Official Marvel Mafia Game Thread

[Akki]

Akki, since the names are out there I am going to ask you a question. I have debated on whether to do so or not, but doesn't seem to be going anywhere.

I don't want you to answer who if the answer is yes. But can you clear anyone on dj's list that were targetting Midnightnick(I'd ask him, but he isn't here)?

I trust that if the answer is yes that you will speak up when the time comes.

Good question. I myself am not totally sure. But from what I know, nope.

[djthefunkchris]

Well, we're just assuming that there is at least one protector, unless you can see some other way to explain Nick not getting killed.

Depends on what his "Ability" is. They aren't exactly a bunch of wimps.

[The Humanoid Typhoon]

If a dozen or so more people jump on, he won't have much of a choice... ;)Not when you're calling your bluff beforehand.

[djthefunkchris]

Depends on what his "Ability" is. They aren't exactly a bunch of wimps.

I don't think I'm the only person that put them together to start (the posts I quoted). I think everyone was seeing at least two protector's....

I don't know if that is what actually happened at Midnightnick's place.

That would mean that we have four protector's (not that I don't doubt that) split up evenly. That in itself would be fine if we thought that all the protector's discussed it with each other, and figured who would protect who.

However... I didn't see them discuss it here, we all knew, but to have two and two like that perfectly? Just would be the VERY FIRST TIME I ever seen that happen.

[The Humanoid Typhoon]

Well, we're just assuming that there is at least one protector, unless you can see some other way to explain Nick not getting killed.Two people fought off Apocalypse.

[djthefunkchris]

Two people fought off Apocalypse.

At Nick's house, or at Akki's?

[BlueStar]

Only 10 pages...wow, that's very little.

[djthefunkchris]

Apocolypse wasn't on my list. So he didn't attack Midnightnick. See where I am going here?

[Akki]

Two people fought off Apocalypse.

Your point?

That would mean that we have four protector's (not that I don't doubt that) split up evenly. That in itself would be fine if we thought that all the protector's discussed it with each other, and figured who would protect who.

However... I didn't see them discuss it here, we all knew, but to have two and two like that perfectly? Just would be the VERY FIRST TIME I ever seen that happen.

I did say that I would be less vulnerable than Nick. With that and knowing what I know, the math works out.

[mjdgoldeneye]

Not when you're calling your bluff beforehand.

The logic is clear...

I don't need to explain myself or provide logic when he knows who is is, where he was, and that we have reason to worry. If he doesn't get the message, we can remind him. :)

I want to see you hold back info smugly when 12, 13, etc. votes are on you and an angry mob is breathing down your neck...

If we don't get that many votes on him, people clearly don't believe he's our best bet, and it's irrelevant...

This isn't poker, most of this game's processes are self fulfilling...

[djthefunkchris]

Apocolypse wasn't on my list. So he didn't attack Midnightnick. See where I am going here?

Bassically, I'm aggreeing that Venom/Apocolypse, and all that went on at Akki's....

WE DID NOT SEE PROTECTOR's Protecting Midnightnick. I hope Nick isn't Blackbolt, lol... *That thought just hit me.

[mjdgoldeneye]

Bassically, I'm aggreeing that Venom/Apocolypse, and all that went on at Akki's....

WE DID NOT SEE PROTECTOR's Protecting Midnightnick. I hope Nick isn't Blackbolt, lol... *That thought just hit me.

He said he was on a list of former Avengers members, and Black Bolt isn't on said list.

Plus, I think some people know who Midnightnick is, anyway,,,

[Akki]

Bassically, I'm aggreeing that Venom/Apocolypse, and all that went on at Akki's....

WE DID NOT SEE PROTECTOR's Protecting Midnightnick. I hope Nick isn't Blackbolt, lol... *That thought just hit me.

Nick already claimed. In fact, so have I. More subtly than you, though. Even more subtly than Aussie, I think.

I have very little doubt that Nick was protected last night. I'm sure I was. I would be sure even without the write-up. Like I said, if you can come up with a better explanation as to why Nick didn't die, I'm all ears.

[djthefunkchris]

He said he was on a list of former Avengers members, and Black Bolt isn't on said list.

Plus, I think some people know who Midnightnick is, anyway,,,

True, was thinking aloud. That part is done with *to signify that. It's not exactly the point I was trying to make (the other stuff is more important).

[djthefunkchris]

Nick already claimed. In fact, so have I. More subtly than you, though. Even more subtly than Aussie, I think.

I have very little doubt that Nick was protected last night. I'm sure I was. I would be sure even without the write-up. Like I said, if you can come up with a better explanation as to why Nick didn't die, I'm all ears.

I'm not saying there wasn't any protector's... I'm saying from the viewpoint (mine), we didn't see any. We only saw four, and possibly a fifth that flew out the window (possibly).

The sixth one might be the protector, staying with him.

Remember, two "Made their move", then later "Snuck out". The two outside seen that there wasn't going to be anything else going on, so they left.

One "might" have flown out.

There was allot of noise inside, impossible to know all of what was going on. Surely it was fighting.

[djthefunkchris]

Akki, any information (since you are both outed anyways), that can help us understand who done what (even if it's minimal), then it would surely help us get some sort of at least pressure going on someone.

Otherwise this day is going to end in a no lynch.

[djthefunkchris]

I have six names, and we are not going to lynch any of them, even though one of them is probably Thanos, and one of them was attacking Midnightnick.

THat's got to be a record. Hell, Astil had better luck when it was just naming people that were out doing things at night. Here we have names of people that TARGETED someone we know is town.

[Akki]

Akki, any information (since you are both outed anyways), that can help us understand who done what (even if it's minimal), then it would surely help us get some sort of at least pressure going on someone.

Otherwise this day is going to end in a no lynch.

OK. Nick stayed home last night (didn't do anything). What I did was Illuminati-related and should have had no impact on anything.

[TJRoH]

Well that sucks. Well guys I think I am pretty much done with the GDS forums. People like Arrows and Moe (Who I don't even know, but annoy him) make this place no fun. Thanks to people like Derek B and Outlaw for being cool. I had fun but some people are great at being jerks so peace out!

-TJRoH-

*Looks like Arrows will be a happy little boy now*

[djthefunkchris]

600+ posts... gee, thanks. Wish I had been able to get back on last night now :rolleyes: Haven't read all of it yet... going to take a break and then come back to finish it off, though I expect I'll fall behind again soon because GTA came out today and I'm getting it in a couple of hours... and there's the football tonight... I'll be fine just don't go doing too much talking.

Anywho, a few interesting happenings in what I've read so far, though just to warn you a lot of the in-depth Marvel discussions will go over my head for the entire game because I'm not really a comic person but superheroes can do cool things... and I figured Rev and Anti would put together a good game, so I joined anyway. Basically, don't shout at me if I seem stupid :o Most of my Superhero knowledge comes from films, with a little bit from TV shows... and even then, I only really know Spiderman, X-Men and Hulk... unless somehow Batman managed to sneak in without anyone noticing! :p

Caught up. Might not have all gone in and stayed in, 'cause I've had a couple of celebratory drinks! UTD ARE GOING TO MOSCOW! 1-0! WOO! Ahem... anyway, I can kind of see what shameless was suggesting but it wasn't something I'd ever advocate. Yes, the gems are with people that can be actively targeted by the mafia but at least we know that they are with good guys for the moment, y'know?

Anyway, off to play GTA and then sleep. Will be on tomorrow at the very least while watching the Chelsea/Liverpool game.

Caught up... well mostly, sort of skimmed some parts because I was getting bored of it.

Never heard of shameless' character but from the sounds of things he wasn't a massively important role and didn't seem a great player from the brief time he was involved. Having said that, I'm not usually a fan of the random day one bandwagon unless there is a pretty substantial slip... think the only time I did just go with a BW was my first game.

Also, surprised there are doubts about Magneto being in since he's one of the few villains I know... again, because I only really know Spiderman, X-Men and Hulk, but I'll trust the experts... would still like him to be in so I can at least understand some of the discussion/write-ups though :p

So yeah, between GTAIV and making sure I don't fail my exams horrificly, while also trying to not be a recluse, I've been strapped for time the last few days. I'm never really that vocal in the first few phases anyway. Will try to get a little more stuck in if possible though.

Good first night, don't think I've ever seen a first night go that well for the town.

The write-up was probably full of hints at characters but I still wasn't very enlightened until I read what others thought about who certain people were. And I thought DJ was claiming Spiderman when he talked about senses... but it turns out he was claiming Daredevil. At least I've heard of DD [from a Superheroes game I played elsewhere] but as for TJ's character, I was left going "huh?"... so I went searching and apparently my X-Men knowledge isn't that conclusive.

Eh... it's 2:15AM here and I need sleep. At the moment my weekend looks fairly clear, and even if something does come up, I'll have Sunday free to recover from it at least, and can use that time to stay involved.

We'll be waiting to here from you... Sunday. Maybe you can double your posts so far?

[djthefunkchris]

Well that sucks. Well guys I think I am pretty much done with the GDS forums. People like Arrows and Moe (Who I don't even know, but annoy him) make this place no fun. Thanks to people like Derek B and Outlaw for being cool. I had fun but some people are great at being jerks so peace out!

-TJRoH-

*Looks like Arrows will be a happy little boy now*

Never take anything that is said in a Mafia game personal. I sincerely doubt that they have actual hard feeling for you...

It's probably the only way they thought they could look townie;) .

[The Humanoid Typhoon]

Your point?That with two people fighting off Apocalypse, there has to be more than one protector.

I don't need to explain myself or provide logic when he knows who is is, where he was, and that we have reason to worry.He still doesn't have to worry when he knows your intentions. It just provides more time to think up suitable excuse.

I want to see you hold back info smugly when 12, 13, etc. votes are on you and an angry mob is breathing down your neck...ROTFLMAO. You clearly haven't been paying attention to my comments.

[foolinc]

I'm leaving now, then...

I'll leave my vote on foolinc... He's been silent and present for at least half an hour, even when prodded...

That just seems shady... Kinda... We'll see... Maybe...

The only thing I could do more than what I've already said (I targeted Nick and wasn't the killer) is fully claim, and I'm not going to do that unless I have to.

[Akki]

The only thing I could do more than what I've already said (I targeted Nick and wasn't the killer) is fully claim, and I'm not going to do that unless I have to.

Well, you can start by giving us your logic on targeting him.

[The Humanoid Typhoon]

Because he knew Nick was in danager, just a thought.

[Antithesis]

It is Day Phase 2. You have until 12:00AM EST/5:00AM GST on Saturday May 3rd to vote on a lynch. If at that time a majority is not reached, a no lynch will be declared.

With 34 players it is 18 to Lynch.


Derek B > 1 (Arrows)
Foolinc > 3 (Trypio, Derek B, MjGoldeneye )

Let me know if there is a mistake in the count.

[gonvick]

I have six names, and we are not going to lynch any of them, even though one of them is probably Thanos, and one of them was attacking Midnightnick.

THat's got to be a record. Hell, Astil had better luck when it was just naming people that were out doing things at night. Here we have names of people that TARGETED someone we know is town.

I agree that the lack of progress has been frustrating. And doing nothing isn't going to help. But I also don't want to out a protector, so I'm not sure where to start.

But if you, or the Illuminati, want to choose one off the list to start with, I'll go along. At the very least, I can trust your motives.

[Akki]

Because he knew Nick was in danager, just a thought.

Thanks for giving him an easy out on that one.

[THEDEMONSEED]

Well that sucks. Well guys I think I am pretty much done with the GDS forums. People like Arrows and Moe (Who I don't even know, but annoy him) make this place no fun. Thanks to people like Derek B and Outlaw for being cool. I had fun but some people are great at being jerks so peace out!

-TJRoH-

*Looks like Arrows will be a happy little boy now*

man there are plenty of people here that annoy me, and i say it. dont worry about what people say. especially in a freakin game.

i dont know what moe has with you. i consider arrows a friend but screw him. we all know the deal there. and if the ones actually involved can get over it, what is it to him to carry a grudge?

now back to the game.

[THEDEMONSEED]

The only thing I could do more than what I've already said (I targeted Nick and wasn't the killer) is fully claim, and I'm not going to do that unless I have to.

no one died.

[Arrows]

Well that sucks. Well guys I think I am pretty much done with the GDS forums. People like Arrows and Moe (Who I don't even know, but annoy him) make this place no fun. Thanks to people like Derek B and Outlaw for being cool. I had fun but some people are great at being jerks so peace out!

-TJRoH-

*Looks like Arrows will be a happy little boy now*

Yay.:cool:

[THEDEMONSEED]

Well, you can start by giving us your logic on targeting him.

interested to hear myself.

[THEDEMONSEED]

Yay.:cool:

you prick. :cool:

[The Humanoid Typhoon]

Thanks for giving him an easy out on that one.He just said that he told us everything he could without role claiming and didn't want to do that except as a last resort. He had two options: A) Harm/Stealing and B) Protecting/Investigating

Really think he's gonna say A if he was?

[Akki]

He just said that he told us everything he could without role claiming and didn't want to do that except as a last resort. He had two options: A) Harm/Stealing and B) Protecting/Investigating

Really think he's gonna say A if he was?

I really wanted to hear something from him. And I don't think I was the only one. Even if it was between protection and investigation, that could have given us something.

[THEDEMONSEED]

He just said that he told us everything he could without role claiming and didn't want to do that except as a last resort. He had two options: A) Harm/Stealing and B) Protecting/Investigating

Really think he's gonna say A if he was?

nope. but that is the way i am leaning.

vote:foolinc

[theoutlaw321]

By the way, I'm hoping you picked up on the sixth.

I think it is between two people.:cool:

[theoutlaw321]

By the way, I'm hoping you picked up on the sixth.

I think it is between two people.:cool:

And I am guessing there is some reason that you haven't thrown his name out there?

[theoutlaw321]

Good question. I myself am not totally sure. But from what I know, nope.

/nods

[foolinc]

I really wanted to hear something from him. And I don't think I was the only one. Even if it was between protection and investigation, that could have given us something.

You, really want to here it from me? Ok, here it is. I'm said I wasn't going to claim unless I have to. The way the things are going, when I wake up tomorrow I just might. However, if I answer your question I will have done just that.

[theoutlaw321]

You, really want to here it from me? Ok, here it is. I'm said I wasn't going to claim unless I have to. The way the things are going, when I wake up tomorrow I just might. However, if I answer your question I will have done just that.


/nods

[Akki]

You, really want to here it from me? Ok, here it is. I'm said I wasn't going to claim unless I have to. The way the things are going, when I wake up tomorrow I just might. However, if I answer your question I will have done just that.

There's really not too much else to do at the moment, then.

Vote: foolinc

[The Humanoid Typhoon]

Eh, I think he's town so please, keep your role to yourself. The town exposing themselves is getting pretty old. Besides, you could claim almost anything and we still wouldn't know 100% if you were telling the truth. Hell, I have 6 different names just off the top of my head anyone could bull**** their way out of this with.

[Akki]

Eh, I think he's town so please, keep your role to yourself. The town exposing themselves is getting pretty old. Besides, you could claim almost anything and we still wouldn't know 100% if you were telling the truth. Hell, I have 6 different names just off the top of my head anyone could bull**** their way out of this with.

What I don't seem to hear is any ideas. You're fine with speculating, pointing things out, and arguing with people, but I haven't seen anything out of you that could actually help us. So why not grace us with the knowledge of what we should do?

[The Humanoid Typhoon]

What I don't seem to hear is any ideas. You're fine with speculating, pointing things out, and arguing with people, but I haven't seen anything out of you that could actually help us.And this differs from you how?

[Imarevenant]

It is now Day Phase 2. You have until 12:00AM EST/5:00AM GST on Saturday May 3rd to vote on a lynch. If at that time a majority is not reached, a no lynch will be declared.

With 34 players it is 18 to Lynch.


Derek B > 1 (Arrows)
Foolinc > 5 (Trypio, Derek B, mjdgoldeneye, THEDEMONSEED, Akki)

[gonvick]

Eh, I think he's town so please, keep your role to yourself. The town exposing themselves is getting pretty old. Besides, you could claim almost anything and we still wouldn't know 100% if you were telling the truth. Hell, I have 6 different names just off the top of my head anyone could bull**** their way out of this with.

Is there anyone on DJ's list that you don't think is town, or at least not sure of enough to pressure? Or do you think we should not use the list and just go in another direction all together?

[The Humanoid Typhoon]

I don't believe DJ released the full list, but I'm getting sick of useful townies outing themselves. It's just putting together a hit list for our enemies and showing them the order in which to do it. The Illuminati outing themselves was bad enough. Harassing people who trying to protect them is just endlessly annoying. Yeah, mafia is after them too, but let the protectors continue to do what they're doing. It worked.

[BlueStar]

Hmmm...got nothing to add at this point. We seem to be running in circles. I'm inclined to put Shape on the safe list for now, based on his D1 claim. Astil...could be bad, but we won't find out now.

Off for a couple of hours.

[Derek B]

I'm caught up now, kinda nice to see that nothing too major happened overnight but still saddened that we don't have any leads. DJ's list is a doule edged sword for us just now... if he does have Thanos on it then we obviously want to track him down ASAP and deal with him. But in doing so we risk outing more powerful roles that we don't really want to have out in the open.

I assume any names DJ isn't reporting are not being revealed for a good reason (you trust/believe them) meaning that you probably think at least one of the names you've already revealed are going to be a gulity party. Since it looks like we've got an attacker AND Thanos on the list (at the very least) then it's just a case of sifting through the names we have and seeing who picked the most obvious house to target last night. (Derek's note: n00bs! :cool:)

Gonna jump in the shower now... hopefully it's not had a special visit from panix any time recently. *shudder*

[Moe Hunter]

Bassically, I'm aggreeing that Venom/Apocolypse, and all that went on at Akki's....

WE DID NOT SEE PROTECTOR's Protecting Midnightnick. I hope Nick isn't Blackbolt, lol... *That thought just hit me.
Yeah, I hope he isn't Blackbolt, that would make him a liar since he already claimed otherwise :P

I have six names, and we are not going to lynch any of them, even though one of them is probably Thanos, and one of them was attacking Midnightnick.

THat's got to be a record. Hell, Astil had better luck when it was just naming people that were out doing things at night. Here we have names of people that TARGETED someone we know is town.
Yeah, why would anyone target MNN unless they wanted to kill him? Jeez, not as if he pushed himself out into the open and BEGGED for protection now, is it?

You have six names of people who were in one place. Those still aren't good odds. When I was scum I got caught because I was one of four, and two of those four had blatant killing intentions. Even then I wasn't caught until I was obviously still killing the next night. Something tells me that out of six people, most of whom are likely town and with no obvious killer... We're not going to find anyone from it on this day.

Well that sucks. Well guys I think I am pretty much done with the GDS forums. People like Arrows and Moe (Who I don't even know, but annoy him) make this place no fun. Thanks to people like Derek B and Outlaw for being cool. I had fun but some people are great at being jerks so peace out!

-TJRoH-

Can't say I'm sorry to see him go. I don't even know what it is about him - probably just the way he was playing, and that may have just because he was scum and plaing like it (I had the "FOS" on him, as people might say). Ah well.

So, did anyone else actually see anything, learn anything or pick up on anything? Surely this enigmatic list can't be everything.

Oh and MJD, was The Shape the only guy with someone else targetting him that you could see?

[Blasphemywebleed]

I'm caught up now. Nothing really to add just now. I agree with THT :eek: that we have to stop outing ourselves so easily. We have a list of 6 people with one of them being scum, best to concentrate on that just now.

[djthefunkchris]

I don't have a great reason for NOT releasing the sixth name, outside of a hunch that he was one of the watcher's.

If the attacks in the write-up have nothing to do with what happened in my section, then what we saw there were two people protecting Akki, knocking Apocolypse out the wall (not a window), and then pounding on him till he was out. He comes to and Venom attacks him.

At Midnightnicks, all we see are four people outside, two "Make their move", and right when they do the house goes crazy with noise/things breaking, etc. Then something (or someone) goes out the window (flying?). The two that "Made their move" "Sneak out". Then two more that were watching leave since they know nothing else will happen there.

SO I have those four names and two others.

I would really have loved for the watcher's to have revealed who they are, and gave us what they seen.

[Moe Hunter]

I don't have a great reason for NOT releasing the sixth name, outside of a hunch that he was one of the watcher's.

If the attacks in the write-up have nothing to do with what happened in my section, then what we saw there were two people protecting Akki, knocking Apocolypse out the wall (not a window), and then pounding on him till he was out. He comes to and Venom attacks him.

At Midnightnicks, all we see are four people outside, two "Make their move", and right when they do the house goes crazy with noise/things breaking, etc. Then something (or someone) goes out the window (flying?). The two that "Made their move" "Sneak out". Then two more that were watching leave since they know nothing else will happen there.

SO I have those four names and two others.

I would really have loved for the watcher's to have revealed who they are, and gave us what they seen.
So to clarify, if there's two watchers, but MJD wasn't on your list yet saw stuff... doesn't that mean that the scope is larger than you think?

[gonvick]

I don't have a great reason for NOT releasing the sixth name, outside of a hunch that he was one of the watcher's.

Have any hunches about who might have had sinister intentions?

[Destiny]

Vote: foolinc

Finally caught up. It seems this is our best lead at the moment.

[Mr T Jobs To Me]

I'm just not getting bad vibes off of foolinc right now. We're at the T-16 hour mark right now too, so I hope he wakes up and claims soon. If he doesn't, we may not have time to organize much against anyone else. I know I won't be around after 7 or 8 PM EST tonight, so hopefully we'll have more development by then.

[gonvick]

You have six names of people who were in one place. Those still aren't good odds. When I was scum I got caught because I was one of four, and two of those four had blatant killing intentions. Even then I wasn't caught until I was obviously still killing the next night. Something tells me that out of six people, most of whom are likely town and with no obvious killer... We're not going to find anyone from it on this day.

Obvious killer or not, two people snuck in and a scuffle broke out. Seems like an attack to me. At least I can't think of a reason why Midnight would scuffle with other townies.

So at least two out of the six are likely bad guys. And there's a 25% chance that Thanos is on the list. Unless he's immune to DJ's ability.

If anyone has a viable alternate direction for the near future, now would be a good time to speak up.

[Slim Jim]

/bangs head on desk over and over.

You guys might as well be talking a foriegn language. :(

Mmhm. In the few posts I've made so far, I've tried not to suggest anything too stupid lest the knowledgable ones call me a retard :rolleyes: ...harder than it sounds when you don't really know much about the theme :p

We'll be waiting to here from you... Sunday. Maybe you can double your posts so far?

You can hear from me now, because I have the afternoon free [well, mostly]. From now until 2ish [about an hour] and then 4:30 onwards, I should be able to discuss things. I was going to be doing other things but one got cancelled and the other two I really don't want to do :p

So hear I am... willing to learn about comics :cool:

Hmm, think I'm going to have to just play off how others are playing, rather than trying to help get clues from write-ups.

[Slim Jim]

Active Players:
2. The Humanoid Typhoon
4. Crychon
8. The Shape
10. Foolinc
12. nZane
15. Gonvick
22. BIGJOSH
25. Ya its me
27. I Effn Rule
31. djthefunkchris
35. Minister Whitey

Those are the folk that I find ...interesting... at this point, for various reasons. Almost all are people I have a bad feeling on, but since we have barely even started there isn't so much to go on yet.

The one that stands out most for me is probably The Shape, just because I have known him for a while and the way he is playing reminds me a lot of whenever I've seen him as scum. But then, I always keep my eye on him in these games, because if he were to "get one over on me" I'd never hear the end of it :rolleyes:

[Arrows]

Those are the folk that I find ...interesting... at this point, for various reasons. Almost all are people I have a bad feeling on, but since we have barely even started there isn't so much to go on yet.

The one that stands out most for me is probably The Shape, just because I have known him for a while and the way he is playing reminds me a lot of whenever I've seen him as scum. But then, I always keep my eye on him in these games, because if he were to "get one over on me" I'd never hear the end of it :rolleyes:

Only person's name I see there that I find odd being there is DJ. Any reason DJ's on that list after claiming and all?

[Slim Jim]

Almost all are people I have a bad feeling on

He's not there for a bad reason... I just think the way he is playing is interesting. Different, perhaps, is a better word. He isn't playing as I would have normally expected from him but I guess it is sort of understandable, given that he thought he was being set-up after supposedly seeing himself, and then claiming because of that. Once he did that, regardless of whether he was mistaken or not, he had already given up too much to go back, I suppose. Still doesn't feel ...completely comfortable to me at the moment. I'm leaning towards being worried FOR him but after the last game where he completely played me, I have the tiniest nagging doubt at the back of my mind making me worried ABOUT him.

Either way, I'm assuming he's not telling the whole story... though if he was, I'd find that even more interesting.

[Moe Hunter]

Obvious killer or not, two people snuck in and a scuffle broke out. Seems like an attack to me. At least I can't think of a reason why Midnight would scuffle with other townies.

So at least two out of the six are likely bad guys. And there's a 25% chance that Thanos is on the list. Unless he's immune to DJ's ability.

If anyone has a viable alternate direction for the near future, now would be a good time to speak up.

Ask yourself, if this theory is actually true that Thanos can seek out gem holders (which it does seem that way from the writeup)... why would he look at someone who already jumped out and said "HEY, YOU WANT SOME GEMS? RIGHT HERE!"?

It's like in CVerse 2 - Machine was trying to find Marat Kohlav and would search every night... except for when Arrows basically told him in the thread "Hey, go get infinitywpi" and that was the end of that.

What I'm saying is, why would he look for something that he already knows to be true? That's why I think Thanos is NOT on DJ's list. I also think that there were more people there with good intentions than bad, and it would be rediculous to potentially out 5 townies just to bag one scum. Especially since we're 1-1 so far, and that's a damn good start considering we had at least 3 townies blurt themselves out right away.

[theoutlaw321]

Ask yourself, if this theory is actually true that Thanos can seek out gem holders (which it does seem that way from the writeup)... why would he look at someone who already jumped out and said "HEY, YOU WANT SOME GEMS? RIGHT HERE!"?

It's like in CVerse 2 - Machine was trying to find Marat Kohlav and would search every night... except for when Arrows basically told him in the thread "Hey, go get infinitywpi" and that was the end of that.

What I'm saying is, why would he look for something that he already knows to be true? That's why I think Thanos is NOT on DJ's list. I also think that there were more people there with good intentions than bad, and it would be rediculous to potentially out 5 townies just to bag one scum. Especially since we're 1-1 so far, and that's a damn good start considering we had at least 3 townies blurt themselves out right away.

Ok, going along with this logic then that would lend us to believe that there were multiple different people after the outed gem owners?

[theoutlaw321]

Active Players:
2. The Humanoid Typhoon
4. Crychon
8. The Shape
10. Foolinc
12. nZane
15. Gonvick
22. BIGJOSH
25. Ya its me
27. I Effn Rule
31. djthefunkchris
35. Minister Whitey

dj, the 6th on Slim's list here? :cool:

[Slim Jim]

Question: Thanos is suspected to be working individually, yes? I'm pretty sure, let's say 87%, that I read someone saying that was probably the case.

So there was TJ attacking Akki and then getting his brain munched by Venom, which would put two [presumably] mafia killers away from Midnight's house, meaning that unless there are three mafia groups, the only non-town killer at Midnight's would have been Thanos, there as an SK. So yeah, I'd agree with Moe about the whole Midnight situation; pressuring the six too much is probably going to end up revealing more town than non-town and make it easier for the mafia(s) to decide who to pick off and when. Though then I'm torn back to what else to actually do with this day phase and that seems the only lead we have... hmm.

Also, in a Superheroes game I played elsewhere, there was a Symbiote group that was in as a cult, that recruited people by infecting them. Now, I'm not saying that is exactly the case here, because it seemed TJ's brain being eaten was pretty fatal :p However, thought I'd throw that out there as an idea for another potential group.

[Moe Hunter]

Ok, going along with this logic then that would lend us to believe that there were multiple different people after the outed gem owners?

Well it sure seems that at least Apocalypse was after an outed gem owner, and now Venom has Apocalypse's gem. I have a feeling that gems aren't only useful to Thanos. In fact I would find it bizzare if he was the only one who could make any use of them. He might be one of the few strong enough to weild the Gauntlet without it *really* affecting him negatively, but certainly these are gems of great power... heh I wanna say people with great responsibility could use them... but I don't think Spidey's quite up to it.

[nZane]

So there was TJ attacking Akki and then getting his brain munched by Venom, which would put two [presumably] mafia killers away from Midnight's house, meaning that unless there are three mafia groups, the only non-town killer at Midnight's would have been Thanos, there as an SK. So yeah, I'd agree with Moe about the whole Midnight situation; pressuring the six too much is probably going to end up revealing more town than non-town and make it easier for the mafia(s) to decide who to pick off and when. Though then I'm torn back to what else to actually do with this day phase and that seems the only lead we have... hmm.I would imagine that Venom is working on his own here. Can't really see him as part of a group in this situation. Other than that, I agree with this.

I'm looking over a few things right now (and trying to get some actual work done, for once :p), so I'll hopefully be back with more in a bit.

[Moe Hunter]

Question: Thanos is suspected to be working individually, yes? I'm pretty sure, let's say 87%, that I read someone saying that was probably the case.

So there was TJ attacking Akki and then getting his brain munched by Venom, which would put two [presumably] mafia killers away from Midnight's house, meaning that unless there are three mafia groups, the only non-town killer at Midnight's would have been Thanos, there as an SK. So yeah, I'd agree with Moe about the whole Midnight situation; pressuring the six too much is probably going to end up revealing more town than non-town and make it easier for the mafia(s) to decide who to pick off and when. Though then I'm torn back to what else to actually do with this day phase and that seems the only lead we have... hmm.

Also, in a Superheroes game I played elsewhere, there was a Symbiote group that was in as a cult, that recruited people by infecting them. Now, I'm not saying that is exactly the case here, because it seemed TJ's brain being eaten was pretty fatal :p However, thought I'd throw that out there as an idea for another potential group.

The way I saw it, Venom would be an individual. Of course we can never discount anything about how many groups - there were what, 3 mafias and a cult in Forum Wars? And one of those mafias (DoA!) *could* have also recruited if Crychon got the Mod spot. Plus there were a ton of individuals to boot!

[theoutlaw321]

Well it sure seems that at least Apocalypse was after an outed gem owner, and now Venom has Apocalypse's gem. I have a feeling that gems aren't only useful to Thanos. In fact I would find it bizzare if he was the only one who could make any use of them. He might be one of the few strong enough to weild the Gauntlet without it *really* affecting him negatively, but certainly these are gems of great power... heh I wanna say people with great responsibility could use them... but I don't think Spidey's quite up to it.

Hold on I missed something. BRB

[Slim Jim]

Ah. Well I was just thinking Venom, Carnage, Toxin and Scream would make a good group but if he is indeed an Indy [and he has the purple text to support that] and Thanos is also Indy as suggested earlier [IIRC] then I can definitely see there being another group on top of the Alliance Of Evil, so going over that list of six again becomes a more appetising prospect.

[theoutlaw321]

Well it sure seems that at least Apocalypse was after an outed gem owner, and now Venom has Apocalypse's gem. I have a feeling that gems aren't only useful to Thanos. In fact I would find it bizzare if he was the only one who could make any use of them. He might be one of the few strong enough to weild the Gauntlet without it *really* affecting him negatively, but certainly these are gems of great power... heh I wanna say people with great responsibility could use them... but I don't think Spidey's quite up to it.

So when did Apocalypse gain a gem? Sorry if that is a noob question. I thought we determined that Doom had one and Thaenos had one from the intial writeup. :confused:

[Slim Jim]

If I followed it right, people were saying that Apocalypse was one of the people in the opening write-up instead of Doom, and that he got Iron Man's gem... then when Venom killed him, he got the gem. Think that's what was said during this phase.

Anyway, I need to go for a couple of hours or so, will try to get back on later, should be able to.

[BlueStar]

dj, the 6th on Slim's list here? :cool:

Hmmm...interesting question.

[Moe Hunter]

Yeah, I had a page or so of discussion with THT where he managed to convince me that it was Apocalypse and not Doom in the first wrietup. I still would expect Dr. Doom and Magneto to be in the game, but it seems as though the Reality gem went from Iron Man to Apocalypse to Venom.

[supermareo]

Ask yourself, if this theory is actually true that Thanos can seek out gem holders (which it does seem that way from the writeup)... why would he look at someone who already jumped out and said "HEY, YOU WANT SOME GEMS? RIGHT HERE!"?

It's like in CVerse 2 - Machine was trying to find Marat Kohlav and would search every night... except for when Arrows basically told him in the thread "Hey, go get infinitywpi" and that was the end of that.

What I'm saying is, why would he look for something that he already knows to be true? That's why I think Thanos is NOT on DJ's list. I also think that there were more people there with good intentions than bad, and it would be rediculous to potentially out 5 townies just to bag one scum. Especially since we're 1-1 so far, and that's a damn good start considering we had at least 3 townies blurt themselves out right away.

i agree here, based on the fact of how i would play the thanos role even if the gem he has got dosent give him help in this department why try to go afteer two people who he already knows have gems plus the fact there out in the open and are likely to be protected and/or watched it would make a lot more sence for him to try and find the other gems that are out there

[theoutlaw321]

Yeah, I had a page or so of discussion with THT where he managed to convince me that it was Apocalypse and not Doom in the first wrietup. I still would expect Dr. Doom and Magneto to be in the game, but it seems as though the Reality gem went from Iron Man to Apocalypse to Venom.

I apologize for all these questions. So I take it that Apocalypse wouldn't know anything about the gems? (Intial write up) Where as Doom would?

And I wonder why it doesn't say anything about Venom gaining the gem?

[Moe Hunter]

I would believe Apocalypse not knowing over Doom any day, and the dialogue actually fits him better too. I just couldn't figure out what he was there for since it made it seem as if he wasn't there for the gem OR Stark. I have to believe that he has his own motives. Well, had... but I'm sure his minions will be all too happy to carry on for him.

It is interesting about there being no mention of the gem changing hands. Maybe it's because the mods didn't want to interfere that much with the gameplay (and our Doom theory), or maybe we're still not on the right track...

[djthefunkchris]

dj, the 6th on Slim's list here? :cool:
/nod.

i agree here, based on the fact of how i would play the thanos role even if the gem he has got dosent give him help in this department why try to go afteer two people who he already knows have gems plus the fact there out in the open and are likely to be protected and/or watched it would make a lot more sence for him to try and find the other gems that are out there

What if the role calls for him to "search" one night (concentrate or whatever, meaning gain his target), then follow through the next. Would he waste time looking at other's?

Who targeted him that we did not see in the write-up...

The only person I think would be hidden, is the true one that actually protected or fought off the attacker's.

Interesting to note how you feel about Thanos Moe... You sure your not him?

[theoutlaw321]

dj, the 6th on Slim's list here? :cool:

/nod.






/nods then I am pretty sure.

[djthefunkchris]

/nods then I am pretty sure.

I was hoping you would catch it, because I'm torn with him. Not playing normal at all, but everyone got that new pimp game, so...

[Moe Hunter]

What if the role calls for him to "search" one night (concentrate or whatever, meaning gain his target), then follow through the next. Would he waste time looking at other's?

Interesting to note how you feel about Thanos Moe... You sure your not him?
Considering we have the same logic about him? As sure as you are that you're not him. The way I expressed it is such because I take issue with MNN and Akki basically needing to be carried through this game for the town to win. They gave themselves away, and could conceivably be targeted on any night, or every night.

I'm also as sure that I'm not Thanos as I am that I'm not Morgneto... sorry, Magneto. I'm most definitely Morgneto.

[Destiny]

I was hoping you would catch it, because I'm torn with him. Not playing normal at all, but everyone got that new pimp game, so...

Yeah, lucky buggers. I only have a PS2. I'm alot less active aswell, I just don't have much to add at this point.

Keeping up with things though. :)

[djthefunkchris]

Considering we have the same logic about him? As sure as you are that you're not him. The way I expressed it is such because I take issue with MNN and Akki basically needing to be carried through this game for the town to win. They gave themselves away, and could conceivably be targeted on any night, or every night.

I'm also as sure that I'm not Thanos as I am that I'm not Morgneto... sorry, Magneto. I'm most definitely Morgneto.

Darn, I was hoping for an easy one there.

There has to be something you can bring to the plate here, unless your the one that protected him from what looks to me as two people, and possibly a 3rd, unless you flew away after defending him...

It's either that or you were outside watching.

[Moe Hunter]

Darn, I was hoping for an easy one there.

There has to be something you can bring to the plate here, unless your the one that protected him from what looks to me as two people, and possibly a 3rd, unless you flew away after defending him...

It's either that or you were outside watching.

You've got me in there. Honestly I can't tell you anything you don't already know.

[djthefunkchris]

Yeah, lucky buggers. I only have a PS2. I'm alot less active aswell, I just don't have much to add at this point.

Keeping up with things though. :)

Allot of how I would take you right now, depends on your role on the other game ~Glares at Outlaw~.

Haven't played in enough games with you to really feel you out that way.

[theoutlaw321]

Allot of how I would take you right now, depends on your role on the other game ~Glares at Outlaw~.

Haven't played in enough games with you to really feel you out that way.

Is that in reference to Destiny's role in the last game?

[djthefunkchris]

You've got me in there. Honestly I can't tell you anything you don't already know.

Two of the six should be able to at least say "I can confirm what DJ said".

They were "Watcher's". Get those names off the list, we can move to a more 50/50 chance of lynching a scum from it.

Get the protector crossed off the list (which is possible that I held the name back to do just that, though it might be opposite), and then we have a 99.9% chance of nailing scum.

So far, not going my way at all, and I really wish I could just take it all back, because I have a feeling other's there aren't saying anything because I have, and figure that's all we need to know.

[djthefunkchris]

Is that in reference to Destiny's role in the last game?

Yes, don't tell me you posted it already (foot in mouth), because I haven't checked in the last 12 hours.... had this page opened here (even while I was at work).

[theoutlaw321]

Yes, don't tell me you posted it already (foot in mouth), because I haven't checked in the last 12 hours.... had this page opened here (even while I was at work).

Nope. On day 7. :o

[djthefunkchris]

Nope. On day 7. :o

Well, all I really want to know is was Destiny always town, and did he really screw up his investigation powers as a townie, by not posting enough in the thread?

[theoutlaw321]

Well, all I really want to know is was Destiny always town, and did he really screw up his investigation powers as a townie, by not posting enough in the thread?

That has been answered. Look at the bottom of the writeups for the nights that I have been over. :cool:

And Destiny won with you. :cool:

[theoutlaw321]

So back to this game. What are we going to do?

[BlueStar]

So back to this game. What are we going to do?

I really don't have bad vibes on Shape or Foolinc. Astil can't talk but that doesn't mean that he's town...still, going after a guy who can't defend himself isn't the best thing to do.

[djthefunkchris]

So back to this game. What are we going to do? Well, we could do this?

http://www.greydogsoftware.com/forum/showthread.php?p=410729#post410729

What do you think about the sixth person Outlaw? IT bugs me to make the decision alone, which is why I wanted you to find out (figured you would catch it).

[djthefunkchris]

That last day phase where Destiny wants to Vote, and doesn't even realise He just won the game (By being recruited that night) was probably the funniest moment I can think of.

[theoutlaw321]

Well, we could do this?

http://www.greydogsoftware.com/forum/showthread.php?p=410729#post410729

What do you think about the sixth person Outlaw? IT bugs me to make the decision alone, which is why I wanted you to find out (figured you would catch it).

Torn. If he is town then he would be exposed. Then again if he is scum then at least everyone would know who the 6th was. :cool:

[theoutlaw321]

That last day phase where Destiny wants to Vote, and doesn't even realise He just won the game (By being recruited that night) was probably the funniest moment I can think of.

Aussie?

[theoutlaw321]

Aussie?

Right Blue?

[Arrows]

Just got caught up again. Sorry I don't have much to add at the moment.

[The Aussie]

Aussie?
Yeah, that happened to me in the Real World Chaos game

[djthefunkchris]

The games I do not play in does not count. LOL.

[Destiny]

That last day phase where Destiny wants to Vote, and doesn't even realise He just won the game (By being recruited that night) was probably the funniest moment I can think of.

It was the first time I had got to the definite end of the game. I didn't know it was over. :o

[djthefunkchris]

Jeesh, I'm torn.... I have a feeling if you caught it though, so did someone else. That ease's my decision a bit, because I'm able to leave the information with someone.

That being said, even if he happens to be scum, there still has to be another one, and the other's are all out there.

I don't know how I feel about any that have taken the time to explain though. I do feel that if Shape was followed, and did anything bad, that Trypio would have been able to say so. So that kind of eliminates him.

Moe, who FOOLED ME last game, is not helping me much here. He say's I know what he knows, but he doesn't confirm his position/point of view.

FoolINC comes off non-scummy to me, but that doesn't mean he can't fool me (I mean, with a name like FOOL... Who knows).

Astil is emaciated... He was THERE... I can't help but to think he might have been one of the watcher's, which is why I can't get any confirmations on them..... He's one, someone else is the other (I'm hoping that's what MOE was saying).

What the hell was MJD talking about?

So that leaves the mystery one, and the other that didn't have anything to add............. YET.

[djthefunkchris]

It was the first time I had got to the definite end of the game. I didn't know it was over. :o

YOU WON!!!!!!!!! And it looked to me like you were upset about it, lol.

[trypio]

Anywho, I might as wlel just come out and say it - Trypio - I had a feeling you might be Destiny aka Irene Adler. Only conceivable problem with that theory is that she's dead, but her inclusion would be a useful clue in terms of what era we're really set in, or if elements are drawn from all over.
I'm not Destiny.

Trypio, I hate to bring this up again, but you never really answered the obvious question to this....

Why would these two individuals be "Town". You mentioned you targeted Shape because you thought he was town, as if finding scum might not be good for your health. Is this worded wrong or something?
Maybe I'm looking for them so I can stop them? I don't really know. I didn't realise it was worded as I'm looking for evil people, but thanks for clearing that up. :)

He asked because his target was on your list.

He wanted to clarify if he was or wasn't on the list. At least that is what it seemed like from reading it.

I also think that this is where some of the confusion with mjd came in. He knew that trypio didn't target Midnight, but Shape.
Exactly.



Anyway, not much new stuff we know right now. DJ, who were the 5 guys on your list that you outed again, I think I am missing one.

Astil, Foolinc, Shape, Crychon and ... ?


change vote: no vote

[djthefunkchris]

I'm not Destiny.


Maybe I'm looking for them so I can stop them? I don't really know. I didn't realise it was worded as I'm looking for evil people, but thanks for clearing that up. :)




Exactly.



Anyway, not much new stuff we know right now. DJ, who were the 5 guys on your list that you outed again, I think I am missing one.

Astil, Foolinc, Shape, Crychon and ... ?


change vote: no vote Post right before yours.

[Moe Hunter]

Jeesh, I'm torn.... I have a feeling if you caught it though, so did someone else. That ease's my decision a bit, because I'm able to leave the information with someone.

That being said, even if he happens to be scum, there still has to be another one, and the other's are all out there.

I don't know how I feel about any that have taken the time to explain though. I do feel that if Shape was followed, and did anything bad, that Trypio would have been able to say so. So that kind of eliminates him.

Moe, who FOOLED ME last game, is not helping me much here. He say's I know what he knows, but he doesn't confirm his position/point of view.

FoolINC comes off non-scummy to me, but that doesn't mean he can't fool me (I mean, with a name like FOOL... Who knows).

Astil is emaciated... He was THERE... I can't help but to think he might have been one of the watcher's, which is why I can't get any confirmations on them..... He's one, someone else is the other (I'm hoping that's what MOE was saying).

What the hell was MJD talking about?

So that leaves the mystery one, and the other that didn't have anything to add............. YET.

Hehe, I'm glad I managed to pull one over on you last game DJ, I think that was my one true accomplishment in my one run as scum. I can't say I was at full scum-seeking alert that game, but you certainly pulled a doosie over all of us with your mad bombing skills.

Essentially my not wanting to say anything further at this point, has been my logic all game - it's way too early for townies to start claiming themselves to death. Yes, we may have one or two scum involved at MNN's house, but in weeding them out we also expose potentially four or five strong townies, ripe for mafia picking. And with those very same strong townies being needed thanks to the Illuminated Illuminati, we certainly can't afford to all throw ourselves on the fire.

[djthefunkchris]

It is Day Phase 1. You have until 11:00AM EST/4:00PM GST on Wednesday April 30th to vote on a lynch. If at that time a majority is not reached, a no lynch will be declared.

With 36 players it is 19 to Lynch.





ShamelessPoser > 19 (The Humanoid Typhoon, djthefunkchris, THEDEMONSEED, Akki, Destiny, masterded, Mr T Jobs To Me, midnightnick, mjdgoldeneye, i effn rule, Arrows, Moe Hunter, Chrychon, The Aussie, BIGJOSH, Astil, nZane, JackalBane, jBergey_2005)
TheHumanoidTyphoon > 1 (ShamelessPoser)


Please let me know if I've made a mistake.

Four out of six. Just for those that keep track of votes.

[trypio]

Post right before yours.

I noticed :D

[djthefunkchris]

Hehe, I'm glad I managed to pull one over on you last game DJ, I think that was my one true accomplishment in my one run as scum. I can't say I was at full scum-seeking alert that game, but you certainly pulled a doosie over all of us with your mad bombing skills.

Essentially my not wanting to say anything further at this point, has been my logic all game - it's way too early for townies to start claiming themselves to death. Yes, we may have one or two scum involved at MNN's house, but in weeding them out we also expose potentially four or five strong townies, ripe for mafia picking. And with those very same strong townies being needed thanks to the Illuminated Illuminati, we certainly can't afford to all throw ourselves on the fire.

I don't want a name... I just want to know why you were there, what you were doing there... Protecting or watching?

Did you see anything I haven't covered (or anyone). Remember, I'm handicapped.... so I might not "Spot" something that has no smell, or presence I can feel, pick up on radar so to speak.

[djthefunkchris]

To add to what I'm saying, the "handicap" I have could lead us to some clue's now or later.

[djthefunkchris]

As for Trypio... You said you wanted to target someone you thought was town, and that was The Shape.

Are you now saying that your trying to find someone that is more then likely scum (going to cruch the town), and you targeted Shape...

You targeted Shape.... Sure it wasn't to protect him while he was doing something "BAD".

[Destiny]

YOU WON!!!!!!!!! And it looked to me like you were upset about it, lol.

Not upset at all, although I was very lucky to be recruited that night.

What trypio is saying doesn't add up.

Firstly he said something like "I targeted Shape because he's likely town"

Then he said "I'm trying to find people who can make bad things happen"

Now "Maybe I'm looking for them so I can stop them?"

Then why target Shape?

[trypio]

As for Trypio... You said you wanted to target someone you thought was town, and that was The Shape.

Are you now saying that your trying to find someone that is more then likely scum (going to cruch the town), and you targeted Shape...

You targeted Shape.... Sure it wasn't to protect him while he was doing something "BAD".

That was because then I though the wording meant that I had to find someone good, but since you're all fairly certain the wording hints at someone bad I'm going to change strategies.

[djthefunkchris]

It's what happened inside that I need to know. None of the other watcher's are verified, so that means we have nothing to go on as far as WHO exactly went into the house, and..

The Watcher's would know.

I think Astil is probably one of them. HE will need protection tonight, so that he can talk (since no one else wants to step up for the town).

I will say something that upsets me in every game that I am town. Everyone seems to want to wait to say what they know till it's close to the end (I guess they feel it gives them a better chance of surviving). IT OVERJOYS ME when I am scum. Why? Because we already have that information, and we ALWAYS learn who else has it without much problem, and we zero in on those people.

The only time that Scum was put on standstill was with the daytime investigation, which I doubt anyone will ever use again, without a way to hamper that role (Way to powerful in my opinion without having a way to block or manipulate).

[djthefunkchris]

That was because then I though the wording meant that I had to find someone good, but since you're all fairly certain the wording hints at someone bad I'm going to change strategies.

Do you know if the Shape (or yourself) went inside the house?

[trypio]

Do you know if the Shape (or yourself) went inside the house?

No, it said something like: "You've successfully checked out The Shape, he's not the one you foresaw.

[i effin rule]

Those are the folk that I find ...interesting... at this point, for various reasons. Almost all are people I have a bad feeling on, but since we have barely even started there isn't so much to go on yet.

The one that stands out most for me is probably The Shape, just because I have known him for a while and the way he is playing reminds me a lot of whenever I've seen him as scum. But then, I always keep my eye on him in these games, because if he were to "get one over on me" I'd never hear the end of it :rolleyes:

Uh oh...I'm on a list.


Anyhoot, I'm caught up. I'll be around off an on, might play some of that aformentioned "pimp" game. It's a nice way of saving myself from the stress of finals (next week).

[djthefunkchris]

No, it said something like: "You've successfully checked out The Shape, he's not the one you foresaw.

You have a different win condition then the town, right? You have to find someone, and then you win when your able to do whatever it is you do?

Meaning, that although he wasn't who you were looking for, he could be someone that is a threat to the town still. Mainly because that's not your goal (Could care less), if your goal is not to eliminate all threats to the town.

[djthefunkchris]

Uh oh...I'm on a list.


Anyhoot, I'm caught up. I'll be around off an on, might play some of that aformentioned "pimp" game. It's a nice way of saving myself from the stress of finals (next week).

I'm on the same list, lol.

[trypio]

I'll check.

[trypio]

Nope, I win when all threats have been eliminated.

[Destiny]

Nope, I win when all threats have been eliminated.

Makes you wonder what your reward is when you find this person.

[djthefunkchris]

Nope, I win when all threats have been eliminated.

The more important question is, Could the Shape still be a threat, although he wasn't who you were looking for?

Or do you know the answer to that (you can ask Imarevenant for clarification)?

[djthefunkchris]

Makes you wonder what your reward is when you find this person.

IF he is who I think he is, it fits his persona.

[trypio]

The more important question is, Could the Shape still be a threat, although he wasn't who you were looking for?

Or do you know the answer to that (you can ask Imarevenant for clarification)?

I'm not an investigator, so he could very well still be a threat, although I find it unlikely, because he was the one that spotted that town didn't have green role titles, but blue ones.

[djthefunkchris]

Just took a look at the latest couple of TEW08 updates... Just WOW, lol.

[trypio]

IF he is who I think he is, it fits his persona.

I can already say with 99% certainty that you are wrong, lol. Won't go in more detail, but you'll see when the time comes.

[djthefunkchris]

I'm not an investigator, so he could very well still be a threat, although I find it unlikely, because he was the one that spotted that town didn't have green role titles, but blue ones.

Umm... Didn't you realise that? I would think even the scum would have realised that.. Just saying.

I don't get a scum vibe from him either, but I would have liked to know if he was inside or watching.

So let's say that The Shape is innocent, and the one I haven't mentioned is innocent, and Astil is innocent....

That leaves three.

Crychon
Foolinc
Moe Hunter

[Destiny]

Umm... Didn't you realise that? I would think even the scum would have realised that.. Just saying.

I don't get a scum vibe from him either, but I would have liked to know if he was inside or watching.

So let's say that The Shape is innocent, and the one I haven't mentioned is innocent, and Astil is innocent....

That leaves three.

Crychon
Foolinc
Moe Hunter

At the moment it looks as if, with the time we have left, we either continue pushing foolinc into role-claiming, then decide to believe him or not, or we reach a no-lynch.

If you feel we can push alot of votes on one of the others, I'm all for it, if you are confident enough.

Just saying.

[djthefunkchris]

I feel as though I have been pretty straight up as to desiring the knowledge of who was watching, and who was not.

So far, I feel that this has been avoided. I don't know if that's because of self preservation, or if it's from not being able to (Astil), and not being as active in the game (The one I haven't mentioned, or foolInc).

I'm hoping the one I haven't mentioned was "Protecting" obviously. That's why I haven't mentioned him. Something he said made me think this way. The fact that no one has stepped up and said "Chris, your wrong." Kind of confirms that.

[trypio]

Umm... Didn't you realise that? I would think even the scum would have realised that.. Just saying.

I don't get a scum vibe from him either, but I would have liked to know if he was inside or watching.

So let's say that The Shape is innocent, and the one I haven't mentioned is innocent, and Astil is innocent....

That leaves three.

Crychon
Foolinc
Moe Hunter
I never said that I knew what his alignment was.

[Destiny]

I feel as though I have been pretty straight up as to desiring the knowledge of who was watching, and who was not.

So far, I feel that this has been avoided. I don't know if that's because of self preservation, or if it's from not being able to (Astil), and not being as active in the game (The one I haven't mentioned, or foolInc).

I'm hoping the one I haven't mentioned was "Protecting" obviously. That's why I haven't mentioned him. Something he said made me think this way. The fact that no one has stepped up and said "Chris, your wrong." Kind of confirms that.

You're not confident enough to put a definite vote down, though?

[trypio]

I feel as though I have been pretty straight up as to desiring the knowledge of who was watching, and who was not.

So far, I feel that this has been avoided. I don't know if that's because of self preservation, or if it's from not being able to (Astil), and not being as active in the game (The one I haven't mentioned, or foolInc).

I'm hoping the one I haven't mentioned was "Protecting" obviously. That's why I haven't mentioned him. Something he said made me think this way. The fact that no one has stepped up and said "Chris, your wrong." Kind of confirms that.

That's because we don't know who you're talking about. :D

[djthefunkchris]

At the moment it looks as if, with the time we have left, we either continue pushing foolinc into role-claiming, then decide to believe him or not, or we reach a no-lynch.

If you feel we can push alot of votes on one of the others, I'm all for it, if you are confident enough.

Just saying.
I'm confident enough that I think we could lynch anyone on my list, if I pushed for it, and they refuse to claim.

However, I am NOT confident enough that it is the right thing to do. In my eyes, we have a 50/50 chance of hitting scum. I would just like to get those odds' narrowed down a bit, since I'm pretty sure THEY COULD BE, if people would step up their game.

[The Humanoid Typhoon]

We're at the T-16 hour mark right now too, so I hope he wakes up and claims soon. If he doesn't, we may not have time to organize much against anyone else.We have almost 13 hours, man.

[djthefunkchris]

That's because we don't know who you're talking about. :D

You know whoever protects has to target the person they protect. You know the other five names. ONE of the six has to be the protector. If I already named the protector, then the one I have not named could be the scummiest of them all.

[djthefunkchris]

You know whoever protects has to target the person they protect. You know the other five names. ONE of the six has to be the protector. If I already named the protector, then the one I have not named could be the scummiest of them all.

I think Outlaw knows who I am talking about, I'm hoping that someone else has caught on as well (someone specific). This means two people could make the call if it is necessary while I'm at work today (which was what I was worried about, someone to be able to carry on without me being here... I'm not worried about Nighttime, I have no fear for a reason).

[trypio]

You know whoever protects has to target the person they protect. You know the other five names. ONE of the six has to be the protector. If I already named the protector, then the one I have not named could be the scummiest of them all.

Indeed, what is it that differentiates that one guy's actions from the other, though?

[Blasphemywebleed]

I dont know anything that happened at Nicks so I cant comment just now.

[Destiny]

I think Outlaw knows who I am talking about, I'm hoping that someone else has caught on as well (someone specific). This means two people could make the call if it is necessary while I'm at work today (which was what I was worried about, someone to be able to carry on without me being here... I'm not worried about Nighttime, I have no fear for a reason).

It's good that we have this lead.

The worrying thing for me is, if we didn't have dj's list, we'd have even less to go on.

You have no fear whatsoever?

[djthefunkchris]

Indeed, what is it that differentiates that one guy's actions from the other, though?

The fact that he wasn't available as I listed people. I had a hunch. Other then that, nothing.

So... If he's the protector, would you really want me to out him?

I don't think there were two protector's there.

I don't think there were more then three people that were on our side there.

I think Astil is a watcher... (HUNCH). If not, then the watcher's are really letting the town down.

[djthefunkchris]

I dont know anything that happened at Nicks so I cant comment just now.

You don't know what happened at nicks, perhaps you know something about one of the people listed?

[djthefunkchris]

It's good that we have this lead.

The worrying thing for me is, if we didn't have dj's list, we'd have even less to go on.

You have no fear whatsoever?

Kind of hard to sneak up on me.

[Moe Hunter]

It's what happened inside that I need to know. None of the other watcher's are verified, so that means we have nothing to go on as far as WHO exactly went into the house, and..

The Watcher's would know.

Speaking of which, I wonder if Uatu "The Watcher" is in. I know how I would write his role if I put him in (which I might for Civil War). It'll be interesting if he is in whether my thoughts match up to his role here.

I feel as though I have been pretty straight up as to desiring the knowledge of who was watching, and who was not.

So far, I feel that this has been avoided. I don't know if that's because of self preservation, or if it's from not being able to (Astil), and not being as active in the game (The one I haven't mentioned, or foolInc).

I'm hoping the one I haven't mentioned was "Protecting" obviously. That's why I haven't mentioned him. Something he said made me think this way. The fact that no one has stepped up and said "Chris, your wrong." Kind of confirms that.
I quoted the wrong one here, but you said you didn't want a name, but an occupation? Guess what means more here, especially since there's only a handful of people who would even recognise half the names here?

It's bad enough we have this nice little list of protectors and watchers all neatly packaged up for the mafias, now you want us to specify exactly what it is we do? I'm sorry, but that's not happening. Not from me. While I'm pretty confident in myself, I am not bulletproof, so you won't find me jumping around like the guy we're all so worried about saving, exclaiming what I can do.

[Destiny]

Kind of hard to sneak up on me.

One less protector we need to worry about then.

[sprinklefurball]

vote:supermareo

Let me just call it a very proveable hunch...;)

[Moe Hunter]

vote:supermareo

Let me just call it a very proveable hunch...;)

Could this finally be a new lead? Interesting.

[djthefunkchris]

Speaking of which, I wonder if Uatu "The Watcher" is in. I know how I would write his role if I put him in (which I might for Civil War). It'll be interesting if he is in whether my thoughts match up to his role here.


I quoted the wrong one here, but you said you didn't want a name, but an occupation? Guess what means more here, especially since there's only a handful of people who would even recognise half the names here?

It's bad enough we have this nice little list of protectors and watchers all neatly packaged up for the mafias, now you want us to specify exactly what it is we do? I'm sorry, but that's not happening. Not from me. While I'm pretty confident in myself, I am not bulletproof, so you won't find me jumping around like the guy we're all so worried about saving, exclaiming what I can do.

I'm asking for information Moe. You don't have to say anything I suppose, but I'm pretty sure the Mafia don't care one way or the other the occupation, they are both equally bad for them. Guess who I would pick if I were mafia? We all know Mafia ussually worry about in game credibility moreso then abilities.....

If I were Mafia, Outlaw, Me, You, nZane, IER, Derek_b, and maybe a couple other's would be the people I would be really looking into. You would too.

In my opinion, out of the people I listed, I would choose you if I were mafia, to roleblock or kill. Just on skills alone. Your a Veteran, your smart, you are able to analyse and put things together other's might miss.... and you have an ability.

[djthefunkchris]

vote:supermareo

Let me just call it a very proveable hunch...;)

Could this finally be a new lead? Interesting.

Moor is needed before I let go of our conversation. Too conveniant if you ask me.

[Moe Hunter]

I'm asking for information Moe. You don't have to say anything I suppose, but I'm pretty sure the Mafia don't care one way or the other the occupation, they are both equally bad for them. Guess who I would pick if I were mafia? We all know Mafia ussually worry about in game credibility moreso then abilities.....

If I were Mafia, Outlaw, Me, You, nZane, IER, Derek_b, and maybe a couple other's would be the people I would be really looking into. You would too.

In my opinion, out of the people I listed, I would choose you if I were mafia, to roleblock or kill. Just on skills alone. Your a Veteran, your smart, you are able to analyse and put things together other's might miss.... and you have an ability.
Absolutely I see that. I've told you every piece of information I have, which is to say no more than you already have. On prinicple alone, I will not divulge my role at this stage of the game. There may come a time where it becomes necessary, but this is not it.

[djthefunkchris]

One less protector we need to worry about then.

I'm not a protector.

[Destiny]

vote:supermareo

Let me just call it a very proveable hunch...;)

Why have you waited until now?

[Moe Hunter]

I'm not a protector.
That's not what he was saying.

And as far as our conversation goes, I can only keep it up until Lost finishes downloading, then I'm out. I should have gone to sleep four hours ago in all honesty.

[djthefunkchris]

Absolutely I see that. I've told you every piece of information I have, which is to say no more than you already have. On prinicple alone, I will not divulge my role at this stage of the game. There may come a time where it becomes necessary, but this is not it.

You sound just like you did last game, you know that don't you?

[Moe Hunter]

You sound just like you did last game, you know that don't you?

Yes, I'm aware of that. Comes with the territory of being under the laser on Day 2. Go read RWC and you'll see the same sort of thing, with a twist since my rolename was revealed for me.

[sprinklefurball]

Why have you waited until now?
I wanted to wait to see if he replied to a suggestion I made earlier, and he just disappeared.

[djthefunkchris]

I wanted to wait to see if he replied to a suggestion I made earlier, and he just disappeared.

Explain.

[djthefunkchris]

Yes, I'm aware of that. Comes with the territory of being under the laser on Day 2. Go read RWC and you'll see the same sort of thing, with a twist since my rolename was revealed for me.

Did you know what I knew already?

[Destiny]

I'm not a protector.

I know. I meant one less protector to have to protect you.

[sprinklefurball]

ok caught up ish, gonna have to read back again as iv only skimmed over most of it really

Guys I have a bad feeling about whoever punisher targeted... as there is only one person that has anything to do with stained glass that I could find...
http://en.marveldatabase.com/Stained_Glass_Scarlet

Stained Glass?

[djthefunkchris]

I know. I meant one less protector to have to protect you.

I figured it out when someone said that's not what you meant.

Yeah, don't worry about me, unless they all gang up on me or something, I think I will be fine... Heck, maybe even if they all gang up on me. I don't think anyone is powerfull enough to take me out yet (Skilled enough at being stealth in many different ways).

[Moe Hunter]

Did you know what I knew already?

Wouldn't that give it away, some? If you must pry something out of me, I will say that no, I did not know everything you knew before you posted it. Now, with a scant few minutes left on this download, I'm interested in an actual potential lead that doesn't go in circles.

[Destiny]

Either you're trying to split the votes in the hope that neither will get lynched, are throwing mareo under a bus in place of foolinc, or you're telling the truth.

[sprinklefurball]

Either you're trying to split the votes in the hope that neither will get lynched, are throwing mareo under a bus in place of foolinc, or you're telling the truth.
I just want to get a villain lynched. Would I claim this if we were that sure that he is in the game, especially seeing as he's in the writeup?

[Moe Hunter]

Hooah, Sprinkle's The Punisher?! Sweet deal. And he took a look at Supermareo by the looks of it... This should definitely be interesting!

[djthefunkchris]

He just claimed.

[djthefunkchris]

Wouldn't that give it away, some? If you must pry something out of me, I will say that no, I did not know everything you knew before you posted it. Now, with a scant few minutes left on this download, I'm interested in an actual potential lead that doesn't go in circles.

I have to leave as well. If you were in or outside of the house probably would have been a better question..... That way your not really saying what your ability was (as it could be many different things, from tracker, to watcher, to protector, to whatever). But it would also give me a clear idea about the one I'm kind of protecting.

[djthefunkchris]

Hooah, Sprinkle's The Punisher?! Sweet deal. And he took a look at Supermareo by the looks of it... This should definitely be interesting!

I would say that he can slip back out of the avator, but I guess it won't make any difference now.

[Destiny]

I just want to get a villain lynched. Would I claim this if we were that sure that he is in the game, especially seeing as he's in the writeup?


/nod
Vote: supermareo

I just hope it's not too late.

[foolinc]

Just got caught up, and while I am going to have to take a look at the "Punisher" write-up and sprinkles (and super's) post, I think this claim could have legs.

[djthefunkchris]

This isn't the monster I'm looking for. Time to ask around.

We'll see what tomorrow brings. Doesn't say it's not a Monster, just not the RIGHT monster.

Vote:Supermareo

[djthefunkchris]

Just got caught up, and while I am going to have to take a look at the "Punisher" write-up and sprinkles (and super's) post, I think this claim could have legs.

Of course you would:rolleyes: .

It shouldn't be too hard, not too many posts by either of them.

[The Humanoid Typhoon]

Vote: supermareo

And yet another role claim. *Sighs.*

[Moe Hunter]

Doesn't say it's not a Monster, just not the RIGHT monster.

Vote:Supermareo

I swear torrents will be the death of me. Even EZTV is crapping out about 7 minutes into the show, lagging like crazy.

So here's my last post 'fore I'm to bed. I had the same thought as you DJ on this one - much like where they weren't the droids they were looking for, they were still droids.

Vote: Supermareo

[foolinc]

Reread the write-up and it does imply that he found a "monster."

Vote: supermareo

[djthefunkchris]

Vote: supermareo

And yet another role claim. *Sighs.*

Look at it this way, more targets to decide on... Makes it kind of hard to figure out which one to go after.

I don't think I've ever claimed without being on the lynching stand. Only one reason I did this time (and it's not the mistake). I would have claimed at some point anyways this time, as I'm sure someone might have wasted a good ability on me, that would obviously be better placed on someone else.

[i effin rule]

Nice job sprink.

Vote: supermareo

[The Humanoid Typhoon]

It's not that hard when you know their abilities. I'm not upset about your claim as you got totally confused. However, they now know two Illuminati members, Nick Fury, Daredevil, The Punisher, some guy with visions, and I'm pretty sure a protector was hinted.

[djthefunkchris]

It's not that hard when you know their abilities. I'm not upset about your claim as you got totally confused. However, they now know two Illuminati members, Nick Fury, Daredevil, The Punisher, some guy with visions, and I'm pretty sure a protector was hinted.

/nod.

I have to go to work now. Be back in 8 hours (or so).

[The Shape]

Did I misread(it was right after the writeup) aren't most of the AoE female?

I'm not sure, but if that's the case note that Astil is female...

And lest we forget that the third one is connected to the one where Astil gets drained.

...Which could mean that's significant.

So the attack on Akki is very accurate, yet the attack on Midnightnick, is totally hazy.

Maybe because with the info you got on Midnight, if everything was specific it'd be too much of a giveaway? Whereas nobody aside from those directly involved had inside knowledge about Akki, so more was detailed.

Yeah, that name. Although we have no new real clues on the mafia, I do have some good news. Apocalypse was the mafia don.

Don't care what Wiki says...I don't think the don would be out attacking people.

no one died.

Which makes the way he phrased it interesting.

We have a list of 6 people with one of them being scum, best to concentrate on that just now.

There's a list of 34 people on the first page...I prefer to concentrate on all of them. ;)

The one that stands out most for me is probably The Shape, just because I have known him for a while and the way he is playing reminds me a lot of whenever I've seen him as scum. But then, I always keep my eye on him in these games, because if he were to "get one over on me" I'd never hear the end of it :rolleyes:

Likewise. :rolleyes:

Ask yourself, if this theory is actually true that Thanos can seek out gem holders (which it does seem that way from the writeup)... why would he look at someone who already jumped out and said "HEY, YOU WANT SOME GEMS? RIGHT HERE!"?

Search then kill, perhaps? Think I saw DJ suggest such a thing but a role like that definitely isn't out of the question.

Kind of hard to sneak up on me.

Which makes me think there must be some other sort of limitation to your role...

vote:supermareo

Let me just call it a very proveable hunch...;)

Ok then, can't let that go to waste.

Vote: supermareo

[Lostrelms]

Caught up again.

Didnt vote on day one, because i was leaning towards believing the Cuckoo claim.

Today however, is different.

Because either SPrinkle is teling the truth, we lynch Mareo, and he is scum..

Or Mareo is town, and Sprinkle gets the noose tomorrow.

Vote: Supermareo

[Imarevenant]

It is now Day Phase 2. You have until 12:00AM EST/5:00AM GST on Saturday May 3rd to vote on a lynch. If at that time a majority is not reached, a no lynch will be declared.

With 34 players it is 18 to Lynch.


Derek B > 1 (Arrows)
Foolinc > 5 (Derek B, mjdgoldeneye, THEDEMONSEED, Akki, Destiny)
Supermareo > 8 (Sprinklefurball, djthefunkchris, The Humanoid Typhoon, Moe Hunter, Foolinc, I Effn Rule, The Shape, Lostrelms)


Destiny, your vote is still on Foolinc, until you use Change Vote:

[Slim Jim]

Aaaaand I'm back.

I'm on the same list, lol.

For different reasons. ;)


Vote: supermareo

Seems simple. Sprinkle is confident enough, and if he's lying then he's just set himself up to get hanged tomorrow.

[jbergey_2005]

Well sounds like Sprinkle is willing to sacrifice himself if he is wrong on this therefore
Vote:Supermareo

I'm not sure what to think of the DJ' situation as of yet. Without doubt there was scum there its just too hard to get to the bottom of it right now without too much information being released. I know what I would be looking out for tonight if I was DJ tonight.

I would tend to agree with a couple of other posts awhile back as well. I doubt Thanos would jump right into the middle of all the action on night 1. Seems like too bold of a play.

[The Humanoid Typhoon]

Don't care what Wiki says...I don't think the don would be out attacking people.Apocalypse leads that group. You don't have believe Wikipedia alone.

http://www.marvel.com/universe/Apocalypse_(En_Sabah_Nur)

Even Marvel.com will you tell that. TJ didn't seem to be that good of a player and considering what we discussed about the gems, he likely wanted them for himself. Which makes me think there must be some other sort of limitation to your role...He could've still been lynched and doesn't know who targeted who or for what.

[Imarevenant]

It is now Day Phase 2. You have until 12:00AM EST/5:00AM GST on Saturday May 3rd to vote on a lynch. If at that time a majority is not reached, a no lynch will be declared.

With 34 players it is 18 to Lynch.


Derek B > 1 (Arrows)
Foolinc > 5 (Derek B, mjdgoldeneye, THEDEMONSEED, Akki, Destiny)
Supermareo > 10 (Sprinklefurball, djthefunkchris, The Humanoid Typhoon, Moe Hunter, Foolinc, I Effn Rule, The Shape, Lostrelms, Slim Jim, Jbergy_2005)


Destiny, your vote is still on Foolinc, until you use Change Vote:
Edit/Delete Message

[supermareo]

blimey guys talk about barking up the wrong tree, all of this becuase i reside in a church, just a pitty i wasnt crawling about at night eh?

[The Shape]

Sprinkle, what exactly did you get told?

[Slim Jim]

Eeeeh... sprinkle, super, full cases for and against the current lynch please.

[supermareo]

Eeeeh... sprinkle, super, full cases for and against the current lynch please.


im n ot sure exactly what the case is aginst me other than sprinkle is looking for a 'monster' of some sort checked me out and the writr up mentions stined glass, because of that sprinkle has jumped to the conclusion im somebody else when im simply in a church asking god for forgiveness hope i dont have to draw people a map with X marks the spot on it just yet

[Slim Jim]

Doesn't help that sprinkle has disappeared...

More information needed from him, to be honest. Well, more definitive, unwavering information that makes it crystal clear that he KNOWS supermareo is non-town.

[theoutlaw321]

Vote:supermareo

[The Humanoid Typhoon]

Eeeeh... sprinkle, super, full cases for and against the current lynch please.Sprinkle is the Punisher. In the write up (War Journal part), he found a "monster", but it wasn't the one he was looking for.

[trypio]

vote: supermareo

[The Shape]

Sprinkle is the Punisher. In the write up (War Journal part), he found a "monster", but it wasn't the one he was looking for.

I'd like to hear the PM he got paraphrased...

[supermareo]

i have to say im finding this bandwagon very illuminating concidering its speed with so little information to convict me

[Imarevenant]

It is now Day Phase 2. You have until 12:00AM EST/5:00AM GST on Saturday May 3rd to vote on a lynch. If at that time a majority is not reached, a no lynch will be declared.

With 34 players it is 18 to Lynch.


Derek B > 1 (Arrows)
Foolinc > 5 (Derek B, mjdgoldeneye, THEDEMONSEED, Akki, Destiny)
Supermareo > 12 (Sprinklefurball, djthefunkchris, The Humanoid Typhoon, Moe Hunter, Foolinc, I Effn Rule, The Shape, Lostrelms, Slim Jim, Jbergy_2005, theoutlaw321, trypio)

[BlueStar]

Right, this is interesting...we spend 24 hours going in circles with DJ and 5-6 others, and suddenly someone springs a trap to another one. Doesn't add up. Especially if you saw all the lurkers around.

Then again, I'm tempted to believe Sprinkle...I'm online for the next hour. Can't help but feel something is...off.

[nZane]

War Journal

Micro got a tip about a crazed killer making his way to New York from the west coast. This is before all hell broke loose and chaos swept the city. There are about a million of these damn super powered morons here now. Whatever. Let them kill each other, while they show off their "gifts." I'll continue to protect the average guy from the monsters like the one I'm searching for.

I asked around, talked to people that know these things. Seems there has been reports of someone, or something, frightening the people of this particular neighborhood. Good place to start, but, I certainly didn't think the trail would lead me here. Nice place, if you go for that sort of thing. I don't.

Quick survey of the surrounding area and things are all clear; time for a closer look.

I approached the perimeter careful not to make a sound. Peak in through the window, hard to see through stained glass, but I catch enough to know who I'm looking at.

This isn't the monster I'm looking for. Time to ask around.

We'll see what tomorrow brings.Is that line I've quoted in red the only reason people are voting for Super? Because I've read that back to myself over and over again and I don't even remotely see how that implicates that his target is a monster. He's looking for a monster. He sees someone in the church that he recognizes and he immediately knows that "(t)his isn't the monster I'm looking for."

Someone mind explaining that one to me? And would someone mind telling me why the mods would give the town something so obvious? And would someone mind explaining the massive influx of bandwagon jumpers?

[BlueStar]

DJ, if you're here...thoughts about this one?

[Slim Jim]

Sprinkle is the Punisher. In the write up (War Journal part), he found a "monster", but it wasn't the one he was looking for.

Well even I can think of one or two monstrous beings from the Marvel universe off the top of my head that would be town so that isn't completely conclusive.

[BlueStar]

Nzane, I agree and I can see at least 2 or 3 people in this bandwagon who voted for Shameless after he claimed, non mon cher?

[Slim Jim]

The count is at 12 already, so in the interest of not letting this vote get rushed through before it's been ironed out a little...

Change Vote: No Vote

[i effin rule]

Just to be safe since I think I caught what I did.

Change Vote: No Vote

I still want more info from you mareo.

[nZane]

vote:supermareo

Let me just call it a very proveable hunch...;)I wanted to wait to see if he replied to a suggestion I made earlier, and he just disappeared.Stained Glass?I just want to get a villain lynched. Would I claim this if we were that sure that he is in the game, especially seeing as he's in the writeup?This is every post Sprinkle has made in this game today. Everything else has been assumed by other people. Again, I'd really like an explanation.

[supermareo]

Just to be safe since I think I caught what I did.

Change Vote: No Vote

I still want more info from you mareo.

what info would you like, im willing to full claim if necessary but would prefer not to as of yet

[i effin rule]

This is every post Sprinkle has made in this game today. Everything else has been assumed by other people. Again, I'd really like an explanation.

What is being assumed?

[nZane]

Supermareo > 12 (Sprinklefurball, djthefunkchris, The Humanoid Typhoon, Moe Hunter, Foolinc, I Effn Rule, The Shape, Lostrelms, Slim Jim, Jbergy_2005, theoutlaw321, trypio)Just quoting this for myself. Makes it easier to look at later on if I can find it by searching through my own posts.

[BlueStar]

Considering your situation....
/shrugs

[The Shape]

I interpreted it as him having done an investigation of sorts but if he's basing it off the write-up I think he's wrong. The fact that he's disappeared so quickly doesn't please me and what mareo is saying definitely adds up.

Change Vote: No Vote

[Slim Jim]

It's being assumed that super is some sort of destructive evil monster because of how one clause in the write-up was interpreted by a couple of people.

[i effin rule]

what info would you like, im willing to full claim if necessary but would prefer not to as of yet

Lambchop mean anything to you?

[Imarevenant]

It is now Day Phase 2. You have until 12:00AM EST/5:00AM GST on Saturday May 3rd to vote on a lynch. If at that time a majority is not reached, a no lynch will be declared.

With 34 players it is 18 to Lynch.


Derek B > 1 (Arrows)
Foolinc > 5 (Derek B, mjdgoldeneye, THEDEMONSEED, Akki, Destiny)
Supermareo > 9 (Sprinklefurball, djthefunkchris, The Humanoid Typhoon, Moe Hunter, Foolinc, Lostrelms, Jbergy_2005, theoutlaw321, trypio)

[i effin rule]

It's being assumed that super is some sort of destructive evil monster because of how one clause in the write-up was interpreted by a couple of people.

Perhaps to some degree, but sprinkle did say it was a "proveable hunch" that mareo was a villain.

[supermareo]

Lambchop mean anything to you?


not that im aware of:confused:

[nZane]

What is being assumed?I just posted Sprinkle's quotes. So, if it's not in there, it is being assumed.

[i effin rule]

not that im aware of:confused:



Are you sure?
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lambchop_%28band%29

[nZane]

Perhaps to some degree, but sprinkle did say it was a "proveable hunch" that mareo was a villain.He said this as he was voting for him. That seems like a pretty good way to prove it.

[supermareo]

Are you sure?
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lambchop_%28band%29


/nods

[nZane]

Are you sure?
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lambchop_%28band%29Ok, that was pretty damn subtle. Didn't have a chance to pick up on what you were saying before that link.

[i effin rule]

Ok, that was pretty damn subtle. Didn't have a chance to pick up on what you were saying before that link.

I do what I can :cool:

[Slim Jim]

I'm still around but I'm doing a few odd jobs now, so I'll only be checking in every now and then until something grabs my attention...

[BlueStar]

First hint I got from the start...lol. Yes...

Mareo, are you a Miller?

[supermareo]

no im not a miller

[nZane]

This should be fun! :D
/nod
Vote: supermareo

I just hope it's not too late.Bandwagon.

Doesn't say it's not a Monster, just not the RIGHT monster.

Vote:SupermareoThis logic is understandable. And I'm not too concerned about him. ;)

Vote: supermareo

And yet another role claim. *Sighs.*Bandwagon.

I swear torrents will be the death of me. Even EZTV is crapping out about 7 minutes into the show, lagging like crazy.

So here's my last post 'fore I'm to bed. I had the same thought as you DJ on this one - much like where they weren't the droids they were looking for, they were still droids.

Vote: SupermareoAgain, the logic is understandable. Still a bit alarming, though.

Reread the write-up and it does imply that he found a "monster."

Vote: supermareoSame as Moe. The fact that both Fool and Moe were on DJ's list could be telling.

Nice job sprink.

Vote: supermareoBandwagon.

Ok then, can't let that go to waste.

Vote: supermareoBandwagon.

Caught up again.

Didnt vote on day one, because i was leaning towards believing the Cuckoo claim.

Today however, is different.

Because either SPrinkle is teling the truth, we lynch Mareo, and he is scum..

Or Mareo is town, and Sprinkle gets the noose tomorrow.

Vote: SupermareoWilling to test one to prove the other. Understandable.

Vote: supermareo

Seems simple. Sprinkle is confident enough, and if he's lying then he's just set himself up to get hanged tomorrow.Same as Lost.

Well sounds like Sprinkle is willing to sacrifice himself if he is wrong on this therefore
Vote:SupermareoSame as Lost and Slim.

Vote:supermareoBandwagon.

vote: supermareoAnd bandwagon.

So, there's a list for some of you more adventurous types. I need to get back to work. :p

[The Shape]

lol nZane, what else do you expect people to do? It seemed pretty clear that he could PROVE that mareo was scum...when someone just comes out and claims from nowhere like that, especially late in the phase, it's natural to go along with it rather than make a point of not doing so in order to pick apart those who do.

I'm sure there's scum amongst that list, though.

[nZane]

As I've said before, based on the write-up it looks as if Punisher is looking for someone in particular. So, unless Sprinkle says otherwise, I'd be surprised if he got a definitive result on Super. Which means that this entire bandwagon was based off a tenuous interpretation of the write-up. Given that I'd be shocked if the mods would give up a bad guy that easily, it seems pretty likely that we may have at least a baddie or two amongst the voters.

[i effin rule]

This should be fun! :D
Bandwagon.

This logic is understandable. And I'm not too concerned about him. ;)

Bandwagon.

Again, the logic is understandable. Still a bit alarming, though.

Same as Moe. The fact that both Fool and Moe were on DJ's list could be telling.

Bandwagon.

Bandwagon.

Willing to test one to prove the other. Understandable.

Same as Lost.

Same as Lost and Slim.

Bandwagon.

And bandwagon.

So, there's a list for some of you more adventurous types. I need to get back to work. :p

So it's just a bandwagon whenever someone votes based on someone else's reasoning? If I can't vote for someone unless I personally have something less it be called bandwagoning, then I don't think we'll get very many lynches in this game. I was well aware of what was going on at the time.

[nZane]

lol nZane, what else do you expect people to do?Ideally, I'd expect people to think. But that's probably asking too much.

[BlueStar]

I'm tempted to vote on one of the bandwagonners but I'm going to check back and compare the list to see if DJ's nr. 6 is in there...

[nZane]

So it's just a bandwagon whenever someone votes based on someone else's reasoning? If I can't vote for someone unless I personally have something less it be called bandwagoning, then I don't think we'll get very many lynches in this game. I was well aware of what was going on at the time.Touched a nerve, did I?

[theoutlaw321]

nZane are you tied to supermareo?

[BlueStar]

Touched a nerve, did I?

IER isn't the one I was looking for but he'll do for now...

[The Humanoid Typhoon]

Is that line I've quoted in red the only reason people are voting for Super? Because I've read that back to myself over and over again and I don't even remotely see how that implicates that his target is a monster. He's looking for a monster. He sees someone in the church that he recognizes and he immediately knows that "(t)his isn't the monster I'm looking for."

Someone mind explaining that one to me?Yes, that's the reason. He doesn't say, "This isn't who I'm looking for" or "This isn't the person I'm looking for" or even "This isn't the guy I'm looking for". By using the word monster, he's acknowledging that person is a monster, just not one he's looking for.

Sure, there are monstrous looking heroes in Marvel, but that's not how the Punisher thinks. He hunts down criminals and he does consider factor in the person's causes. In Civil War, he joined the Anti-Registeration forces despite them technically being criminals with his reasoning being "the other guys started enlisting known thieves and convicted killers".

[BlueStar]

nZane are you tied to supermareo?

With that roleclaim, I can see what you're going for...

[supermareo]

i'll tell ya the two that bother me the most, the last two trypio and outlaw, both voted when i was around both voted with no reasoning of there own, neither of them questioned me, and neither stuck around after theyd voted

[BlueStar]

i'll tell ya the two that bother me the most, the last two trypio and outlaw, both voted when i was around both voted with no reasoning of there own, neither of them questioned me, and neither stuck around after theyd voted

That's not answering the questions...if you are who you say you are, I think your ability wouldn't be "agressive"? Non?

[theoutlaw321]

With that roleclaim, I can see what you're going for...

Who's super's?

I would have to go read. I just ask because it seems that everyone has been spinning their collective wheels around this list and not getting anywhere. Then someone outs themselves and gives another direction to go in and nZane wants to put a screaming halt on it. Just strikes me as odd.

[supermareo]

That's not answering the questions...if you are who you say you are, I think your ability wouldn't be "agressive"? Non?

no its not

[The Shape]

Yes, that's the reason. He doesn't say, "This isn't who I'm looking for" or "This isn't the person I'm looking for" or even "This isn't the guy I'm looking for". By using the word monster, he's acknowledging that person is a monster, just not one he's looking for.

Sure, there are monstrous looking heroes in Marvel, but that's not how the Punisher thinks. He hunts down criminals and he does consider factor in the person's causes. In Civil War, he joined the Anti-Registeration forces despite them technically being criminals with his reasoning being "the other guys started enlisting known thieves and convicted killers".

Would he dismiss mutants as monsters?

[i effin rule]

Touched a nerve, did I?

No, it just doesn't make a whole lot of sense. We have a player claim someone we know is in the game and know is town. He says "hey guys this guy is bad". What do you want people to do? It's not like there was a lot of time left in the phase to break things down and still get a vote. Was sprinkle wrong? Appears so, but we had no reason to trust him at the time.

[theoutlaw321]

i'll tell ya the two that bother me the most, the last two trypio and outlaw, both voted when i was around both voted with no reasoning of there own, neither of them questioned me, and neither stuck around after theyd voted

Knock knock. Haven't went anywhere.

[The Shape]

I think the town is going to win this game.

[BlueStar]

/kicks up dirt...

I hate this situation. We spend 24 hours going over DJ's list, KNOWING there's scum on that list. When the deadline's getting closer, someone who's not been active just gives a name, there's a big bandwagon....and suddenly all people on DJ's list are forgotten.

A good thing? Convenient? And so, for who?

[i effin rule]

Who's super's?

I would have to go read. I just ask because it seems that everyone has been spinning their collective wheels around this list and not getting anywhere. Then someone outs themselves and gives another direction to go in and nZane wants to put a screaming halt on it. Just strikes me as odd.

You'd hate him if you're a UNC fan.

[BlueStar]

no its not

If you're telling the truth, I know what you can do.

[i effin rule]

/kicks up dirt...

I hate this situation. We spend 24 hours going over DJ's list, KNOWING there's scum on that list. When the deadline's getting closer, someone who's not been active just gives a name, there's a big bandwagon....and suddenly all people on DJ's list are forgotten.

A good thing? Convenient? And so, for who?

Instead of hitting and missing with DJ's list, wouldn't it be best if he continued to use his ability and see if he can see the same names popping up from time to time? There are valuable good guys in his list that I would certainly prefer not to die.

[supermareo]

Knock knock. Haven't went anywhere.
45 miniuts after youd voted when i was hanging around the thread but nevermind eh