View Full Version : The Official Hollywood Horror Mafia Game Thread
Pages :
1
2
3
4
5
6
[
7]
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
But if he's only a survivor:
a) He wouldn't be a threat to the town so we'd leave him alone, and
b) The serial killer and Mafia wouldn't see him as a priority target, something which he's hinting otherwise.
He's hinting otherwise but he also says he missed a day action, and that... what, was the only time he would have been able to act?
He hasn't denied or accepted the day power role, and he hasn't explained it further, IE: If he had a day role, what exactly did he do day 1? If he "missed" his day role in day 2, well, then he has a role that, seemingly, would be used daily.
Unless it's an optional role... if using it could be both beneficial or hazardous...
hmmm...
i effin rule
07-24-2008, 10:35 PM
If you recall, I emailed Adam during the first day phase with two predictions, that you and Wallbanger were scum. That's why I won the Hawkeye Award. ;)
As I recall, you ruined my evil plan too.
The Aussie
07-24-2008, 10:35 PM
If you recall, I emailed Adam during the first day phase with two predictions, that you and Wallbanger were scum. That's why I won the Hawkeye Award. ;)
Damn. Those were really good guesses
Undertaker666
07-24-2008, 10:36 PM
So your not going to claim at all pride?
Are we happy with a JB_ & pride combo or do we want to look in other directions?
We've still got plenty of time and there are people not currently online who could potentially give us some information, namely people in the UK who aren't as crazy as I am to be awake at 4:35am. :p
blackphoenix
07-24-2008, 10:36 PM
Okay I'm off to study and go to work.
check in again in about nine hours.
praguepride
07-24-2008, 10:37 PM
So your not going to claim at all pride?
Would you, given the situation that I'm in? (read that I put myself in :( )
d_w_w
07-24-2008, 10:38 PM
So your not going to claim at all pride?
Are we happy with a JB_ & pride combo or do we want to look in other directions?
Sigh.
No, I'm not happy with this. In fact, I'm downright unhappy with this, because prague's play is putting a stupid "kill me at night" sticker on my back. And I'm perfectly capable of getting that sticker on my own!
Prague has an ability. I know what it is. It doesn't seem like a scum ability, but I can't verify his alignment or character.
Undertaker666
07-24-2008, 10:38 PM
As I recall, you ruined my evil plan too.
Damn. Those were really good guesses
And this is why scum often want me dead ASAP in these games. :(
Undertaker666
07-24-2008, 10:39 PM
Sigh.
No, I'm not happy with this. In fact, I'm downright unhappy with this, because prague's play is putting a stupid "kill me at night" sticker on my back. And I'm perfectly capable of getting that sticker on my own!
Prague has an ability. I know what it is. It doesn't seem like a scum ability, but I can't verify his alignment or character.
He's not in a sharing mood so would you care to share, and how you came across his ability too?
mjdgoldeneye
07-24-2008, 10:39 PM
And this is why scum often want me dead ASAP in these games. :(
Hmmm... No attempts on your life yet...
We've been in this situation before...
GET HIM!!!
:p
If only your roleclaim didn't make perfect sense...
praguepride
07-24-2008, 10:42 PM
If only your roleclaim didn't make perfect sense...
Wait, when did he roleclaim? Either quote or page approximation would be helpful...
Sigh.
No, I'm not happy with this. In fact, I'm downright unhappy with this, because prague's play is putting a stupid "kill me at night" sticker on my back. And I'm perfectly capable of getting that sticker on my own!
Prague has an ability. I know what it is. It doesn't seem like a scum ability, but I can't verify his alignment or character.
So. Prague HAS a night ability. And you can confirm this. But didn't he say earlier he only had a day ability? Or did he stumble over his own words?
Sitting around and waiting for day again. Heck, I completely missed my action for day 2 because the lynch happened so fast. I leave for work in the morning and it's still night time, then day time comes and bam, lynch and then night time again.
Undertaker666
07-24-2008, 10:43 PM
Hmmm... No attempts on your life yet...
We've been in this situation before...
GET HIM!!!
:p
If only your roleclaim didn't make perfect sense...
It's possible the first night that 'Banger was killed he was protecting me, but we wont know if someone tried to kill me until the end of the game.
I'm surprised no-one's noticed anything about my posts recently....
d_w_w
07-24-2008, 10:43 PM
He's not in a sharing mood so would you care to share, and how you came across his ability too?
Sure. I targetted him last night. His play looked iffy to me before, and so I thought he was worth looking into.
And, I'll give prague one more chance to give away a hint or something that will appease folks. Failing that, I'll come out with all my info.
And prague, I'm not doing this to get you killed. I'm doing this to keep you from being lynched. Now sure, you might get killed at night. But, it's better to die at night and help the town find a good target now, than it is to just get lynched and not help the town at all.
blackphoenix
07-24-2008, 10:44 PM
Wait, when did he roleclaim? Either quote or page approximation would be helpful...
He dropped hints for the first like.... twenty pages.
And several of us got it, several of us have visited him and not ended up dead.
d_w_w
07-24-2008, 10:44 PM
So. Prague HAS a night ability. And you can confirm this. But didn't he say earlier he only had a day ability? Or did he stumble over his own words?
To be fair, I can't confirm that. I can only confirm that he has an ability.
d_w_w
07-24-2008, 10:45 PM
To be fair, I can't confirm that. I can only confirm that he has an ability.
That is, I could see this being a day ability.
blackphoenix
07-24-2008, 10:45 PM
It's possible the first night that 'Banger was killed he was protecting me, but we wont know if someone tried to kill me until the end of the game.
I'm surprised no-one's noticed anything about my posts recently....
No more dancing?
Why so sad?
blackphoenix
07-24-2008, 10:46 PM
stop being so interesting I really have to go study.. nargh
praguepride
07-24-2008, 10:47 PM
Sure. I targetted him last night. His play looked iffy to me before, and so I thought he was worth looking into.
And, I'll give prague one more chance to give away a hint or something that will appease folks. Failing that, I'll come out with all my info.
And prague, I'm not doing this to get you killed. I'm doing this to keep you from being lynched. Now sure, you might get killed at night. But, it's better to die at night and help the town find a good target now, than it is to just get lynched and not help the town at all.
Alright, you moved me. You really shouldn't have revealed yourself because as they said, it's better for an idiot like myself to die before someone experienced like you reveals their hand.
Alright, here's a summary of the hints I've dropped:
- I work with a partner
- I work for the government
- I work odd hours and really weird jobs
praguepride
07-24-2008, 10:49 PM
Although to be honest in RL I do work a job that leaves me about 4 hours of free time (I wake up at 5am to commute 2 hours to work. By the time I get back home, I'm usually too tired to read through the 20 pages that have been posted while I was at work)
Undertaker666
07-24-2008, 10:49 PM
No more dancing?
Why so sad?
I'm not sad, all will be revealed when I use my ability. ;)
The Aussie
07-24-2008, 10:49 PM
Alright, you moved me. You really shouldn't have revealed yourself because as they said, it's better for an idiot like myself to die before someone experienced like you reveals their hand.
Alright, here's a summary of the hints I've dropped:
- I work with a partner
- I work for the government
- I work odd hours and really weird jobs
Would these weird jobs be investigative in origin?
d_w_w
07-24-2008, 10:50 PM
Alright, you moved me. You really shouldn't have revealed yourself because as they said, it's better for an idiot like myself to die before someone experienced like you reveals their hand.
Alright, here's a summary of the hints I've dropped:
- I work with a partner
- I work for the government
- I work odd hours and really weird jobs
Shrug, I always reveal my hand :p I basically did it in Heroes and I do it practically every game at Astil's site. It's kind of my thing.
Besides, with Sylar about, it's imperative that we kill him as soon as possible. If we're getting 2 this phase, no reason to waste it on someone that I know is not Sylar.
And, well, I'm working under the assumption that you can live through this. Protectors, and such.
praguepride
07-24-2008, 10:50 PM
Would these weird jobs be investigative in origin?
Possible. You could almost say they're Xtremely investigative. Although my role is actually not terribly useful at the moment :(
praguepride
07-24-2008, 10:52 PM
Anway. Here is a list of people that I suspect is Sylar
d_w_w
ford
blackphoenix
foolinc
Undertaker666
Sprinklefurball
trypio
Wallbanger
The Shape
BlueStar
cyberkitten01
Slim Jim
Do with them what you will. If I die at least I've contributed something.
The Aussie
07-24-2008, 10:52 PM
Possible. You could almost say they're Xtremely investigative. Although my role is actually not terribly useful at the moment :(
I see what you did there
jbergey_2005
07-24-2008, 10:52 PM
Fair enough...I think
Change Vote:RKO_HBK
just because I want to get to the end of my list while I can.
blackphoenix
07-24-2008, 10:55 PM
Change vote: No Vote.
No I leave... really... honestly.
Undertaker666
07-24-2008, 10:55 PM
Although to be honest in RL I do work a job that leaves me about 4 hours of free time (I wake up at 5am to commute 2 hours to work. By the time I get back home, I'm usually too tired to read through the 20 pages that have been posted while I was at work)
I've got no problem with revealing who I am if anyone wants to know. I can only use my ability once so i'm no great loss to the town if someone decides to take me out.
Anway. Here is a list of people that I suspect is Sylar
d_w_w
ford
blackphoenix
foolinc
Undertaker666
Sprinklefurball
trypio
Wallbanger
The Shape
BlueStar
cyberkitten01
Slim Jim
Do with them what you will. If I die at least I've contributed something.
lol, you think i'm possibly Sylar? Don't you think the 6 or so people who've visited me during the nightphases might have caught on if that were the case?
d_w_w
07-24-2008, 10:56 PM
Anway. Here is a list of people that I suspect is Sylar
d_w_w
ford
blackphoenix
foolinc
Undertaker666
Sprinklefurball
trypio
Wallbanger
The Shape
BlueStar
cyberkitten01
Slim Jim
Do with them what you will. If I die at least I've contributed something.
Can you elaborate on any of these suspicions? Why do you think that these players might be Sylar? Some I agree with, some I don't. But I've probably missed things, so.
The Aussie
07-24-2008, 10:56 PM
I've got no problem with revealing who I am if anyone wants to know. I can only use my ability once so i'm no great loss to the town if someone decides to take me out.
lol, you think i'm possibly Sylar? Don't you think the 6 or so people who've visited me during the nightphases might have caught on if that were the case?
Yeah, I think that if you were Sylar then we would have a mountain of corpses
blackphoenix
07-24-2008, 10:58 PM
lol, you think i'm possibly Sylar? Don't you think the 6 or so people who've visited me during the nightphases might have caught on if that were the case?
As I said earlier I visited taker night 1 and didn't die. I'm pretty sure he wasn't bad.
Undertaker666
07-24-2008, 10:58 PM
Yeah, I think that if you were Sylar then we would have a mountain of corpses
I can probably say with all confidence that i'm the least threatening person at this convention. :D
blackphoenix
07-24-2008, 10:58 PM
I can probably say with all confidence that i'm the least threatening person at this convention. :D
And the most huggable.
The Aussie
07-24-2008, 10:59 PM
I can probably say with all confidence that i'm the least threatening person at this convention. :D
What are you going to do? Pull out the dancing smiley and have them laugh to death?
Maybe Prague is claiming a role that hunts down Sylar? Hence why he's only listed specific people, not people cleared by others here in this thread.
If that's the case, Prague certainly needs to be kept healthy.
blackphoenix
07-24-2008, 11:00 PM
I can probably say with all confidence that i'm the least threatening person at this convention. :D
That's why I totally get your role claim too, your not threatening...
But there are people who looooove you... and are irish.
d_w_w
07-24-2008, 11:02 PM
So... am I the only one that wishes that Ford and blackpheonix and others would post in a thread outside of the dog pound.
Your post count of zero looks silly to me :)
blackphoenix
07-24-2008, 11:02 PM
okay I'm going now to study and get ready to work.
I'll pop back in a couple of hours.
My only question is why someone so purple has a computer. But hey, I don't think I really need the answer.
blackphoenix
07-24-2008, 11:03 PM
So... am I the only one that wishes that Ford and blackpheonix and others would post in a thread outside of the dog pound.
Your post count of zero looks silly to me :)
I came for the mafia.
I'd play GDS stuff if it played with macs.. but sadly not.
Undertaker666
07-24-2008, 11:03 PM
And the most huggable.
Awwwwww, thanks. :)
What are you going to do? Pull out the dancing smiley and have them laugh to death?
Death is not in my nature.
Maybe Prague is claiming a role that hunts down Sylar? Hence why he's only listed specific people, not people cleared by others here in this thread.
If that's the case, Prague certainly needs to be kept healthy.
He's claimed an investigator but then said "my role is actually not terribly useful at the moment".... so he's an investigator that can't investigate? I don't get it.
blackphoenix
07-24-2008, 11:05 PM
My only question is why someone so purple has a computer. But hey, I don't think I really need the answer.
I think it was a computer in his room. Nothing to do anything with his character.
My chicken lover was always going to learn english day 1, I visited taker night 1. Crychon wrote the pm for more storyline reasons than just saying. Hoorah you learnt english.
praguepride
07-24-2008, 11:06 PM
That is the unabridged version. I figure if I edit it myself with my own suspicions then if I'm wrong, then I've ruined it.
Now if you ask me what I really believe, the list is much shorter:
ford
foolinc
Sprinklefurball
trypio
Wallbanger
The Shape
BlueStar
cyberkitten01
Slim Jim
d_w_w risked much to save me from myself, but could that be a power that Sylar absorbed? I'm hoping not.
And Undertaker666 might be taking everyone for a ride, but the dancing makes me think it's something else.
Finally, if there IS a Sylar, I'd advise looking at the people who haven't posted at all, except maybe a lynch vote. Remember from the show that Sylar survived by staying in the shadows, by blending in. Maybe that means that as part of his really cool SK role that he can't post except to vote for a lynch (maybe not even that).
Someone with more time on their hands might want to look at the people on that list and see who hasn't posted. Just a thought, this part of it is pure speculation on my part, I don't have real data to back up anything other then the list.
blackphoenix
07-24-2008, 11:07 PM
okay really gone. Closing page and not refreshing.
damn it mafia is addictive.
Undertaker666
07-24-2008, 11:07 PM
My only question is why someone so purple has a computer. But hey, I don't think I really need the answer.
Purple? Barney is purple, i'm fuchsia. :cool:
I like to think I taught Blackphoenix in the same way Sesame Street teaches kids how to spell.
I came for the mafia.
I'd play GDS stuff if it played with macs.. but sadly not.
You can play GDS games on Macs using Boot Camp so i'm told.
The Aussie
07-24-2008, 11:08 PM
I'm heading off now also. I have an appointment soon
So... am I the only one that wishes that Ford and blackpheonix and others would post in a thread outside of the dog pound.
Your post count of zero looks silly to me :)
The last GDS semi-affiliated game I played was EWR 4.2. I'm totally a freeloader.
Although I do love that game.
praguepride
07-24-2008, 11:09 PM
Maybe Prague is claiming a role that hunts down Sylar? Hence why he's only listed specific people, not people cleared by others here in this thread.
If that's the case, Prague certainly needs to be kept healthy.
It's funny, you're right for all the wrong reasons.
praguepride
07-24-2008, 11:11 PM
On a completely different track, I've finished my preliminary idea sketch for my mafia game. I wouldn't mind consulting with someone much more experienced with mafia other then myself to consult about what kind of balances should be in place to keep it from being completely one sided.
blackphoenix
07-24-2008, 11:11 PM
Purple? Barney is purple, i'm fuchsia. :cool:
I like to think I taught Blackphoenix in the same way Sesame Street teaches kids how to spell.
You can play GDS games on Macs using Boot Camp so i'm told.
Boot camp is no longer available as a download and I have the verision before the new fancy OS.. :(
The only thing about Taker not dancing anymore makes me thing that his little buddy is in trouble. He loved to drink and punch people..
Taker do you think that's him in the write ups?
Crychon
07-24-2008, 11:12 PM
Well, bed awaits. As always, I will check in with a vote count befor work in the morning, then after that it's the weekend, woot.
It is now day phase four. You have until 7:00 AM EST Saturday, July 26th (12:00 PM Saturday, July 26th GMT) to reach a majority decision.
jbergey_2005: 8 (The Rock 13, cyberkitten01, Wallbanger, The Shape, i effin rule, TheEdgeOfReason, Glotnot, mjdgoldeneye, praguepride)
praguepride: 3 (Undertaker666, mjdgoldeneye, The Aussie)
The Aussie: 2 (Astil, ford)
RKO_HBK: 1 (jbergey_2005)
With 27 players remaining, it is 14 to lynch.
praguepride
07-24-2008, 11:13 PM
Well, I hope at least to have given a little focus towards townie suspicion before I get horribly slaughtered by Sylar, shot by scum or lynched in my (RL) sleep.
Undertaker666
07-24-2008, 11:15 PM
Boot camp is no longer available as a download and I have the verision before the new fancy OS.. :(
The only thing about Taker not dancing anymore makes me thing that his little buddy is in trouble. He loved to drink and punch people..
Taker do you think that's him in the write ups?
lol, i'd never even considered it was him, but it would be awesome if he was in the game too. :D
Don't pay any attention to the lack of a dancing smiley, it's got nothing to do with the game at all, it was just something I did to amuse myself. :p
Wallbanger
07-24-2008, 11:20 PM
Prague, you flatter me, but I can assure the gathered conventioneers that the brains of others holds no fascination to me whatsoever, especially those removed from their skulls.
praguepride
07-24-2008, 11:23 PM
Well, another role hint.
I didn't generate the list myself, it was delivered to me by another person. I'm a speaker for someone else, my partner, if you will.
jbergey_2005
07-24-2008, 11:23 PM
I find it unusual that he voted for me yet I wasnt good enough to make this star studded list:(
Undertaker666
07-24-2008, 11:24 PM
Anyway boys and girls, it's 5:25am so it's time I was off. Don't get lynch happy, we've still got a full day for us to get info and reach a majority to lynch.
If she turns up while i'm not here, I want to hear from CYBERKITTEN. (that'll hopefully get her attention if she's only skimming posts)
Cyberkitten, any info you can give us? What have you been up to during the nightphases etc?
Undertaker666
07-24-2008, 11:25 PM
You too, Wallbanger. You've been rather quiet, anything you'd like to share?
I'm off.............
Wallbanger
07-24-2008, 11:26 PM
And while I'm thinking of it:
LOGISTICAL ANNOUNCEMENT: The family and I are heading out of town tomorrow and will be on vacation next week. This does NOT mean I'm dropping off the grid entirely, I have a laptop, a WiFi card, and the ability to use both. :p It does mean that I won't be online as much as I typically am though.
And if you think that I'm just saying it as cover for not being very talkative, the Goal Line Blitz folks can corroborate that I said the same thing on our team forum.
Wallbanger
07-24-2008, 11:27 PM
You too, Wallbanger. You've been rather quiet, anything you'd like to share?
I'm off.............
I hate it when you say this just before I tell folks I'm not going to be online as much. ;)
praguepride
07-24-2008, 11:28 PM
I find it unusual that he voted for me yet I wasnt good enough to make this star studded list:(
Hey, just because you're not Sylar doesn't mean you're not still scum...
i effin rule
07-24-2008, 11:28 PM
Well, another role hint.
I didn't generate the list myself, it was delivered to me by another person. I'm a speaker for someone else, my partner, if you will.
I think I know things. Is there a particular reason you are more active this day phase?
Wallbanger
07-24-2008, 11:29 PM
And I have shared, just in a nuanced fashion.
i effin rule
07-24-2008, 11:29 PM
Not asking for a reason or anything, just a yes or no will do.
d_w_w
07-24-2008, 11:30 PM
Hey, just because you're not Sylar doesn't mean you're not still scum...
Agreed.
Prague - can you explain a little bit more about the list? I only know the basics behind your role. Was the list delivered to you as an entire unit or did you get it in pieces?
i effin rule
07-24-2008, 11:32 PM
Agreed.
Prague - can you explain a little bit more about the list? I only know the basics behind your role. Was the list delivered to you as an entire unit or did you get it in pieces?
Or is your partner into CSI or other forensic type stuff?
praguepride
07-24-2008, 11:35 PM
I think I know things. Is there a particular reason you are more active this day phase?
a) I had a massive finger pointed at me by accident. I swear I just missed the post where jberg was not to be pressured anymore. I had planned on staying in the shadows and just bandwagoning until I had narrowed down the list some more.
b) I actually had some freetime tonight so I've been online for a bit. Most other nights I pretty much had time to check if I had been killed or lynched yet, and if not then who people were voting for on the lynching.
As for the list, it was delivered as one big chunk.
d_w_w
07-24-2008, 11:35 PM
Really though, if this list was generated at a whole, then I'm feeling pretty good that Sylar is on it. Meaning, we should eliminate the folks that we know are not Sylar and get to work, while we still have dayphase left.
praguepride
07-24-2008, 11:36 PM
Or is your partner into CSI or other forensic type stuff?
All I'll say is that my partner is much better at this, in more ways then one. Actually this is partially helpful because the more they focus on me, the more time my partner has to find the truth. The truth is out there...
jbergey_2005
07-24-2008, 11:38 PM
a) I had a massive finger pointed at me by accident. I swear I just missed the post where jberg was not to be pressured anymore.
I dont think anyone asked that I not get pressured. It seems some people would like more answers before jumping to conclusions. d_w_w seems to have the right train of thought IMO.
praguepride
07-24-2008, 11:38 PM
Remember, this is the original list
d_w_w
ford
blackphoenix
foolinc
Undertaker666
Sprinklefurball
trypio
Wallbanger
The Shape
BlueStar
cyberkitten01
Slim Jim
Speculate as you will, I'm going to bed. G'night. This day phase has been interesting, to say the least. We'll see what happens next day phase :D
blackphoenix
07-24-2008, 11:40 PM
I dont think anyone asked that I not get pressured. It seems some people would like more answers before jumping to conclusions. d_w_w seems to have the right train of thought IMO.
I was at the understanding that we said that we were happy with JB being a suspect and we were looking for another due to Taker's ability so we can take out two at once.
praguepride
07-24-2008, 11:41 PM
Also, PM me if you'd be willing to help me get a mafia game designed so that it can be run next time there's a gap.
It should be pretty fun, I've got an interesting idea that should be amusing to say the least.
I've already hinted that the Dr. Horrible universe would be included in a heroes vs. villains, but I've got an idea to throw in a bunch of second-rate heroes from another universe to combat the second-rate villains in the Dr. Horrible-verse.
jbergey_2005
07-24-2008, 11:43 PM
I was at the understanding that we said that we were happy with JB being a suspect and we were looking for another due to Taker's ability so we can take out two at once.
Well what I was saying could be spun to say basically the same thing. You were much more detailed.
jbergey_2005
07-24-2008, 11:46 PM
I was at the understanding that we said that we were happy with JB being a suspect and we were looking for another due to Taker's ability so we can take out two at once.
I would presume you would like to find Sylar correct?
d_w_w
07-24-2008, 11:47 PM
Ok, let's get to work. I'm trusting the list.
d_w_w
ford
blackphoenix
foolinc
Undertaker666
Sprinklefurball
trypio
Wallbanger
The Shape
BlueStar
cyberkitten01
Slim Jim
I'm not Sylar. I'd like to think that I've given enough with my saving of Prague to show that.
As I've already outed myself, so I'll just go out and say that Bluestar is not Sylar. I targetted him the night I got this role and "her" ability does not include decapitations.
I also feel good about eliminating UT from the list.
And Wallbanger (reason: well, Sylar killed my first role on night 1. However, my new role apparently did not take a night 1 action, as I did not receive any grandfathered info). Thus, it stands to reason that the person playing Sylar did something on night 1 and did not need to be replaced.
I also trust blackphoenix. I can't verify that she's the chicken lover I think she is, but it would be a crazy move to make as Sylar.
So, here's where I'm at:
ford
foolinc
Sprinklefurball
trypio
The Shape
cyberkitten01
Slim Jim
Thoughts?
blackphoenix
07-24-2008, 11:47 PM
Well what I was saying could be spun to say basically the same thing. You were much more detailed.
lol, my way at looking at it we were pretty happy to put you in that slot and are looking for someone else to take to the gallows/nightkill
your way of looking at it was people were a bit sus on you but didn't want to jump to conclusions on that.
Your version contains much more spin that mine did. I was one of the people that reminded people several times not to lynch you so we can find another, otherwise there were several people who could have easily put us over.
Anyway, I'm really gone now.
drags self away from the internetz
blackphoenix
07-24-2008, 11:49 PM
I would presume you would like to find Sylar correct?
absolutely but just because your not sylar doesn't me that your town either. especially in a game this big.
blackphoenix
07-24-2008, 11:51 PM
ford
foolinc
Sprinklefurball
trypio
The Shape
cyberkitten01
Slim Jim
The worst thing is that most of these people have been silent most of the damn game.
The Shape has been hanging around alot on the board tho... without posting.
jbergey_2005
07-24-2008, 11:51 PM
ford
foolinc
Sprinklefurball
trypio
The Shape
cyberkitten01
Slim Jim
Thoughts?
Foolinc will bring some good ithoughts to the game sometimes It is kind of surprising the level of inactivity he has show. Trypio seems to be playing like he usually does. The Shape seems to always send me scummy vibes for some reason. Taker might have something on cyberkitten so that would be a good place to look as well. Sprinkle is normally pretty quiet. First game with ford I do believe and Slim Jim I havent really noticed anything.
blackphoenix
07-24-2008, 11:52 PM
Also cyberkitten01 seemed eager to play in the signups thread but hasn't contributed much.
gonvick
07-25-2008, 12:02 AM
And Wallbanger (reason: well, Sylar killed my first role on night 1. However, my new role apparently did not take a night 1 action, as I did not receive any grandfathered info). Thus, it stands to reason that the person playing Sylar did something on night 1 and did not need to be replaced.
My understanding of the typical SK role is that killing is mandatory and if a target isn't sent in by the player then one is chosen at random by the mod. So I don't think that's a strong enough reason to remove someone from the list.
Oh, and I'll vouch for trypio. He's not Sylar.
d_w_w
07-25-2008, 12:03 AM
Arg, I have a headache. Need to sleep soon.
Anyhow, I'm not really sure how to approach this list.
Need sleep. Need people with better scum-hunting ability to think about things.
d_w_w
07-25-2008, 12:06 AM
My understanding of the typical SK role is that killing is mandatory and if a target isn't sent in by the player then one is chosen at random by the mod. So I don't think that's a strong enough reason to remove someone from the list.
Oh, and I'll vouch for trypio. He's not Sylar.
That's a fair point. I'm curious as to how you can clear trypio, but it doesn't matter for now. The fact that you can is good enough for now, as Sylar almost certainly runs alone.
At some point, presuming I'm still alive, I'll probably come back to you and trypio though. Although, some rereading and Tylenol might clear some things up for me.
Should we say then that the list is:
ford
foolinc
Sprinklefurball
Wallbanger
The Shape
cyberkitten01
Slim Jim
?
gonvick
07-25-2008, 12:09 AM
That's a fair point. I'm curious as to how you can clear trypio, but it doesn't matter for now. The fact that you can is good enough for now, as Sylar almost certainly runs alone.
At some point, presuming I'm still alive, I'll probably come back to you and trypio though. Although, some rereading and Tylenol might clear some things up for me.
Should we say then that the list is:
ford
foolinc
Sprinklefurball
Wallbanger
The Shape
cyberkitten01
Slim Jim
?
That's as narrowed down as I can get it at this point.
Lostrelms
07-25-2008, 12:11 AM
*Cough* Meet my new daughter, Madison...
born July 23rd, 2008, 6 lbs 12 oz, 19.5 inches long...
http://i47.photobucket.com/albums/f194/Lostrelms/Madison/11MADISONSKY072308.jpg
So yeah, lynch all inactives...
Im back now tho :-)
Glotnot
07-25-2008, 12:12 AM
I can also say that Trypio isn't Sylar.
And I'm pretty sure Slim isn't either. He's a way for a bit on vacation, I think, so he wouldn't be able to send the kills in.
ford
foolinc
Sprinklefurball
Wallbanger
The Shape
cyberkitten01
foolinc
07-25-2008, 12:15 AM
Sorry about not being more active. Real life and my current addiction, Europa Universalis III, have been taking up most of my time. In any case, while I'm not totally sure of sure whether or not Bruce Campbell, the actor, is in the game I can say that I am Convention Aligned and have hinted at who I am in previous posts.
d_w_w
07-25-2008, 12:22 AM
*Cough* Meet my new daughter, Madison...
born July 23rd, 2008, 6 lbs 12 oz, 19.5 inches long...
So yeah, lynch all inactives...
Im back now tho :-)
Congratulations!
jbergey_2005
07-25-2008, 12:24 AM
*Cough* Meet my new daughter, Madison...
born July 23rd, 2008, 6 lbs 12 oz, 19.5 inches long...
http://i47.photobucket.com/albums/f194/Lostrelms/Madison/11MADISONSKY072308.jpg
So yeah, lynch all inactives...
Im back now tho :-)
I huge congratulations Lostelms
You should be very proud.
Glotnot
07-25-2008, 12:26 AM
Oi, how did I miss that.
Congratulations, mate. :)
Bringing a human life into this world is a great thing. I wish you luck in raising her.
blackphoenix
07-25-2008, 12:28 AM
BABY!
In other things...
The Shape and sprinklefurball
are the only ones out of the inactives that I've seen logged in during nightphase, yes you need to consider invisible and all that but at least it's something.
gonvick
07-25-2008, 12:29 AM
*Cough* Meet my new daughter, Madison...
born July 23rd, 2008, 6 lbs 12 oz, 19.5 inches long...
So yeah, lynch all inactives...
Im back now tho :-)
Congratulations.
Sorry about not being more active. Real life and my current addiction, Europa Universalis III, have been taking up most of my time. In any case, while I'm not totally sure of sure whether or not Bruce Campbell, the actor, is in the game I can say that I am Convention Aligned and have hinted at who I am in previous posts.
Can you point to anything that backs up what you're hinting at?
EBWOP : Congrats Lost soul.
Foolinc, I got your claim. I believe he would be in a game like this. I mean, that takes you off my list for Sylar, but I can't speak for the majority.
jbergey_2005
07-25-2008, 12:31 AM
Sorry about not being more active. Real life and my current addiction, Europa Universalis III, have been taking up most of my time. In any case, while I'm not totally sure of sure whether or not Bruce Campbell, the actor, is in the game I can say that I am Convention Aligned and have hinted at who I am in previous posts.
Im not seeing any hints other than something about Peter Valentine. You do seem pretty worried about the bad luck the red mafia and the f'n serial killer. I must have totally missed any hints.
Well then Yippee-ki-yay, [Peter Valentine]!
Sorry about that. I was just caught up watching Die Hard again and wasn't totally thinking straight.
"Come out to the coast, we'll get together, have a few laughs..."
That quote gets me every time! :D
Those were what I saw.
blackphoenix
07-25-2008, 12:33 AM
In a random thing...
Remember that the mafia members don't always necessarily know who all the other members are. Eg. Heroes game.
So a mafia member can accidentally vote for another.
Came to me in the shower.
d_w_w
07-25-2008, 12:40 AM
O.M.G.
Foolinc is saying that Peter Valentine is a mother...
I mean, really, the great Peter Valentine? Star of the HGC/TCW and USPW!?!?!!?!? He of unmatched in-ring skill and charisma!!!!
I don't know how much of this I can handle. I think I need a replacement.
Anyhow, I picked up on those quotes too. The issue is, just 'cause he says that doesn't make it true.
Watch.
[Shouts to the heavens]
I am surrounded by naked cheerleaders!
[Nothing happens]
Of course, that is true of practically everyone, all the time in mafia. So yeah, I'm really not saying anything useful at all.
Off to bed, I need sleep! I'll be around here and there tomorrow when I'm at work.
jbergey_2005
07-25-2008, 12:51 AM
If you guys would like to get this correct I am more than willing to throw on a costume tonight and basically waste my ability. I am sure it will show up in the night writeup that this costumed guy was somewhere.
gonvick
07-25-2008, 12:55 AM
Foolinc, I got your claim. I believe he would be in a game like this. I mean, that takes you off my list for Sylar, but I can't speak for the majority.
You know, you're on the list as well. Anything you can reveal that will allow us to take you off the list?
The Rock 13
07-25-2008, 01:32 AM
Congratsulations Lostrelms!
Anyway Change Vote: No Vote
BlueStar
07-25-2008, 01:43 AM
Congrats, Lost!!!!
Well, I'm pretty much agreeing with the list.
Wallbanger v.2.0? Shape? Two dangerous players...Shape's been a bit more quiet during this game than usual, then again, there's been little to react on.
blackphoenix
07-25-2008, 01:46 AM
Congrats, Lost!!!!
Well, I'm pretty much agreeing with the list.
Wallbanger v.2.0? Shape? Two dangerous players...Shape's been a bit more quiet during this game than usual, then again, there's been little to react on.
I'll stick this out there then...
Change vote: The Shape
Imarevenant
07-25-2008, 01:51 AM
Congrats Lostrelms!
::goes back to being dead::
foolinc
07-25-2008, 02:01 AM
Almost forgot, CONGRATS Lost!
blackphoenix
07-25-2008, 02:02 AM
CYBERKITTEN
You are currently under suspcion, can you drop some hints or tell us what you've been up to/why so quiet?
blackphoenix
07-25-2008, 02:03 AM
wow that was really big. lol
blackphoenix
07-25-2008, 02:32 AM
and no response and then CK is gone.
Hmmm...
Off to work then. Check back later.
RKO_HBK
07-25-2008, 04:45 AM
Just caught up with the last 20 pages, I was going to vote Praguepride, but it seems we're going in a slightly different direction. And Jbergey, just to clarify:
Well my initial list had Big Josh, Astil, Orange-Kun, Rko_HBK, Praguepride and Comrabot(sp??") on it and Prague hasnt dont much to look much better.
Change Vote:Praguepride
Just wondering why I'm on the list and....
Fair enough...I think
Change Vote:RKO_HBK
just because I want to get to the end of my list while I can.
...why you voted for me before I'd had any chance to argue my case?
The Shape
07-25-2008, 05:16 AM
The Shape has been hanging around alot on the board tho... without posting.
Hey, I post elsewhere (but this forum really is where I feel I belong...) :o Normally I'm more active but I was really out of the loop until this last phase, where with the whole jbergy thing I decided to get involved lol.
And I'm pretty sure Slim isn't either. He's a way for a bit on vacation, I think, so he wouldn't be able to send the kills in.
Aye but only for a couple of days he said.
Anyway the list
ford
foolinc
Sprinklefurball
trypio
cyberkitten01
Slim Jim
trypio's popped his head up now and again...any reason why he only has 8 posts? xD
Crychon
07-25-2008, 05:57 AM
And an updated vote count:
It is now day phase four. You have until 7:00 AM EST Saturday, July 26th (12:00 PM Saturday, July 26th GMT) to reach a majority decision.
jbergey_2005: 8 (cyberkitten01, Wallbanger, The Shape, i effin rule, TheEdgeOfReason, Glotnot, mjdgoldeneye, praguepride)
praguepride: 3 (Undertaker666, mjdgoldeneye, The Aussie)
The Aussie: 2 (Astil, ford)
RKO_HBK: 1 (jbergey_2005)
: 1 ([B]blackphoenix)
With 27 players remaining, it is 14 to lynch.
blackphoenix
07-25-2008, 07:48 AM
Dobe do do do do do...
who's invisablllle...
i effin rule
07-25-2008, 07:50 AM
Dobe do do do do do...
who's invisablllle...
Me.
blackphoenix
07-25-2008, 08:01 AM
I miss the endless chatter with JB, I wonder if he is safe in detainment?
The Aussie
07-25-2008, 08:09 AM
I'm totally bored. Where the hell are everyone?
Destiny
07-25-2008, 08:29 AM
Just a few random thoughts as they came to me really.
It's possible the first night that 'Banger was killed he was protecting me, but we wont know if someone tried to kill me until the end of the game.
I'm surprised no-one's noticed anything about my posts recently....
/nod. I think. :o
Anway. Here is a list of people that I suspect is Sylar
d_w_w
ford
blackphoenix
foolinc
Undertaker666
Sprinklefurball
trypio
Wallbanger
The Shape
BlueStar
cyberkitten01
Slim Jim
Do with them what you will. If I die at least I've contributed something.
The original list, as a reference point.
Aye but only for a couple of days he said.
Anyway the list
ford
foolinc
Sprinklefurball
trypio
cyberkitten01
Slim Jim
trypio's popped his head up now and again...any reason why he only has 8 posts? xD
Clever what you've done there Shape. Taken yourself off of the list so people will copy your one. ;)
Slim Jim
07-25-2008, 08:34 AM
Aaaaand I'm back.
ford
foolinc
Sprinklefurball
trypio
The Shape
cyberkitten01
Slim Jim
The worst thing is that most of these people have been silent most of the damn game.
I wasn't THAT inactive before I went on holiday for a couple of days :( I had a nice conversation with Shadowed about a car backfiring outside his house just before I left...
The Shape seems to always send me scummy vibes for some reason.
Slim Jim I havent really noticed anything.
First part: from my experiences with him both in mafia games and generally talking to him, he is one of two things. Town or big, big scum. I would normally lean to town but I'd hate for him to catch me out as I'd never hear the end of it. But yeah, he's not playing in a way that makes me think that he's a "normal" scum player at all.
Second part: I've been sunning myself for the last two days and enjoying the beach. Jealous? :cool:
And I'm pretty sure Slim isn't either. He's a way for a bit on vacation, I think, so he wouldn't be able to send the kills in.
If I was Sylar and had played this game the way I have so far, you wouldn't be alive for starters :p
Just read everything I missed while I was away, going to get something to eat, re-read the recent stuff and then comment on more things if they grab my attention.
The Shape
07-25-2008, 08:36 AM
Clever what you've done there Shape. Taken yourself off of the list so people will copy your one. ;)
lol hardly some huge ploy, just eliminated the one who I know is town...
blackphoenix
07-25-2008, 08:37 AM
Just a few random thoughts as they came to me really.
/nod. I think. :o
The original list, as a reference point.
Clever what you've done there Shape. Taken yourself off of the list so people will copy your one. ;)
Good catch, The Shape was definately not taken off the short list at all.
Original short list for reference..
ford
foolinc
Sprinklefurball
trypio
The Shape
cyberkitten01
Slim Jim
And yes Slim Jim, I wasn't refering to you when I said inactive but if you look at the many on that list they have been.
I tried to get cyberkitten01 to talk before and she/he totally skipped out.
My new short list for our double lynch attempt is
The Shape and Cyberkitten.
Destiny
07-25-2008, 08:40 AM
lol hardly some huge ploy, just eliminated the one who I know is town...
I'd be fine with that if there was a concrete reason as to why you are town and not Sylar.
The Shape
07-25-2008, 08:42 AM
xD "good catch"? I'm hardly going to sit here and mull myself over and say "yeah Hmm not sure what to make of this guy." And I trust people aren't just going to blindly copy my list given what's being said atm.
I don't even know how I've come under consideration really, I barely followed the first 50 pages or so and jumped in when I saw something I both fully understood and felt strongly about.
As for concrete reasons, well I'm sure if you could just throw sylar a bone to appease him this game would be much simpler :o
The Shape
07-25-2008, 08:47 AM
So yeah uh any questions?
Destiny
07-25-2008, 08:53 AM
So yeah uh any questions?
Not so much from me. I'm not aware enough of the source material to question specific roleclaims.
blackphoenix
07-25-2008, 09:19 AM
Sorry went to make cookies.. mmmm...cookies.
You don't have to flat out roleclaim but some hints would be nice, :ie have you appeared in the write up etc.
BlueStar
07-25-2008, 09:22 AM
Just passed my motorcycle exam!
What exactly do we have against Jbergey?
The Shape
07-25-2008, 09:24 AM
I've now dropped a total of two hints already, which is rather unlike me :cool:
Don't see myself in any writeups (well a quick control + F search of one rather crucial word suggests that's the case anyway xD).
sprinklefurball
07-25-2008, 09:30 AM
Sorry for being so inactive, I'm just not into this whole thing right now...
Congrats lost.
Astil
07-25-2008, 09:50 AM
Congrats lost.
So now Han and Little Lost. It's a babypalooza!
Change Vote: Cyberkitten
We have still 5 targets, maybe more.
Destiny
07-25-2008, 10:00 AM
Congrats lost.
So now Han and Little Lost. It's a babypalooza!
Change Vote: Cyberkitten
We have still 5 targets, maybe more.
That's a huge positive we can take from this day phase. Out of curiosity, Astil, what names that were on your list you posted earlier also appear on prague's?
Astil
07-25-2008, 10:35 AM
Just these 2 I think
19. trypio - Hasn't posted much at all.
32. d_w_w (v2.0) - Part of the 'confusing' replacement ordeal
cyberkitten01
07-25-2008, 10:44 AM
Jeez! Sorry for seeming inactive there everyone. I've been keeping up with this game every day, but yesterday evening I ended up reading comics and sitting with the husband instead of being on the computer all night. I check the game this morning before work and there's 20 pages to catch up on!! :eek: Never found time to check them in work, so by the time I came back there 29 pages!!
So to the matter at hand, I can guarantee that I am not Sylar. The vast majority of my posts before this one have all been in character and being my first Mafia game I haven't been totally sure if I should just be chatting about Arrested Development and things like that or actually trying to give hints as to who I am, so I've been letting the more experienced players point fingers and then I think the evidence is good I throw in my vote too.
Here are my most notable posts
Vote: No Lynch
I'm not about to see someone lynched without a good reason
This was before I understood there was a No Vote..
The time for waiting is over. Now is a time for action. The people have suffered too much already
vote: BIGJOSH
Justice was served tonight. There will be a great deal more bloodshed before the guilty are brought to justice
When I said this I meant we'd have to kill more of the bad guys before we had justice, but on it's own it looks a bit too ambiguous
My neck is safe, don't worry. This is something very wrong with the country, and this Convention is the epitomy of that. Convention goers should not live in fear, it is the wicked like BIGJOSH who should fear the Convention goers
This was my biggest hint, paraphrasing one of my character's lines from the film he is in
Suspicioooooous. Still not convinced
vote: Orange-Kun
Change Vote: No Lynch
I agree. I'm satisfied that after that pressure Orange-kun isn't the one we should be focused on
I'm ready to believe ShadowFlames is lying to us, but I will wait and see how the pressure of death quickens his tongue before I cast my vote
Vote: jbergey_2005
With someone like Sylar running around, I don't think we can afford to be cautious right now
I've tried hinting that my character is all about justice and power for the people. As I haven't posted much that hasn't made me a target until now. My character doesn't have a day or a night time power, more of an "always switched on" power.
Night-time Activity: Again as this is my first game, the first two Night phases I asked to "stay in and defend" as I didn't want to end up dead too early in the game. I'm not even sure if there is a stay in action, but Crychon seemed ok with it. Night phase 3 I PM'd Crychon that I wanted to protect blackpheonix as it was obvious from her hints and writeup on Night 1 that she wasn't evil. I figured that would have made her a target. (very much in-character) I would sacrificed myself to ensure that justice was had and that the innocent people would no longer suffer.
I hope this is satisfactory. My last post was nearly 24 hours ago voting jbergey_2005. I'm convinced jb isn't scum, therefore...
Change Vote: No Vote
Astil
07-25-2008, 10:49 AM
Change Vote: trypio
Ok, good enough for me cyber
The Aussie
07-25-2008, 10:55 AM
Change Vote: trypio
Ok, good enough for me cyber
Didn't Trypio claim The Dude?
Astil
07-25-2008, 10:56 AM
Didn't Trypio claim The Dude?
Did I miss that?
If someone verifies I'll lay off and switch to Shape for now...
Glotnot
07-25-2008, 10:56 AM
I don't think Trypio claimed.
Glotnot
07-25-2008, 10:57 AM
Either way, he's not scum. I'll vouch for that, if that means anything.
Slim Jim
07-25-2008, 11:00 AM
Means enough. And you were me in Neo Mafia... why'd you have to die? :( And I seriously LOL'd at the other two guys in your group.
Gotta share this story with the folks here. One scum guy has a continuous daykill... another a continuous night bomb that he can carry out during the night, separate from the rest of it... they don't know who the other is, start arguing and the one with the night bomb kills his teammate and himself in the middle of a night phase, which then continued. It was hilarious :p
The Aussie
07-25-2008, 11:03 AM
Did I miss that?
If someone verifies I'll lay off and switch to Shape for now...
He dropped hints concerning White Russians and someone (can't remember who) connected the dots.
mjdgoldeneye
07-25-2008, 11:03 AM
Fantasy Football People:
Draft starts in about 10 minutes...
The Aussie
07-25-2008, 11:04 AM
Anyways, I'm off to bed now. 2:00AM does not make me a happy camper.
Glotnot
07-25-2008, 11:06 AM
Jesus that was annoying.
Continuous Day Phase Kill guy had the entire Town convinced that he was Town. He would have died once they figured out he wasn't dying at night, but he was Mafia's best shot at winning.
Then here comes Bomb Guy who can kill himself and take one player with him, who none of us knew was Mafia. In his defense, there's no way he could have known.
But I had to die because I was stupid. Still, almost got them to believe two roleclaims. But then that guy had to roleclaim and tell everyone that I wasn't who I said I was. Both times. Would have been epic if it worked.
The Shape
07-25-2008, 11:09 AM
If I was still alive both scum groups would be outed by now, but no no no :(
d_w_w
07-25-2008, 11:10 AM
The fact that people can vouch for trypio is enough to keep him off my short list of people that could by Sylar.
I'm not positive who Cyberkitten is claiming either, but the phrases and wording seem familiar. I'm willing to move past that for now.
Honestly, I'm kind of leaning toward the Shape as being Sylar. No data here, just kind of a gut feeling.
The Shape
07-25-2008, 11:13 AM
Honestly this is the one situation as town where I've wanted people to think I was town...sure there's other roles that have that effect but in my experience I actually want to be seen as town because of how my role works. xD
I'm not going to speak about my ability regardless but I'll happily character claim if needs be, unless people are appeased by the fact that I was one of these in my first game :cool:
sprinklefurball
07-25-2008, 11:16 AM
vote:cyberkitten
sprinklefurball
07-25-2008, 11:16 AM
The fact that people can vouch for trypio is enough to keep him off my short list of people that could by Sylar.
I'm not positive who Cyberkitten is claiming either, but the phrases and wording seem familiar. I'm willing to move past that for now.
Honestly, I'm kind of leaning toward the Shape as being Sylar. No data here, just kind of a gut feeling.
maybe I should've waited to read before I voted...
Slim Jim
07-25-2008, 11:16 AM
Shape, admit that you're Sylar or I won't write Raw...
If he's Sylar, this'll work for sure, guys.
The Shape
07-25-2008, 11:24 AM
To be fair Slim I planned to "play an honest game" if I was scum, but unfortunately I didn't get the chance :o
d_w_w
07-25-2008, 11:24 AM
Shape, admit that you're Sylar or I won't write Raw...
If he's Sylar, this'll work for sure, guys.
You would resort to blackmail?
Good man, good man!
d_w_w
07-25-2008, 11:25 AM
vote:cyberkitten
Strange for you to vote on cyberkitten, with you being on the list and all.
The Shape
07-25-2008, 11:25 AM
You would resort to blackmail?
Good man, good man!
If he's playing in character then that's a terrible sign :cool:
To be fair I don't see why he's been let off the hook because he was a away for a couple of days, I'm almost certain he hasn't missed any night phases in full. Maybe a day but not a night.
Slim Jim
07-25-2008, 11:30 AM
I missed the last night phase in full, was here for the others though. We were in the middle of the Shadowed lynch when I left.
Plus, no hook can contain me, I've had de-hook training :cool:
d_w_w
07-25-2008, 11:32 AM
If he's playing in character then that's a terrible sign :cool:
To be fair I don't see why he's been let off the hook because he was a away for a couple of days, I'm almost certain he hasn't missed any night phases in full. Maybe a day but not a night.
I missed the last night phase in full, was here for the others though. We were in the middle of the Shadowed lynch when I left.
Plus, no hook can contain me, I've had de-hook training :cool:
This is interesting. I don't really have any sense for when Slim was gone. Maybe others could chime in on this.
The Shape
07-25-2008, 11:36 AM
Ok I just checked and his last post was in the day phase...but it was yesterday time wise, hence my confusion :(
The Shape
07-25-2008, 11:36 AM
Not yesterday, the day before...pfft...
Slim Jim
07-25-2008, 11:40 AM
Mmhm, my last post before I left was my vote on Shadowed.
Undertaker666
07-25-2008, 12:15 PM
I think it's 18 hours to go until the end of the day phase.
Shape, what's the "crucial" word that you've been looking for in the write-ups? I've been mentioned in the write-ups but I haven't seen anything written in them that I would expect to see if was referring to me. So, what have you been up to during the nightphases?
I'm inclined to leave Cyberkitten alone for the time being, it's her first game and I wouldn't expect someone new to choose a false claim that had a constant ability. But then again, she is new so we don't know how tricksy she can be....
cyberkitten01
07-25-2008, 12:26 PM
I'm pleased to say that if you read my posts on the rest of the forums, I'm far from subtle :) What you see is what you get
The Shape
07-25-2008, 12:30 PM
Shape, what's the "crucial" word that you've been looking for in the write-ups? I've been mentioned in the write-ups but I haven't seen anything written in them that I would expect to see if was referring to me. So, what have you been up to during the nightphases?
Well I don't expect to be able to identify myself without any particular traits and doubt I'd be "he" or "she". The crucial word is what I am, so really you're all just barking up the wrong tree xD
d_w_w
07-25-2008, 12:30 PM
I think it's 18 hours to go until the end of the day phase.
Shape, what's the "crucial" word that you've been looking for in the write-ups? I've been mentioned in the write-ups but I haven't seen anything written in them that I would expect to see if was referring to me. So, what have you been up to during the nightphases?
I'm inclined to leave Cyberkitten alone for the time being, it's her first game and I wouldn't expect someone new to choose a false claim that had a constant ability. But then again, she is new so we don't know how tricksy she can be....
UT - out of the people on the list, which worry you the most?
cyberkitten01
07-25-2008, 01:03 PM
Only 5 hours before the end of the Night phase. I think we need to get decisive. Of the list I think it's likely to be someone who doesn't post often, so I'm joining Astil
Change Vote: trypio
Undertaker666
07-25-2008, 01:07 PM
I'm pleased to say that if you read my posts on the rest of the forums, I'm far from subtle :) What you see is what you get
I'm English though, we know not to trust the Welsh. ;)
UT - out of the people on the list, which worry you the most?
All of 'em. :p
Only 5 hours before the end of the Night phase. I think we need to get decisive. Of the list I think it's likely to be someone who doesn't post often, so I'm joining Astil
Change Vote: trypio
Eh? The DAY phase ends 12pm GMT on Saturday.
d_w_w
07-25-2008, 01:09 PM
Only 5 hours before the end of the Night phase. I think we need to get decisive. Of the list I think it's likely to be someone who doesn't post often, so I'm joining Astil
Change Vote: trypio
trypio might be scum, but I don't see how he can be Sylar when others are willing to vouch for him. I don't see why Sylar would have any connections to other players.
cyberkitten01
07-25-2008, 01:10 PM
Eh? The DAY phase ends 12pm GMT on Saturday.
*Facepalm* I'm so used to these phases ending at midnight I forgot we had some shorter phases recently. Still, pressure!
cyberkitten01
07-25-2008, 01:12 PM
trypio might be scum, but I don't see how he can be Sylar when others are willing to vouch for him. I don't see why Sylar would have any connections to other players.
I should make notes. Some players are blurring together. Do we have any good suspects? We have to get Sylar as soon as possible
d_w_w
07-25-2008, 01:13 PM
We have some time, but really need to make some of directed effort to get to the bottom of this, as there a number of names on the list:
ford
foolinc
Sprinklefurball
Wallbanger
The Shape
cyberkitten01
Slim Jim
I pulled trypio, for the reasons I listed above. If we believe that Slim was gone, then it's probably not likely that he's Sylar (it just seems... too convenient that Peter was killed for Sylar to have had a random target that night, so I'm assuming that it was someone that has been around). Now, that's only if we believe that Slim was not gone.
And, like UT, I don't really feel like Cyberkitten is the culprit. That leaves:
ford
foolinc
Sprinklefurball
Wallbanger
The Shape
5 people, we have to pick one :(
Glotnot
07-25-2008, 01:14 PM
I think our two top Sylar suspects were you and Shape.
Glotnot
07-25-2008, 01:15 PM
Or not. I kind of want to pressure Shape, to be honest.
Undertaker666
07-25-2008, 01:20 PM
trypio might be scum, but I don't see how he can be Sylar when others are willing to vouch for him. I don't see why Sylar would have any connections to other players.
Indeed.
We have some time, but really need to make some of directed effort to get to the bottom of this, as there a number of names on the list:
ford
foolinc
Sprinklefurball
Wallbanger
The Shape
cyberkitten01
Slim Jim
I pulled trypio, for the reasons I listed above. If we believe that Slim was gone, then it's probably not likely that he's Sylar (it just seems... too convenient that Peter was killed for Sylar to have had a random target that night, so I'm assuming that it was someone that has been around). Now, that's only if we believe that Slim was not gone.
And, like UT, I don't really feel like Cyberkitten is the culprit. That leaves:
ford
foolinc
Sprinklefurball
Wallbanger
The Shape
5 people, we have to pick one :(
As scummy as it may make me seem, if I had to pick one of those to be lynched i'd go for Wallbanger because he didn't offer anything up when I asked him what he'd been doing, and then he scooted off on vacation. Obviously i've got nothing to suggest that he is Mafia or Sylar, but I also think he'd be the biggest threat if he was one of them.
d_w_w
07-25-2008, 01:27 PM
Wallbanger is probably the scariest of the list, because he really is that good. I don't feel like he's Sylar, although I can't really explain why. Call it intuition... I'm willing to go down that path though, but it would be under protest.
Now, if Sylar was not replaced, then Wallbanger is clean. Of course, Gonvick made a good point that SK's often have to target someone and if they do not, someone is randomly selected.
That means this player has actively targeted me (Version 1.0), Comradebot (the No Country for Old Men killer), and Orange-kun (Peter).
Targeting Orange-Kun made a lot of sense, given what was said on day 3.
Now, I'm pretty sure that d_w_w version 1.0 didn't give away any good info on day 1, so I'm not sure if that version of me was a completely random target or taken out by someone that's played with me before (I've only played one game here, so I'd be inclined to think that it was someone from Astil's site... someone that figured I'd be good to kill maybe, given my penchant for giving out info).
What about Comradebot? I can't really remember his play on d1 or d2, was there anything there that made him a good target?
Just trying to think of the different players on the list and if they would have been likely to target the people that Sylar killed.
This might be a fruitless thought experiment though, if the targets were randomly selected.
sprinklefurball
07-25-2008, 01:40 PM
change vote: no vote
The Shape
07-25-2008, 01:46 PM
trypio might be scum, but I don't see how he can be Sylar when others are willing to vouch for him. I don't see why Sylar would have any connections to other players.
Beggars can't be choosers, if we have to pick another target then might as well go for a scummy one.
And, like UT, I don't really feel like Cyberkitten is the culprit.
On what basis?
Or not. I kind of want to pressure Shape, to be honest.
I've hinted a fair bit. Not, I'm not sure how many of my kind hit the big screen in 2005, so I can't tell if it's obvious or really vague, but I should hope that my recent posts are enough to ease people's minds.
Undertaker666
07-25-2008, 01:47 PM
change vote: no vote
Anything you'd like to share?
I've hinted a fair bit. Not, I'm not sure how many of my kind hit the big screen in 2005, so I can't tell if it's obvious or really vague, but I should hope that my recent posts are enough to ease people's minds.
Knowing what you've been up to during the nightphases would ease my mind. :p
The Shape
07-25-2008, 01:53 PM
Knowing what you've been up to during the nightphases would ease my mind. :p
Nothing at this stage.
Undertaker666
07-25-2008, 01:55 PM
Nothing at this stage.
So you're saying that you've got a night ability but you haven't chosen to use it yet? Are you only allowed to use it a certain number of times then?
The Shape
07-25-2008, 02:00 PM
I don't have one whatsoever atm. If something specific happens then I might, I'm not entirely sure.
Undertaker666
07-25-2008, 02:03 PM
I don't have one whatsoever atm. If something specific happens then I might, I'm not entirely sure.
So we've now got you and Praguepride that both say you're not useful yet? If you haven't got a great ability to hide then, as with Praguepride, I fail to see why you don't reveal who you are.
The Shape
07-25-2008, 02:11 PM
Excuse me? I'm not just going to out myself needlessly, I've hinted a fair bit and told you about my role and I'm not just going to claim fully for the sake of it. You say it as though people have been asking me for ages, but I've been fully cooperative and responded every time someone's asked me something and put forward my own views on others. I don't see this to be as black and white as "I have to votes on me, better roleclaim" especially in a game where there's so much potential to make stuff up.
Undertaker666
07-25-2008, 02:15 PM
Excuse me? I'm not just going to out myself needlessly, I've hinted a fair bit and told you about my role and I'm not just going to claim fully for the sake of it. You say it as though people have been asking me for ages, but I've been fully cooperative and responded every time someone's asked me something and put forward my own views on others. I don't see this to be as black and white as "I have to votes on me, better roleclaim" especially in a game where there's so much potential to make stuff up.
You've just said yourself that there's the potential to make stuff up, so your hints could well be false too. Also take into account that not everyone is going to get your hints. Some people have hinted left, right and centre, but if I don't know what they're hinting at then the hints they've provided mean nothing. Remember what Chris Tarrant says on Millionaire, "They're only easy if you know the answers".
The Shape
07-25-2008, 02:20 PM
Well I haven't actually hinted at who I am, more what I am, I should think that's fairly obvious if you re-read my posts today. Then I've thrown in the date of 2005 for the movie's release, which hopefully narrows things down to just one on a big scale xD
Undertaker666
07-25-2008, 02:29 PM
Well I haven't actually hinted at who I am, more what I am, I should think that's fairly obvious if you re-read my posts today. Then I've thrown in the date of 2005 for the movie's release, which hopefully narrows things down to just one on a big scale xD
I just find it strange that you said this previously:
I'm not going to speak about my ability regardless but I'll happily character claim if needs be, unless people are appeased by the fact that I was one of these in my first game :cool:
You'll "happily character claim" eh....?
The Shape
07-25-2008, 02:29 PM
"if needs be" eh eh?
Undertaker666
07-25-2008, 02:31 PM
"if needs be" eh eh?
And does this not seem like a "if needs be" situation eh, eh?
The Shape
07-25-2008, 02:35 PM
Well it's only you whose pushing it atm (been far too quiet today for my liking, lol) and others seem to have moved on, I have like 1 or 2 votes and think even those will be shifted soon enough.
Astil
07-25-2008, 02:36 PM
Change Vote: The Shape
The Shape
07-25-2008, 02:41 PM
I'll claim if everyone in the UK phones 09016 16 16 13 repeatedly for the next hour and a half :o
(what? don't we all watch big brother?!)
Undertaker666
07-25-2008, 02:41 PM
Well it's only you whose pushing it atm (been far too quiet today for my liking, lol) and others seem to have moved on, I have like 1 or 2 votes and think even those will be shifted soon enough.
Vote counts shouldn't matter as we've got a great opportunity to weed out Sylar and a Mafia member, all you're doing is confusing issues which isn't helping. (if you're a townie of course, otherwise your plan is working)
Change vote: The Shape
Undertaker666
07-25-2008, 02:42 PM
I'll claim if everyone in the UK phones 09016 16 16 13 repeatedly for the next hour and a half :o
(what? don't we all watch big brother?!)
You should be lynched simply for watching that abomination of a TV show. :p
The Shape
07-25-2008, 02:42 PM
Yeah don't worry, I'm off for a bit in 20 minutes so will claim now in case anything needs straightening out before I do.
Danny, Convention Aligned Domesticated Dog
Of “Unleashed” Fame
The Shape
07-25-2008, 02:42 PM
You should be lynched simply for watching that abomination of a TV show. :p
It'll be less of an abomination if you phone that number ;)
Undertaker666
07-25-2008, 02:46 PM
Yeah don't worry, I'm off for a bit in 20 minutes so will claim now in case anything needs straightening out before I do.
Danny, Convention Aligned Domesticated Dog
Of “Unleashed” Fame
I've got absolutely no idea who or what you're talking about. :confused:
It'll be less of an abomination if you phone that number ;)
It'll still be an abomination. :p
The Shape
07-25-2008, 02:47 PM
I've got absolutely no idea who or what you're talking about. :confused:
Nor did I, but I looked it up and apparently the film did quite well in america *shrug*
Undertaker666
07-25-2008, 02:49 PM
Nor did I, but I looked it up and apparently the film did quite well in america *shrug*
With your dog clues I thought you were on about Lords of Dogtown.
You know, you're on the list as well. Anything you can reveal that will allow us to take you off the list?
I haven't been able to do anything yet, but I will say that Jackal shouldn't have to worry about being imprisoned forever. He should "break free" during this night phase... as long as I don't die of course. Then, w
ebwop: Then well... I dunno what would happen, as it'd be out of my hands then.
The Shape
07-25-2008, 02:53 PM
With your dog clues I thought you were on about Lords of Dogtown.
xD well I said I wasn't a "he" or "she" more of an "it" and that I'd been one of these before (brian in cartoon chaos, my first game), and a quick look at wiki suggests there's no actual dogs in that :o
mjdgoldeneye
07-25-2008, 03:05 PM
Danny is a Jet Li character from a movie I only barely remember ads for...
The claim is so random and unlikely that I kind of believe it.
"Unleashed" didn't do "very well" in the US, but did, in fact, exist, apparently...
cyberkitten01
07-25-2008, 03:15 PM
Danny, Convention Aligned Domesticated Dog
Of “Unleashed” Fame
Oh yeah, that really didn't click as a Jet Li film when I read that. I love Jet Li :)
Undertaker666
07-25-2008, 03:30 PM
RKO_HBK, you said this:
Just caught up with the last 20 pages, I was going to vote Praguepride, but it seems we're going in a slightly different direction. And Jbergey, just to clarify:
Just wondering why I'm on the list and....
...why you voted for me before I'd had any chance to argue my case?
But then you didn't argue your case and you've said nothing since, anything you'd like to share? Have you been up to anything during the nightphases?
gonvick
07-25-2008, 03:40 PM
I haven't been able to do anything yet, but I will say that Jackal shouldn't have to worry about being imprisoned forever. He should "break free" during this night phase... as long as I don't die of course. Then, w
Well, I guess that would clear you from being Sylar at least. But your choice of targets makes me seriously question your alignment.
As for Shape's claim, I don't know. It's certainly obscure enough to work as a false claim. And the whole 'I don't do anything now but might later at some point' doesn't help his case either. All together, I don't feel any better about him than before.
RKO_HBK
07-25-2008, 03:47 PM
RKO_HBK, you said this:
But then you didn't argue your case and you've said nothing since, anything you'd like to share? Have you been up to anything during the nightphases?
I was waiting for him to respond, but no worries. I've not done anything during the nightphases yet, but I do have an ability that I can only use once. Not really sure what else to say, but I'm happy to answer any questions.
d_w_w
07-25-2008, 03:53 PM
Danny is the human attack dog role where the evil boss guy uses him to beat up folks that haven't paid back their loans or whatever?
I guess I'll buy the role, but I find it odd that he has no night abilities. I mean, Jet Li as a human attack dog with no night abilities? That doesn't sound super plausible to me.
d_w_w
07-25-2008, 03:53 PM
Well, I guess that would clear you from being Sylar at least. But your choice of targets makes me seriously question your alignment.
And yeah, I'd like to hear a little bit more about why you selected Jackalbane...
The Shape
07-25-2008, 04:05 PM
"Unleashed" didn't do "very well" in the US, but did, in fact, exist, apparently...
Ah right. I had a quick look on wiki and noticed a big-ish number by the gross thing, but really I'm clueless as to proportionally what's good lol.
Danny is the human attack dog role where the evil boss guy uses him to beat up folks that haven't paid back their loans or whatever?
I guess I'll buy the role, but I find it odd that he has no night abilities. I mean, Jet Li as a human attack dog with no night abilities? That doesn't sound super plausible to me.
Without going into too much detail and not knowing what is and isn't part of the film, basically I'm not working for a boss anymore and am out on my own and unsure of what to do, hence why I ended up here.
Undertaker666
07-25-2008, 04:09 PM
I was waiting for him to respond, but no worries. I've not done anything during the nightphases yet, but I do have an ability that I can only use once. Not really sure what else to say, but I'm happy to answer any questions.
Care to share who you are?
Danny is the human attack dog role where the evil boss guy uses him to beat up folks that haven't paid back their loans or whatever?
I guess I'll buy the role, but I find it odd that he has no night abilities. I mean, Jet Li as a human attack dog with no night abilities? That doesn't sound super plausible to me.
So he's a human attack dog who works for an evil boss? Hmmmmmmm.
Without going into too much detail and not knowing what is and isn't part of the film, basically I'm not working for a boss anymore and am out on my own and unsure of what to do, hence why I ended up here.
You've said you're not going to disclose your ability, but you could you tell us why you haven't used this ability yet?
The Shape
07-25-2008, 04:10 PM
As for Shape's claim, I don't know. It's certainly obscure enough to work as a false claim. And the whole 'I don't do anything now but might later at some point' doesn't help his case either. All together, I don't feel any better about him than before.
It fits with the role and the way its described really, not sure how much is the end of the film and how much is Crychon's imagination, but basically the character has changed its actions recently and certain things could lead to them changing back to their old ways...really I'd rather not say any more at this point, so hopefully everyone's at least convinced enough to pursue other targets for now. With the time frame we're working in I'd like to think so as I think we'll need to still reach a majority on Jbergy regardless of taker's ability.
The Shape
07-25-2008, 04:11 PM
You've said you're not going to disclose your ability, but you could you tell us why you haven't used this ability yet?
I can't, unless something happens. Or things. Right now, I'm vanilla.
Undertaker666
07-25-2008, 04:12 PM
It fits with the role and the way its described really, not sure how much is the end of the film and how much is Crychon's imagination, but basically the character has changed its actions recently and certain things could lead to them changing back to their old ways...really I'd rather not say any more at this point, so hopefully everyone's at least convinced enough to pursue other targets for now. With the time frame we're working in I'd like to think so as I think we'll need to still reach a majority on Jbergy regardless of taker's ability.
So basically you're saying that you can turn evil? That's not very comforting.
The Shape
07-25-2008, 04:14 PM
lol not evil. I don't think my boss is in the game, there's no hints to him and he could have died in the film for all I know.
Allegiance would remain the same but actions would revert, if you get me?
d_w_w
07-25-2008, 04:16 PM
In the movie, Danny starts off working for some evil loan shark. A plot twist comes, and some old blind guy helps him out, helps him to become more human and less aggressive and feral.
The fact that you could revert... well, like UT says, that's not terribly comforting.
d_w_w
07-25-2008, 04:16 PM
lol not evil. I don't think my boss is in the game, there's no hints to him and he could have died in the film for all I know.
Allegiance would remain the same but actions would revert, if you get me?
Ah, I see.
mjdgoldeneye
07-25-2008, 04:16 PM
From what wiki says and from what I know about the movie, Danny isn't evil. He just has no choice.
Have we seen any attacks by a "human attack dog" yet?
Basically, I don't fear The Shape at the moment.
However, his master is probably in the game, and is definitely evil if that's the case.
Fun Fact: Astil randomly mentioned Jet Li in an early post that I found kind of weird.
RKO_HBK
07-25-2008, 04:17 PM
Care to share who you are?
I'm not sure if it'll help, because I've never seen the show so I don't know much at all about my character, but:
You are Hiro Nakamura, Convention Aligned _______
Of “Heroes” Fame
I've left out the last bit purely because it includes my ability, which could prove very useful. I'll post it if you still need confirmation that I'm town, but it would be more useful for us if I didn't reveal it just yet.
mjdgoldeneye
07-25-2008, 04:18 PM
I was kind of late with that post, as things were just covered...
I say that if we see any dog-like attacks on townies, we'll know what to do...
The Shape
07-25-2008, 04:19 PM
ANOTHER heroes character? Thought this was for films? xD
And I don't think my boss is in the game. Looking back he's mentioned in the backstory but the bit about me going to the convention is detatched from that. Can't rule it out but still I'd suggest otherwise atm.
d_w_w
07-25-2008, 04:19 PM
I'm not sure if it'll help, because I've never seen the show so I don't know much at all about my character, but:
You are Hiro Nakamura, Convention Aligned _______
Of “Heroes” Fame
I've left out the last bit purely because it includes my ability, which could prove very useful. I'll post it if you still need confirmation that I'm town, but it would be more useful for us if I didn't reveal it just yet.
Heroes, Heroes, Heroes... everywhere :eek:
Sigh, if you're telling the truth, I suspect it has suddenly become much more imperative that we get Sylar this phase...
mjdgoldeneye
07-25-2008, 04:19 PM
I'm not sure if it'll help, because I've never seen the show so I don't know much at all about my character, but:
You are Hiro Nakamura, Convention Aligned _______
Of “Heroes” Fame
I've left out the last bit purely because it includes my ability, which could prove very useful. I'll post it if you still need confirmation that I'm town, but it would be more useful for us if I didn't reveal it just yet.
We know what you do... You were in the last GDS game...
RKO_HBK
07-25-2008, 04:21 PM
We know what you do... You were in the last GDS game...
Oh...I've not played since the 2nd ever mafia game on the board, so I had no idea.
Undertaker666
07-25-2008, 04:23 PM
From what wiki says and from what I know about the movie, Danny isn't evil. He just has no choice.
Have we seen any attacks by a "human attack dog" yet?
Basically, I don't fear The Shape at the moment.
However, his master is probably in the game, and is definitely evil if that's the case.
Fun Fact: Astil randomly mentioned Jet Li in an early post that I found kind of weird.
I was kind of late with that post, as things were just covered...
I say that if we see any dog-like attacks on townies, we'll know what to do...
I think you're missing the point, he could very well be lying. We could be sat around waiting for a "human attack dog" reference in the write-up whilst he's out removing the tops of peoples heads. Is he Sylar? I don't know, but the idea shouldn't be dismissed based purely on what he's said.
gonvick
07-25-2008, 04:24 PM
lol not evil. I don't think my boss is in the game, there's no hints to him and he could have died in the film for all I know.
Allegiance would remain the same but actions would revert, if you get me?
Well, I'm not prepared to remove you from the list of suspects at this point. But there's not much more that can be done with this. So moving on for now is a fine idea.
RKO_HBK
07-25-2008, 04:25 PM
I'm off for the night now, Smackdown starts in 5. I'll catch up after work tomorrow.
The Shape
07-25-2008, 04:26 PM
I think you're missing the point, he could very well be lying. We could be sat around waiting for a "human attack dog" reference in the write-up whilst he's out removing the tops of peoples heads. Is he Sylar? I don't know, but the idea shouldn't be dismissed based purely on what he's said.
And I expect as much. But there's literally nothing more that I know that you don't, so I want to start clarifying things for the rest of this day phase.
With regards to your ability will we still need a majority vote during this day? As if we get within a couple of hours of the deadline votes for jbergy will be needed unless something else has come up. And on that note we should get back to the rest of that list, foolinc being a name that I recall but I'm sure there were others. If they can't be hear to speak up it might be worth the risk of just going for them, as by process of elimination we could be looking at a 1 in 3/4 shot...
mjdgoldeneye
07-25-2008, 04:28 PM
I think you're missing the point, he could very well be lying. We could be sat around waiting for a "human attack dog" reference in the write-up whilst he's out removing the tops of peoples heads. Is he Sylar? I don't know, but the idea shouldn't be dismissed based purely on what he's said.
But what he's said is so ridiculously random that I doubt it's a false claim...
Knowing where The Shape is from, having the entire movie and TV universe at hand for a false claim, who would choose a random Jet Li character of questionable alignment?
Besides, I don't think he's Sylar.
I haven't read super well today (Fantasy Football stuff, working around the house a bit, etc.), but should we believe there are 3 (or more if I missed one) Heroes characters in this game? RKO_HBK seems iffy to me...
Undertaker666
07-25-2008, 04:32 PM
With regards to your ability will we still need a majority vote during this day?
No, but it'd be best used if we achieve a lynch, if only to narrow down the list of suspects.
Undertaker666
07-25-2008, 04:33 PM
Besides, I don't think he's Sylar.
So who do you think Sylar is?
masterded
07-25-2008, 04:36 PM
I hate you all. I take off for about 2 days am too lazy to do anything last night and too busy getting ready for work and drafting for FF (damn you mjd),, So I have been at work about an hour and a half read all the damn posts (and thanks to ier and others most of it was nothing) and now I have to go reread it all becuase I forgot half of it by the time I finished (though at least I get to reread through someone rcing a person in a game of character. If it isn't a lie, he should have lied and said he was Ash).
gonvick
07-25-2008, 04:38 PM
And I expect as much. But there's literally nothing more that I know that you don't, so I want to start clarifying things for the rest of this day phase.
With regards to your ability will we still need a majority vote during this day? As if we get within a couple of hours of the deadline votes for jbergy will be needed unless something else has come up. And on that note we should get back to the rest of that list, foolinc being a name that I recall but I'm sure there were others. If they can't be hear to speak up it might be worth the risk of just going for them, as by process of elimination we could be looking at a 1 in 3/4 shot...
The remainder of the list that are unknowns to me would be:
Slim Jim
Sprinklefurball
Wallbanger
That's not to say that one of them must be Sylar, as it's quite possible one of the others are lying, but these are the ones I don't have anything for yet.
d_w_w
07-25-2008, 04:39 PM
No, but it'd be best used if we achieve a lynch, if only to narrow down the list of suspects.
Just to be clear. What are the steps that we're aiming for (not asking for detals of what will happen or anything).
Do we lynch someone and then you use your power, or do you use your power and then we lynch someone?
Undertaker666
07-25-2008, 04:41 PM
Just to be clear. What are the steps that we're aiming for (not asking for detals of what will happen or anything).
Do we lynch someone and then you use your power, or do you use your power and then we lynch someone?
Lynch, then power.
d_w_w
07-25-2008, 04:42 PM
The remainder of the list that are unknowns to me would be:
Slim Jim
Sprinklefurball
Wallbanger
That's not to say that one of them must be Sylar, as it's quite possible one of the others are lying, but these are the ones I don't have anything for yet.
Yeah, I'm not really sure how much I believe some of their claims.
If I had to pick from this list, I'd go for Sprinkelfurball. But again, that would be purely hunch driven.
d_w_w
07-25-2008, 04:42 PM
Lynch, then power.
Ok - in that case, do you think it's best if we lynch a Sylar subject or should we keep with the Jbergey lynch?
Undertaker666
07-25-2008, 04:44 PM
Ok - in that case, do you think it's best if we lynch a Sylar subject or should we keep with the Jbergey lynch?
Jbergey is a Sylar suspect. :p
mjdgoldeneye
07-25-2008, 04:45 PM
So who do you think Sylar is?
I already made my suggestion... RKO_HBK seems more likely to me than Shape, as I can't see all that many heroes characters after we've just done a Heroes game...
Is there a "Sylar list"? (I think there is, but I haven't actually seen it yet.) IDK, I'm kind of behind.
gonvick
07-25-2008, 04:56 PM
Is there a "Sylar list"? (I think there is, but I haven't actually seen it yet.) IDK, I'm kind of behind.
Here's the original list:
d_w_w
ford
blackphoenix
foolinc
Undertaker666
Sprinklefurball
trypio
Wallbanger
The Shape
BlueStar
cyberkitten01
Slim Jim
I think d_w_w, ford, blackphoenix, Undertaker, trypio, and BlueStar can all be safely removed.
foolinc, The Shape, and cyberkitten have all claimed/hinted at being someone other than Sylar.
d_w_w
07-25-2008, 04:57 PM
Jbergey is a Sylar suspect. :p
Not really. Remember, praguepride's partner investigated one of Sylar's killings and came up with this list of suspects:
d_w_w
ford
blackphoenix
foolinc
Undertaker666
Sprinklefurball
trypio
Wallbanger
The Shape
BlueStar
cyberkitten01
Slim Jim
We've eliminated a bunch of them, but jbergey isn't on the list. I'm not saying he's not scum, but I doubt he's Sylar.
And remember, praguepride gave us this list after I pushed him, revealing that I knew his ability. And, based on what my result from looking at prague last night said, this list seems like something legitimate that would be associated with his ability.
The only way this list does not contain Sylar is if Crychon made it so that praguepride and his partner received a list of suspects that did not include the actual killer. Which would be really cruel of Crychon, don't you think?
Slim Jim
07-25-2008, 04:59 PM
Well, I'm here, so if you have any questions, fire away.
d_w_w
07-25-2008, 05:01 PM
Well, I'm here, so if you have any questions, fire away.
I would. But I have to go log out, before I get fired for submiting overtime :rolleyes:
For now, how about this: have you been in any of the writeups?
Be back when I get home and such.
gonvick
07-25-2008, 05:04 PM
Well, I'm here, so if you have any questions, fire away.
Anything you can reveal that would reassure us that you're not Sylar?
mjdgoldeneye
07-25-2008, 05:05 PM
Of the, I believe, 3 left, all I can say is if it's Wallbanger, he'll be able to false claim his way out of this, probably...
Undertaker666
07-25-2008, 05:10 PM
Not really. Remember, praguepride's partner investigated one of Sylar's killings and came up with this list of suspects:
d_w_w
ford
blackphoenix
foolinc
Undertaker666
Sprinklefurball
trypio
Wallbanger
The Shape
BlueStar
cyberkitten01
Slim Jim
Speaking for myself though, i'd like to know how that list was created, why are those people on the list and not others etc.? There's no way I should be on there because I don't even leave my hotel room, as has been proven by multiple people visiting me.
And remember, praguepride gave us this list after I pushed him, revealing that I knew his ability. And, based on what my result from looking at prague last night said, this list seems like something legitimate that would be associated with his ability.
The only way this list does not contain Sylar is if Crychon made it so that praguepride and his partner received a list of suspects that did not include the actual killer. Which would be really cruel of Crychon, don't you think?
One of the two partners could very well "Paranoid" don't you think?
Slim Jim
07-25-2008, 05:14 PM
I would. But I have to go log out, before I get fired for submiting overtime :rolleyes:
For now, how about this: have you been in any of the writeups?
Be back when I get home and such.
Two, though one phase I was active in I wasn't mentioned and one that I wasn't active in, I was mentioned. I wasn't mentioned in the last night phase.
Anything you can reveal that would reassure us that you're not Sylar?
Err... how about, "I'm not Sylar"? :D Hmm, not really anything I can say that wouldn't make it obvious. I am from an American TV show, but not Heroes... and I had heard of me, and I expect all Brits in the game would have too.
foolinc
07-25-2008, 05:25 PM
Of the, I believe, 3 left, all I can say is if it's Wallbanger, he'll be able to false claim his way out of this, probably...
To be honest, everyone has a pretty good chance of getting away with a false claim in this game. There are just too many characters in the world of TV and Movies.
praguepride
07-25-2008, 05:35 PM
So we've now got you and Praguepride that both say you're not useful yet? If you haven't got a great ability to hide then, as with Praguepride, I fail to see why you don't reveal who you are.
Well, I guess I should clarify. As you saw, I was given a really big list. Now it has some good info on it, but it in itself is useless without my partner. Now that the list is published, I've got nothing, really. Ordinarily I'd have to wait and wait as the list gets narrowed down (and it was narrowed down, I removed the people already dead) so if Sylar slipped through the cracks I'd be able to pin him down by the end game, but if we get him early... yay.
Alright, I don't have time to reprint every quote, but I'll try and address stuff
Q From Undertaker: How was the list generated? Why are people on there? Blah blah blah.
This list was generated by taking Sylar and a bunch of random people and throwing them together, at least that's been my guess so far. As for it's accuracy, it's accurate. My character is a skeptic, the partner's the crazy one :D, so I don't have to worry about sanity. Finally, I'm not playing Maxwell Smart, so I'm pretty sure this list is accurate.
Danny the Human Attack Dog: This seems like a really weird role, and I think I'm gonna cry foul at this. In the movie, Danny was a combat god that would rip people apart. By the end of the movie, he was a protector, destroying the "mafia" (in the movie it was the evil loan shark) after the shark threatened Danny's new family. It seems really strange that he wouldn't have a protector role, that he wouldn't have a night ability, and Danny was never evil, so there's only a few situations I can think of that would make you not want to use your ability, as hinted.
Although it is a weird role claim, I'm still thinking that Sylar is a quiet chap hanging in the background. Haven't really heard much from Wallbanger or Sprinklefur...
praguepride
07-25-2008, 05:39 PM
On a completely unrelated note, my "Super" Heroes game is pretty much ready to go. Plus due to a research prospect at work I might be able to get the GDS forums unblocked so I would actually be able to mod it during my lunch break.
I know other people haven't been really excited about another mafia game, but I'm excited :D. I think I'll enjoy modding more then playing at this point.
Not to say I'm not having fun, but I always enjoy being an observer, knowing all the secrets and watching as people lie, cheat, and steal their way out of tight spots.
praguepride
07-25-2008, 05:46 PM
Looking at my list, is it wrong that everyone has some sort of "power." Not all powers are equal, but pretty much everyone has some sort of special condition to their power that actually affects game mechanics (no posting restrictions yet)
Crychon
07-25-2008, 05:50 PM
It is now day phase four. You have until 7:00 AM EST Saturday, July 26th (12:00 PM Saturday, July 26th GMT) to reach a majority decision.
jbergey_2005: 6 (Wallbanger, The Shape, i effin rule, TheEdgeOfReason, Glotnot, praguepride)
The Shape: 3 (blackphoenix, Astil, Undertaker666)
praguepride: 2 (mjdgoldeneye, The Aussie)
The Aussie: 2 (Astil, ford)
RKO_HBK: 1 (jbergey_2005)
trypio: 1 (cyberkitten01)
With 27 players remaining, it is 14 to lynch.
Undertaker666
07-25-2008, 05:58 PM
This list was generated by taking Sylar and a bunch of random people and throwing them together, at least that's been my guess so far.
Errrrr.... what?
As for it's accuracy, it's accurate.
How can it be accurate when you aren't even sure how the list was created?
My character is a skeptic, the partner's the crazy one :D
You said previously that you can't use your ability yet, so therefore it would've been your crazy partner who created the list. With your partner being paranoid (unlikely that person isn't), how can you say the list is accurate?
vBulletin® v3.6.8, Copyright ©2000-2013, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.