters that would be plausible, right? If CBot really is Corleone, that would rule him out, and I didn't think RA was hinting at Rose. I had her more along the lines of a certain Sandra Bullock character. Am I blatantly wrong? SuperOwens has an active ability I thought, and Paws said they both didn't have active night abilities...
So I just thought that ruled out all the remaining females.
Comradebot
08-05-2010, 07:37 PM
Guess we'll be waiting on Jman to confirm or deny whether or not he targetted one of them.
I mean, it kind of makes sense.
But I don't know. Let's just see what all happens.
Pre-Edit: Haha, Rose would be female, and we've run out of female characters that would be plausible, right? If CBot really is Corleone, that would rule him out, and I didn't think RA was hinting at Rose. I had her more along the lines of a certain Sandra Bullock character. Am I blatantly wrong? SuperOwens has an active ability I thought, and Paws said they both didn't have active night abilities...
So I just thought that ruled out all the remaining females.
Yes, OLF, I'm Corleone Aligned and I decided push incredibly hard to lynch our own Don. :rolleyes:
Olivier le Fou
08-05-2010, 07:38 PM
Haha, I've seen it done, before.
But no, I believe you. Jman has taken a fancy of driving you around.
So, is it basically safe to confirm that you're our elusive Rose?
Jaded
08-05-2010, 07:38 PM
I had her more along the lines of a certain Sandra Bullock character. Am I blatantly wrong?
Yup, but she's not claiming Rose either.
SuperOwens has an active ability I thought, and Paws said they both didn't have active night abilities...
I didn't think she did...
To back up C-bot's thing about being bus driven, this was the first time that the write-up hasn't shown the sex of the person I visited, which seemed weird. Would make sense if that was because I'd targetted a female but ended up at a male.
So, Jman... all eyes are on you! And Glotnot, obviously.
Jman2k3
08-05-2010, 08:15 PM
Well, I'm NOT Corleone Aligned...
JMan busdrove me last phase to protect me from a kill.
Which would also mean Jaded didn't actually block me. :p
Well whoever he busdrove you with.
Corleone aligned.
What???? When I switch Comradebot it was with Antithesis since I thought he was bulletproof and could take the hit.
Jman2k3
08-05-2010, 08:17 PM
Vote: Midnightnick
Comradebot
08-05-2010, 08:29 PM
Yeah, Nick HAS to be lying if Jman didn't switch me.
There's absolutely ZERO way I can be Corleone aligned, and the answer should be right in front of yall. At this point, he's just trying to get one more mislynch before he gets strung up.
Max Peck
08-05-2010, 08:30 PM
Vote: Midnightnick
Jman2k3
08-05-2010, 08:31 PM
Yeah, Nick HAS to be lying if Jman didn't switch me.
There's absolutely ZERO way I can be Corleone aligned, and the answer should be right in front of yall. At this point, he's just trying to get one more mislynch before he gets strung up.
Then throw a vote down as well lol.
Midnightnick
08-05-2010, 08:31 PM
What???? When I switch Comradebot it was with Antithesis since I thought he was bulletproof and could take the hit.
Vote: Midnightnick
Did you switch Comrade last night Jman?
If you did, who did you switch him with?
As my results got me Comrade as Corleone.
Jman2k3
08-05-2010, 08:33 PM
Did you switch Comrade last night Jman?
If you did, who did you switch him with?
As my results got me Comrade as Corleone.
I didn't switch Comradebot at all last night. Wasn't even near him.
Midnightnick
08-05-2010, 08:33 PM
I didn't switch Comradebot at all last night. Wasn't even near him.
Then Comrade's Corleone.
Undertaker666
08-05-2010, 08:35 PM
Vote Count:
Glotnot: 2 (Olivier le Fou, Jaded)
Midnightnick: 2 (Jman2k3, Max Peck)
It is now Day 7, with 17 left it takes 9 to lynch. You have until Sunday 12:30am August 8th BST (Saturday 7:30pm August 7th EST) to achieve a lynch. If a majority has not been reached by the deadline, a No Lynch will be declared.
Glotnot
08-05-2010, 09:09 PM
Let's catch us a Bald Assassin. First avenue to look into?
Vote: Glotnot
Glot... Why didn't you silence anyone, and at least just prove that you're not lying about your ability? There were numerous people you could have chosen to silence, and the write-up appearance could have even helped us decipher who someone was, depending on who you targetted. Refresh our memories, your claim is something of a skilled killer, no?
Olivier, were you recruited?
You can't say "Hey Glot, you're a character who's a known killer, are you the bald guy killing everyone?" when the character you're basing this assumption off of doesn't even fit the physical description of the one performing the actions you suspect me of committing.
It doesn't work like that. If you accept me to be someone, and base the possibility that I could be a killer on that, and then the someone isn't at all like the one you suspect me to be, then that should say quite a bit to you.
Basically:
I'm. Not. Bald.
Kobe1724
08-05-2010, 09:17 PM
Max Peck.
Why do you think there was only 1 kill tonight?
Max Peck
08-05-2010, 09:20 PM
Max Peck.
Why do you think there was only 1 kill tonight?
If I had to guess I would say that the scum figured out that you were gonna investigate me, I would come up not town, so the lack of kill paints me as scum pretty good.
Small problem with that is I am not scum.
Olivier le Fou
08-05-2010, 09:23 PM
Haha, but Glot, until you use your ability, or someone uses their ability on you, and you show up in a write-up, you can't say "I'm Not Bald" and expect us to just take your word for it, when there's someone going around killing people in a skilled sort of way. I didn't say it was you doing the killing. I was just pointing out how you haven't used your silence ability yet, and therefore, to my knowledge, haven't appeared in a write-up yet, to prove you're who you're claiming as, and not as our Assasin.
But whatever. I've got nothing really else to say, that hasn't been said in any of my previous posts, already.
Got a friend ever. Don't expect much out of me for the next, like, 14 hours.
Kobe1724
08-05-2010, 09:30 PM
If I had to guess I would say that the scum figured out that you were gonna investigate me, I would come up not town, so the lack of kill paints me as scum pretty good.
Small problem with that is I am not scum.
Your possible lynch doesn't outweigh the pros of a guaranteed town kill though, does it?
Kobe1724
08-05-2010, 09:31 PM
Haha, but Glot, until you use your ability, or someone uses their ability on you, and you show up in a write-up, you can't say "I'm Not Bald" and expect us to just take your word for it, when there's someone going around killing people in a skilled sort of way. I didn't say it was you doing the killing. I was just pointing out how you haven't used your silence ability yet, and therefore, to my knowledge, haven't appeared in a write-up yet, to prove you're who you're claiming as, and not as our Assasin.
But whatever. I've got nothing really else to say, that hasn't been said in any of my previous posts, already.
Got a friend ever. Don't expect much out of me for the next, like, 14 hours.
How do you explain the Astil/DQ stuff if Glot isn't town?
Max Peck
08-05-2010, 09:31 PM
Your possible lynch doesn't outweigh the pros of a guaranteed town kill though, does it?
Yeah but its all more fun to manipulate the town...plus if I get lynched then YOU look bad as you pushed my scumminess.
Kobe1724
08-05-2010, 09:31 PM
Your possible lynch doesn't outweigh the pros of a guaranteed town kill though, does it?
And by that I mean the scum could have definitely killed a townie last night.
Why frame you instead?
Rebelliousangel
08-05-2010, 09:32 PM
Guess we'll be waiting on Jman to confirm or deny whether or not he targetted one of them.
I mean, it kind of makes sense.
But I don't know. Let's just see what all happens.
Pre-Edit: Haha, Rose would be female, and we've run out of female characters that would be plausible, right? If CBot really is Corleone, that would rule him out, and I didn't think RA was hinting at Rose. I had her more along the lines of a certain Sandra Bullock character. Am I blatantly wrong? SuperOwens has an active ability I thought, and Paws said they both didn't have active night abilities...
So I just thought that ruled out all the remaining females.
Ok let me clear it up, I'm not Rose the Sanda Bullock interpurtation was indeed correct.
Kobe1724
08-05-2010, 09:32 PM
Yeah but its all more fun to manipulate the town...plus if I get lynched then YOU look bad as you pushed my scumminess.
No one pays attention to my theories, though. :)
Max Peck
08-05-2010, 09:33 PM
Read my reply, it answers that question Kobe...
Or actually, to be nice
Framing me and getting me mislynched will make you look bad too
Mind games and all:)
Glotnot
08-05-2010, 09:33 PM
Haha, but Glot, until you use your ability, or someone uses their ability on you, and you show up in a write-up, you can't say "I'm Not Bald" and expect us to just take your word for it, when there's someone going around killing people in a skilled sort of way. I didn't say it was you doing the killing. I was just pointing out how you haven't used your silence ability yet, and therefore, to my knowledge, haven't appeared in a write-up yet, to prove you're who you're claiming as, and not as our Assasin.
Aye. But the reason you're singling me out as being the bald assassin is because you think I'm an assassin.
You have no reason to think I'm assassin other than the fact that I SAID I'm an assassin.
So for you to make this argument, you have to accept that I'm an assassin, and in order to do that, you have to accept my claim, and while my claimed character IS an assassin, he is not bald.
Therefore, your argument is fundamentally flawed.
Kobe1724
08-05-2010, 09:33 PM
Ok let me clear it up, I'm not Rose the Sanda Bullock interpurtation was indeed correct.
Pawsisscum PawsisscumPawsisscumPawsisscumPawsisscumPawsisscum Pawsisscum
PawsisscumPawsisscumPawsisscumPawsisscumPawsisscum Pawsisscum
PawsisscumPawsisscumPawsisscum.
Max Peck
08-05-2010, 09:34 PM
Pawsisscum PawsisscumPawsisscumPawsisscumPawsisscumPawsisscum Pawsisscum
PawsisscumPawsisscumPawsisscumPawsisscumPawsisscum Pawsisscum
PawsisscumPawsisscumPawsisscum.
So is Kobe though....:D
Kobe1724
08-05-2010, 09:35 PM
Read my reply, it answers that question Kobe...
Or actually, to be nice
Framing me and getting me mislynched will make you look bad too
Mind games and all:)
See above. No one pays attention to my theories. Otherwise, you would definitely be lynched now.
Because the probability that you're scum is now above 90%.
Max Peck
08-05-2010, 09:36 PM
See above. No one pays attention to my theories. Otherwise, you would definitely be lynched now.
Because the probability that you're scum is now above 90%.
If you're so sure, where's your vote? Afraid to get your hands dirty?
Here's mine, just so we are all clear.
Change Vote: Kobe1724
Kobe1724
08-05-2010, 09:36 PM
Likely Scum:
Paws
MNN
BHK
Smart Bomb
Max Peck
I am okay with lynching with any of the above today, but won't vote on anyone else under any circumstances this phase.
Kobe1724
08-05-2010, 09:37 PM
If you're so sure, where's your vote? Afraid to get your hands dirty?
Here's mine, just so we are all clear.
Change Vote: Kobe1724
Afraid... to get my hands dirty? :rolleyes:
Rebelliousangel
08-05-2010, 09:39 PM
Pawsisscum PawsisscumPawsisscumPawsisscumPawsisscumPawsisscum Pawsisscum
PawsisscumPawsisscumPawsisscumPawsisscumPawsisscum Pawsisscum
PawsisscumPawsisscumPawsisscum.
No I really don't think she isNo I really don't think she isNo I really don't think she isNo I really don't think she isNo I really don't think she is
Likely Scum:
Paws
MNN
BHK
Smart Bomb
Max Peck
I am okay with lynching with any of the above today, but won't vote on anyone else under any circumstances this phase.
Hey why I'd get kicked off hte team again! :(
If you're so sure, where's your vote? Afraid to get your hands dirty?
Here's mine, just so we are all clear.
Change Vote: Kobe1724
Ohhh fun Me to Me too!!
Vote: Kobe1724
*sings*Come on ride a train it's a cho cho train!! Whoo hoo
Kobe1724
08-05-2010, 09:41 PM
The thing that speaks most damningly to both your innocence and guilt here would be your insistence on engaging me and making a scene.
On the one hand, it points to a fixation with my result. Scummy.
On the other hand, your best play here would have been to stay silent. You aren't being pressured by anyone, and weren't even being pressured by me before you brought up my result. So why bring it up? Either it's fixation... or else you're so completely town that you want to engage me in some sort of confrontation so that the town will choose between us.
Interesting.
I would say right now that you are probably the indy serial killer.
Yes, that's almost certainly it.
Max Peck
08-05-2010, 09:42 PM
The thing that speaks most damningly to both your innocence and guilt here would be your insistence on engaging me and making a scene.
On the one hand, it points to a fixation with my result. Scummy.
On the other hand, your best play here would have been to stay silent. You aren't being pressured by anyone, and weren't even being pressured by me before you brought up my result. So why bring it up? Either it's fixation... or else you're so completely town that you want to engage me in some sort of confrontation so that the town will choose between us.
Interesting.
I would say right now that you are probably the indy serial killer.
Yes, that's almost certainly it.
Talk is cheap young lady.
Kobe1724
08-05-2010, 09:43 PM
No I really don't think she isNo I really don't think she isNo I really don't think she isNo I really don't think she isNo I really don't think she is
Hey why I'd get kicked off hte team again! :(
Ohhh fun Me to Me too!!
Vote: Kobe1724
*sings*Come on ride a train it's a cho cho train!! Whoo hoo
Because even though you are quick to anger and ignorant of the fact you're being played, the simple fact of the matter is that right now you're...
Likely Town:
Oliver
C-Bot
Kobe1724
Glotnot
Teh Showtime
RA
Likely Scum:
Paws
MNN
BHK
Smart Bomb
Max Peck
Ambiguous:
SuperOwens
Blue Star
Gabbo
I-mac
Jaded
Jman2k3
Inadvertant
No read/Ambivalent:
Rebelliousangel
08-05-2010, 09:44 PM
The thing that speaks most damningly to both your innocence and guilt here would be your insistence on engaging me and making a scene.
On the one hand, it points to a fixation with my result. Scummy.
On the other hand, your best play here would have been to stay silent. You aren't being pressured by anyone, and weren't even being pressured by me before you brought up my result. So why bring it up? Either it's fixation... or else you're so completely town that you want to engage me in some sort of confrontation so that the town will choose between us.
Interesting.
I would say right now that you are probably the indy serial killer.
Yes, that's almost certainly it.
I liked being on the scum team better! *pouts* I want team mates to talk to!
Kobe1724
08-05-2010, 09:46 PM
Talk is cheap young lady.
Voting on you would serve no purpose right now.
The town is focused on another lynch, and for whatever reason I lack the clout to push for your lynch.
So I'll wait for now. :cool:
Kobe1724
08-05-2010, 09:46 PM
I liked being on the scum team better! *pouts* I want team mates to talk to!
You're annoying.
Rebelliousangel
08-05-2010, 09:48 PM
You're annoying.
Haha if that isn't the pot calling the kettle black thenI don't knwo what is!
Antithesis
08-05-2010, 09:48 PM
You're annoying.
CATFIGHT!!!!!
:dies again:
Kobe1724
08-05-2010, 09:49 PM
MNN, the time has come for us to get to the bottom of your alignment. I have some questions for you.
Midnightnick
08-05-2010, 09:49 PM
MNN, the time has come for us to get to the bottom of your alignment. I have some questions for you.
Fire away.
Kobe1724
08-05-2010, 09:49 PM
CATFIGHT!!!!!
:dies again:
Heh. :cool:
Max Peck
08-05-2010, 09:51 PM
CATFIGHT!!!!!
:dies again:
Anti, you scallywag!
Kobe1724
08-05-2010, 09:54 PM
1. Please share with us exactly what you got back from your night 2, night 4 and night 6 investigations.
2. Please share with us what your reasons were for investigating C-Bot.
3. What are the four people you find most likely to be scum and to be town, respectively?
4. If we vote to lynch C-Bot and he comes up town, how would you feel about being lynched tomorrow?
5. What are your thoughts on Oliver? Do you think his suspicions on your are founded or unfounded?
Kobe1724
08-05-2010, 09:55 PM
6. Also, how likely do you think JMan is to be scum on a scale of 1 to 100 with 100 being the most likely.
Rebelliousangel
08-05-2010, 09:57 PM
Aww looks like someone doesn't want to no more...:D
Rebelliousangel
08-05-2010, 09:58 PM
Aww looks like someone doesn't want to play no more...:D
fixed
Midnightnick
08-05-2010, 09:59 PM
1. Please share with us exactly what you got back from your night 2, night 4 and night 6 investigations.
2. Please share with us what your reasons were for investigating C-Bot.
3. What are the four people you find most likely to be scum and to be town, respectively?
4. If we vote to lynch C-Bot and he comes up town, how would you feel about being lynched tomorrow?
5. What are your thoughts on Oliver? Do you think his suspicions on your are founded or unfounded?
1)Night 2 - Vampire Cult Aligned
Night 4 - Good Aligned
Night 6 - Corleone Family Aligned
2) Gut feeling. You've been preaching about your scum list and trying to get them lynched. So I wanted to take a long shot.
And it payed off.
3) Top 4 Town - Myself, Olivier, Teh Showtime and Jman2k3.
Top 4 Scum - C-Bot (only because of the result), Smart Bomb, Paws and I-mac.
4) If he comes up town? Then I've got no idea why I got Corleone aligned for a result. And I'll admit my bad.
5) I think Olivier is the most town person this side of the now deceased Antithesis and myself.
Midnightnick
08-05-2010, 09:59 PM
6. Also, how likely do you think JMan is to be scum on a scale of 1 to 100 with 100 being the most likely.
15.
Kobe1724
08-05-2010, 10:01 PM
1)Night 2 - Vampire Cult Aligned
Night 4 - Good Aligned
Night 6 - Corleone Family Aligned
2) Gut feeling. You've been preaching about your scum list and trying to get them lynched. So I wanted to take a long shot.
And it payed off.
3) Top 4 Town - Myself, Olivier, Teh Showtime and Jman2k3.
Top 4 Scum - C-Bot (only because of the result), Smart Bomb, Paws and I-mac.
4) If he comes up town? Then I've got no idea why I got Corleone aligned for a result. And I'll admit my bad.
5) I think Olivier is the most town person this side of the now deceased Antithesis and myself.
Why do you think i-mac is scummy?
Comradebot
08-05-2010, 10:02 PM
So, MNN, bad news about your result, and thus for you:
Not only am I not scum, but I can prove it. :D
Midnightnick
08-05-2010, 10:03 PM
Why do you think i-mac is scummy?
Hasn't added much if anything.
Just coasted by.
There's still kills and scum out there.
Paws7297
08-05-2010, 10:03 PM
1. Please share with us exactly what you got back from your night 2, night 4 and night 6 investigations.
2. Please share with us what your reasons were for investigating C-Bot.
3. What are the four people you find most likely to be scum and to be town, respectively?
4. If we vote to lynch C-Bot and he comes up town, how would you feel about being lynched tomorrow?
5. What are your thoughts on Oliver? Do you think his suspicions on your are founded or unfounded?
Mnn I have a question to ask you myself.
N1 mded came up as Vampire Cult Aligned Supreme Vampire. What EXACTLY did C-bot come up as?
Midnightnick
08-05-2010, 10:04 PM
So, MNN, bad news about your result, and thus for you:
Not only am I not scum, but I can prove it. :D
Well Comrade, I'll eat my words if you come up Good Aligned. But you came up Corleone Family Aligned.
Either a) you're scum.
or b) framed.
Midnightnick
08-05-2010, 10:05 PM
Mnn I have a question to ask you myself.
N1 mded came up as Vampire Cult Aligned Supreme Vampire. What EXACTLY did C-bot come up as?
Corleone Family Aligned Cleaner to be exact.
Max Peck
08-05-2010, 10:06 PM
Corleone Family Aligned Cleaner to be exact.
Cleaner is a mafia term (RL mafia, not game) for a killer is it not?
Kobe1724
08-05-2010, 10:06 PM
C-Bot, please share with us your proof.
Midnightnick
08-05-2010, 10:06 PM
Cleaner is a mafia term (RL mafia, not game) for a killer is it not?
You betcha.
Know who else is a cleaner?
Agent 47.
Comradebot
08-05-2010, 10:07 PM
Well Comrade, I'll eat my words if you come up Good Aligned. But you came up Corleone Family Aligned.
Either a) you're scum.
or b) framed.
Or c, you're lying
Or d, you were re-directed.
That said, I'm not being lynched today, on account of being able to prove your so-called result is false. And I'm sorry, I'm not happy with watching you "eat your words" after I get mislynched:
And, again... I LEAD THE LYNCH ON THE FREAKIN' DON!!! Even if I was an usurper, it would've been just terrible, terrible, terrible timing that would've screwed my own chances at winning.
If you're actually town, which I doubt with this combined with JMan's evidence he gave us last phase, then use your brain. If you're not town, prepare to hang.
Paws7297
08-05-2010, 10:08 PM
Corleone Family Aligned Cleaner to be exact.
You're a lyar!
Guys he's lying. Lynch his ass.
Kobe1724
08-05-2010, 10:08 PM
MNN, you're 80% likely to be scum.
Just enough.
Vote: Midnight Nick
Comradebot
08-05-2010, 10:08 PM
C-Bot, please share with us your proof.
Well, for starters... by any other name I'd smell just as sweet. :cool:
Midnightnick
08-05-2010, 10:08 PM
Or c, you're lying
Or d, you were re-directed.
That said, I'm not being lynched today, on account of being able to prove your so-called result is false. And I'm sorry, I'm not happy with watching you "eat your words" after I get mislynched:
And, again... I LEAD THE LYNCH ON THE FREAKIN' DON!!! Even if I was an usurper, it would've been just terrible, terrible, terrible timing that would've screwed my own chances at winning.
If you're actually town, which I doubt with this combined with JMan's evidence he gave us last phase, then use your brain. If you're not town, prepare to hang.
Well Comrade, J-Man said he didn't bus drive you last night.
And I know C isn't the answer.
So, it's a or b.
Max Peck
08-05-2010, 10:09 PM
That said, I'm not being lynched today, on account of being able to prove your so-called result is false. And I'm sorry, I'm not happy with watching you "eat your words" after I get mislynched:
Care to share with the group?
If MNN is scum I would like to be rid of him asap.
Midnightnick
08-05-2010, 10:10 PM
MNN, you're 80% likely to be scum.
Just enough.
Vote: Midnight Nick
You vote me instead of the people you have higher on your scum listing?
Tsk Kobe, I thought you were smarter.
When I show up as the best Arnold character this side of the Terminator, you're going to regret this guys.
Max Peck
08-05-2010, 10:11 PM
Well, for starters... by any other name I'd smell just as sweet. :cool:
C Bot, would you be by chance "adorable"?
Comradebot
08-05-2010, 10:12 PM
C Bot, would you be by chance "adorable"?
I'm not Jaded.
Kobe1724
08-05-2010, 10:12 PM
RA, I no longer suspect you of being scum, and I'm really sorry that I accused you and placed so much attention on your role claim so late in the game given what a loss your death would have been to the town. It was unusually reckless even for me, but at this point it's water over/under the bridge, hopefully. That said, some quick questions?
Rebelliousangel
08-05-2010, 10:13 PM
Well, for starters... by any other name I'd smell just as sweet. :cool:
Ahh my other possiability for that role. I had down 2 people for that and you were one. :D
vBulletin® v3.6.8, Copyright ©2000-2013, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.