PDA

View Full Version : Judging of fights


adamrobertk
10-24-2007, 11:34 AM
Serious question and no relation to boxing or any moral thing i have against MMA, just something i noticed in some MMA sim's and title bout (kinda goes against my point but you know).

The judging in fights and judges. Sorry if this has been asked before but i noticed in title bout and some others that the judges like real life have different preferences, and will judge to their preference (i.e some judges will favour an attacking fighter if he is slightly ineffective where as the guy right next to him may give the fight to the defensive guy for his sheer brilliance at what he does). In the real world this helps as it gives guys something to talk about, i.e. bad judging and everyone has an oppinion, how will this work in the game?

VBigB
10-24-2007, 12:34 PM
All we know so far is what's been stated in the developers journal:

Finally, Addled from Alabama asks: "Also I know that every fight isn't going to end in a knockout or submission. So how are the decisions handled. I mean is it possible that we can get a "Hamill-Bisping" decision that isn't really seen as the right call in the minds of the viewers?"

The judges work the same was as in reality; each scores the fight their own way, and the result is decided by their three scorecards. There can be bad and questionable decisions.

Jim Force
10-25-2007, 02:54 PM
Serious question and no relation to boxing or any moral thing i have against MMA, just something i noticed in some MMA sims

I have never seen any other MMA sims on the market. What are they and how long have they been out?