2008 GDS Scummie Awards -- VOTING/DISCUSSION THREAD

[Wallbanger]

Voting is now closed.

2008 Scummies
Official Ballot


The i effin rule Best Role Claim Award

This category is to recognize the most effective role claim in a single game which impacts the outcome of the game and has high dramatic/entertainment value. Whether the claim was truthful or not is immaterial, only the game and narrative impact of the claim should be considered.

The Shape as Note Giver (false), Lakeside's Grand Finale
Arrows as Town Charlatan (false), Lakeside's Grand Finale
Glotnot as Brea Tonnika (false), Star Wars Mafia II
Undertaker666 as Victoria Pratt (false), Heroes Mafia
foolinc as Mephisto, Marvel Mafia
Imarevenant as Simon Dark (false), Gotham Nights


The trypio Funniest Role Claim Award

This category is to recognize the funniest/most entertaining roleclaim in a single game, regardless of game impact.

Slim Jim/BlueStar as Maybe Dick, Rocky and Bullwinkle Mafia
The Aussie as Arrows, Forum Wars
masterded as Duncan Macleod (false), Hollywood Horror
Lostrelms as Megatron, Cartoon Chaos
Comradebot as The Gambler, Music Mythology Mafia
Imarevenant as Chev Chelios, Hollywood Horror


The 'Ugly Duckling/Psychotic Swan' Best Role Award

This category is to recognize well-crafted roles in a single mafia game. Remember the award is for the ROLE, not the PLAYER. A well crafted role played poorly should not be penalized in this category.

The Joker, Gotham Nights
Sylar, Heroes Mafia
Panix, Forum Wars
Venom, Marvel Mafia
Thanos, Marvel Mafia
Mr. Freeze, Gotham Nights


The Panix Award (Person Most Likely to Die First Day)

Fairly self-explanatory, this category is to recognize players who seem to have a short lifespan, either because they're not trusted, or because they're so well respected that no one wants them around in case they're not on the same side.

The Aussie
blackphoenix
UFC-King


The Undertaker666 Best Individual Performance - Town Award

This category is to recognize outstanding individual performance in playing a town-aligned character in a single game.

nZane as Nien Nunb, Star Wars Mafia II
petrija as Molly Walker, Heroes Mafia
Cyberkitten as V, Hollywood Horror
Wallbanger as Slim Jim, Forum Wars
widowmaker as Sexy Chat Princess, MMO Mafia
Lostrelms as Rocket J. Squirrel, Rocky and Bullwinkle Mafia


The derekb Best Individual Performance - Mafia Award

This category is to recognize outstanding individual performance in playing a mafia-aligned character in a single game.

theoutlaw321 as Thanos, Marvel Mafia
Bear as Vengeance Minded Ex-Husband, Lakeside's Grand Finale
Arrows as Fast Talking Charlatan, Lakeside's Grand Finale
Gonvick as Mr. Freeze, Gotham Nights
The Shape as Really Fast Runner, Lakeside's Grand Finale
Arrows as Penguin, Gotham Nights


The Wallbanger Best Individual Performance - Cult Award

This category is to recognize outstanding individual performance in playing a cult-aligned character in a single game.

Nevermore as Midnightnick, Forum Wars
theoutlaw321 as Police Officer, Welcome to E-Ville
Lostrelms as Cult Leader, Welcome to E-Ville
petrija as Heir to the Pack, Lakeside's Grand Finale


The Best Individual Performance - Mason/Individual Award

This category is to recognize outstanding individual performance in playing characters with individual or special alignments in a single game.

Nevermore as Bobba Fett, Star Wars Mafia II
derek_b as Beltcher Crankcase, Rocky and Bullwinkle Mafia
The Shape as Admiral Ackbar, Star Wars 2.0
Crychon as Nell Fenwick, Rocky and Bullwinkle Mafia
Midnightnick as Mon Mothma, Star Wars Mafia II
i effin rule as Alfred Pennyworth, Gotham Nights


The Axis of Evil Best Group Performance Award

This category is to recognize outstanding group performance in a single game regardless of alignment. "The town" is considered a group for purposes of this category.

Mafia, Lakeside's Grand Finale
Titans, Marvel Mafia
The Moon Men, Rocky and Bullwinkle Mafia
Hutt Cartel, Star Wars Mafia II
Town, Hollywood Horror
CLAN, Forum Wars


The theoutlaw321 Best Contribution to Mafia Discussion Award

This category is to recognize individual players whose overall quality of discussion contributes to the enjoyment of the game for all players over the course of the year.

derek_b
Wallbanger
Midnightnick
Mr. T Jobs to Me
Gonvick
nZane


The theoutlaw321 Best Scum Catcher Award

This category is to recognize players who have a knack for identifying mafia and successfully eliminating them from play over the course of the year.

Arrows
i effin rule
Wallbanger
djthefunkchris


The Panix Best Serial Killer Award

This category is to recognize the most effective performance by a serial killer, cannibal, and/or psychopath in a single game. Both high body count and fear struck in the hearts of players should be taken into account in this category.

Prophet as Last Brother Standing, Lakeside's Grand Finale
djthefunkchris as Panix, Forum Wars
mjdgoldeneye as Sylar, Heroes Mafia
Ford as Sylar, Hollywood Horror


The Jim Force/Panix Funniest Player Award

This category is to recognize the funniest/most entertaining player overall over the course of the year.

derek_b
Astil
Comradebot
blackphoenix
Midnightnick
Prophet


The Undertaker666 Most Prolific Player Award

This category is to recognize the player who has generated the most quality participation over the course of the year. This should not be considered a 'post-whore' award, it is for consistent, meaningful participation in the GDS mafia community over the course of the year.

Arrows
Wallbanger
Moe Hunter
Crychon
Midnightnick
djthefunkchris


The Barebones Mafia Most Enjoyable Game Award

What was your favorite game in 2008?

Star Wars Mafia II
Hollywood Horror
Marvel Mafia
Gotham Nights
Lakeside's Grand Finale
Welcome to E-ville
Forum Wars


The DOTT Mafia Best Night Scene Award

This category is to recognize an outstanding writeup for a night scene in a single game. Both composition and game impact should be taken into consideration.

Marvel Mafia, Night 5
Welcome to E-Ville, Night 16
Forum Wars, Night 10
Forum Wars, Night 1
Star Wars Mafia II, Night 2


Best Overall Writeups Award

This category is to recognize the overall writing of lynches, night scenes and special events for a single game. Composition, game impact, consistency of style, and the overall storytelling of the collective game writeups should be taken into consideration.

Marvel Mafia (Imarevenant/Antithesis)
Rocky and Bullwinkle (Wallbanger/theoutlaw321)
Hollywood Horror (Crychon)
Forum Wars (theoutlaw321)
Cartoon Chaos (mjdgoldeneye/Antithesis)
MMO Mafia (d_w_w/blackphoenix)


The machinesxe/Midnightnick Most Improved Player Award

This category is to recognize a player who has made considerable strides in his play throughout the year.

Glotnot
Comeradebot
BIGJOSH
James Casey
nZane
Astil


The SadisticBlessings Best Moderator Award

This category is to recognize a moderator who has achieved distinctive excellence in scenario design, game balancing, entertaining writeups and adjudication of issues.

i effin rule/Imarevenant, Star Wars Mafia II
Imarevenant/Antithesis, Marvel Mafia
theoutlaw321, Forum Wars/Rocky and Bullwinkle
djthefunkchris, Gotham Nights
Crychon, Hollywood Horror
derekb/Arrows, Welcome to E-Ville


The Barebones Mafia Most Dramatic Moment In Game Award

This category recognizes outstanding dramatic moments in game due to the players' interaction, shift in game momentum and/or the invocation of abilities to create a swerve.

PeterHilton (cappyboy) daykill of Slim Jim (Wallbanger), Forum Wars
Reveal of Masons Night 1, Marvel Mafia
Masons accuse Outlaw, Welcome to Eville
Choosing between The Shape and sprinklefurball as Joker, Gotham Nights
Voting on masterded at the wrong time of dayphase, Forum Wars
Interrogation of sprinklefurball as suspected Thanos, Marvel Mafia


Rookie of the Year - 2008

This category recognizes outstanding contributions to the game by a new player. For purposes of this award, a 'rookie' is defined as a player who played and completed their FIRST GDS mafia game in calendar year 2008.

Bear
The Shape
d_w_w
Comradebot
Cyberkitten
blackphoenix


The "It Seemed Like A Good Idea At The Time" Award

Also referred to as 'Best Botch', this category is for recognizing the most memorable moment where a particular player choice/action/statement doesn't go exactly the way it was meant to.

Maybe Dick Double False Claim, Rocky and Bullwinkle Mafia
Namor scenario, Marvel Mafia
Jar-Jar Binks reveal, Star Wars Mafia II
foolinc targets Moe Hunter, Lakeside's Grand Finale
Electing djthefunkchris moderator, Forum Wars
TJRoH outing the Cult, Welcome to E-Ville


The Most Underrated Player Award

This category is to recognize up-and-coming players who have had multiple high quality performances, yet seems not to be well known within the mafia community.

Gonvick
Bluestar
masterded
Jbergey
Prophet
Mr T. Jobs to Me


GDS Mafia Hall of Fame - 2008

This category is to induct the Class of 2008 of the GDS Mafia Hall of Fame, recognizing outstanding overall performance, community spirit, and honorable play. This category will be conducted with a weighted vote system. Vote for three (3) nominees, assigning your top choice five (5) points, your second choice three (3) points, and your third choice one (1) point. A minimum of three nominiees will be inducted; additional inductees may be chosen based on overall score.

Wallbanger
djthefunkchris
Arrows
mjdgoldeneye
derek_b
Mr T. Jobs to Me
i effin rule

---

Short Form (Copy and paste to PM for your convenience)

Best Roleclaim:
Funniest Roleclaim:
Best Role:
Panix Award:
BIP-Town:
BIP-Mafia:
BIP-Cult:
BIP-Mason/Indy:
Best Group:
Best Discussion:
Best Scum Catcher:
Best Serial Killer:
Funniest Player:
Most Prolific:
Most Enjoyable Game:
Best Night Scene:
Best Overall Writeups:
Most Improved:
Best Moderator:
Most Dramatic Moment:
Rookie of the Year:
Best Botch:
Most Underrated:
Hall of Fame (5 points):
Hall of Fame (3 points):
Hall of Fame (1 point):

---

Voting Rules

One vote per account.
You must have at least 10 posts on the forum to vote (to prevent dummy accounts).
You needn't vote for every category, but try to vote for as many as you can.
You can't vote for yourself or a group you were a member of where you as a player/moderator/group are nominated. You can vote for events you were involved in (like Most Dramatic Moment or Best Botch).
PM ballots to both myself and theoutlaw321 (That's 'Wallbanger; theoutlaw321' in the PM's address box.)
Voting closes 12:00am EST/5am GMT Sunday, January 18th.---

Notes on the final ballot:

Outlaw and I collaborated to trim down the catagories with over six nominations. In similar fashion to last year we tried to follow some core principles: 1) making sure that as many different games were represented as possible, 2) where individuals were nominated multiple times (like a player nominated twice in a best performance category from different games) we tried to identify the stronger nomination and keep it, and 3) all other things being equal, the nominee with fewer total nominations would be given consideration in order to have as many community members contending for a Scummie as possible. (There was one category, though where we decided to leave seven on the ballot - Best Game. We just couldn't bring ourselves to take one off the list, they were all just too good.) We've tried our best to be fair, and we hope that is apparent.

---

Feel free to use this thread to discuss, lobby, cajole and beg for votes as you see fit. Just remember, Mafia is only a game.

[theoutlaw321]

If you have a problem with anything, Banger is the one that cut your's out. :D:cool:

[Wallbanger]

/looks up

Hey, where'd that bus come from?

[Antithesis]

Being "Discussion" is in the thread title. Would it be a problem if I argued for people I think deserve it (and maybe argue in a few cases against people I don't think desrve it ?)

[theoutlaw321]

Being "Discussion" is in the thread title. Would it be a problem if I argued for people I think deserve it (and maybe argue in a few cases against people I don't think desrve it ?)

/nod I am okay with it

Banger?

[Wallbanger]

Feel free to use this thread to discuss, lobby, cajole and beg for votes as you see fit. Just remember, Mafia is only a game.

We may not be in the Dog Pound anymore, but please observe the Code of Conduct anyway.

[Antithesis]

We may not be in the Dog Pound anymore, but please observe the Code of Conduct anyway.

Ahh I didn't read the fine print.

And I promise I will be both reasonable and civil.

[d_w_w]

I'm lazy and I'd love it if someone with free time happened to paste the best night scene write-up nominations in this thread :o;):D

[theoutlaw321]

I'm lazy and I'd love it if someone with free time happened to paste the best night scene write-up nominations in this thread :o;):D

You can get mine from the discussion thread. About four or five posts in. I have updated my links. The others may have to searched for. I will check if I get a chance.

[theoutlaw321]

http://67.19.230.90/~arles/forum/showthread.php?p=400627#post400627

Forum Wars Night 1

[i effin rule]

When the hell did I get added to the HOF ballot? That's a surprise, for sure.

[Imarevenant]

I'm lazy and I'd love it if someone with free time happened to paste the best night scene write-up nominations in this thread :o;):D

Ask and you shalt receive

E-Ville Night 16
http://67.19.230.90/~arles/forum/showpost.php?p=395040&postcount=8044

Star Wars Night 2
http://67.19.230.90/~arles/forum/showpost.php?p=484268&postcount=2286

Forum Wars Nights 1 and 10
http://67.19.230.90/~arles/forum/showpost.php?p=400627&postcount=2303
http://67.19.230.90/~arles/forum/showthread.php?p=410705#post410705

Marvel Night 5
http://67.19.230.90/~arles/forum/showpost.php?p=419670&postcount=4642

[i effin rule]

The beauty of a rampaging Rancor.

[Mr T Jobs To Me]

I was pleasantly surprised to see myself nominated for a few things too. I don't think I voted last year but my ballot has now been cast!

[BlueStar]

I sent in my votes.

[Prophet]

Oh man ... it's like homework now! I gotta study! *kicks dirt* :p

(Yes, I openly admit that I'm a fool. lol)

And, by the by, I didn't say this in the other thread, so I'm gonna do it here, as a cheap ploy to lobby more votes for myself ... no ... I meant to think that, and type something obscenely generous. Darn you brain!

(Tangent, sorry.)

In all seriousness, thanks for nominating me. I believe Springfield is my 6th game, 5th here, so to be up in any category is awesome. And truly appreciated. :)

[jbergey_2005]

[
Voting Rules

One vote per account.
You must have at least 10 posts on the forum to vote (to prevent dummy accounts).
You needn't vote for every category, but try to vote for as many as you can.
You can't vote for yourself or a group you were a member of where you as a player/moderator/group are nominated. You can vote for events you were involved in (like Most Dramatic Moment or Best Botch).
PM ballots to both myself and theoutlaw321 (That's 'Wallbanger; theoutlaw321' in the PM's address box.)
Voting closes 12:00am EST/5am GMT Sunday, January 18th.---


The Scummys are becoming big when rules like this are being added:)

[Antithesis]

Just my thoughts on many of the nominations. And please note I think almost all the nominations listed are deserving. But some I think are more deserving than others. Afterall thats what this is for, to decide a winner.


Best Role Claim

It says to consider the role which had the biggest impact or entertainment value. I will say that I found Rev's claim of Simon Dark was maybe the most perfect example of ever of making a fake claim fit the facts presented to the town. But it didn't save him, and I can't say it changed the course of the game. Of the Nominees, Shape's claim goes a long way in helping his team win. He took the role, built a story around it, and managed to fool people collectively and individually. For those reasons I think he deserves it.


Funniest Role Claim
Which one had the most entertainment value overall? Thats pretty much subjective, but I'll note that it was the Maybe Dick and Aussie as Arrows claims that got talked about the most eitehr during the games themselves or afterwards. I'd say if something is memorable, then that's a mark people were entertained by it. But of the two, Maybe Dick was a claim that was part of a plan, and the Arrows claim seemed more like a reaction to events in the game. Personally, watching an elaborately planned ruse fall apart is, to me, more entertaining. So, I;d have to go with Maybe Dick.


Best Role Award
This is recognition to Mods for making a well crafted role. Myself, I think no role in a game exists by itself. If it is really great, it blends with the game and serves an integral part of how the game turns out. In that aspect, Thanos, Sylar, and Panix strike me as roles the game or parts of the game, were built around. All three were original in their own way, and personally, the idea of an SK who steals his victims abilities is the one I like the most. I think had Rev and I made the Gems in the Marvel game up for grabs by anyone, and not just Thanos, I'd vote for Thanos. Sylar had the ability to pick and choose, Thanos was restricted in that regard. The impact of the Panix role relied somewhat on chance. Not that there is anything wrong with that, but with Syalr, the entire game was open to that role (as best I can remember). That kind of freedom deserves the award, imho.


Best Individual Town performance
Scum tried to kill him I forget how many times. He helped lead multiple lynches despite having a role I wouldn't say was all that grand. He survived because other townies recognized the fact that he was a leader. I think Nzane deserves this award.


Best Individual Mafia Performance

There are two different methods to examine. Was the best Mafia performance done behind the scenes, or was it played out in the open? Furthermore, which got the job done via gameplay, or did one have to rely heavily on the role provided? Shape would be right in pointing out that he took what was given him and made it better. And he did it all out where everyone could see. However, I can't help but think being untargetable scum in the game prior to that helped him an added bit in Lakeside, whereas by mid game in Marvel the general mood was something wasn't right about Outlaw, who mainly kept his head down and did his damage behind the scenes where people couldn't see it until it was too late. In fairness, he was helped a lot by his reputation as a talented scum hunter. People didn't want to risk lynching someone so valuable. Honestly I can't decide between these two, but I do think they are the most deserving.


Best Individual Cult Performance
A good measurement is looking to see if they won their game. Out of all the Noms, Nevermore fits that. And he did it by convincing others that he could be trusted.


Best Individual Mason/Individual Award
As mentioned above, winning counts a lot. 2 Cases here of Masons leading the town to victory, and one of an SK making it to the end. Personally, I am not a fan of deal making. I cannot award Nevermore for managing to survive when his survival entailed making a deal. I know, it was smart for him and good game play from his perspective, it just doesn't hold that much sway with me. On the otehr hand, IER and Crychon both played a major part in their sides winning. The Rebel Alliance folks did great as well, but I've already discussed how I feel that Nzane lead the town in that game. So I am looking more at IER and Crychon in their respective games. I know some may deduct points because they think Crychon's role wasn't balanced. And maybe because of that imbalance he was able to step up and lead whereas IER did have a moment where he struggled to convince people to lynch the person who turned out to be the Joker. Having played both games, I just got the sense that Crychon seized the reins early and never looked back. IER didn't really start putting his stamp on things until the midway point. Again, some may argue that's because of Crychon's role. But I'd have to give my vote to Crychon.


Best Group Performance
For this I tend to favor the Town in Hollywood Horror and the Mafia from lakeside, though both won for distinctly different reasons in vastly different games. Honestly its impossible for me to try to figure out a clear winner here. Numbers wise though, I'll note the town had less of an advantage in Hollywood Horror than Scum had in Lakeside. I know people cried sour grapes when I brought up the ratio business, but the truth is I am less impressed by a scum group winning a Dark Barebones game with what became a 1:2 Scum ratio than I am with town in Hollywood Horror kicking the crap out of all the scum they had to face in their game. Still, I'm open to being convinced otherwise.


Best Contribution to Game Discussion
This is for individual players whose overall quality of discussion contribute to the enjoyment of others over the course of the year.

Its an understated approach, but to me Gonvick contributes the most by his habit of just showing up to share information or ask questions.


Best Scum Catcher
I kind of feel somewhat like Arrows was nominated for this based on what he did in SouthPark Mafia. I don't dispute that he's a great scumcatcher. I am just trying to recall what games in 2008 were there where he either didn't sit out, Mod/Co-mod, or die very early? There was Marvel and Lakeside, but he was scum in both of those. The award is for catching scum over the course of the year, afterall. Almost the same thing with DJ, although he did have a tremendous game in Cartoon Chaos, but otehr games he was either targetted early or scum himself. I think IER, for the duration of the year, is a better fit with this.



Most Enjoyable Game
Hollywood Horror. Maybe if I had played it I'd feel differently, but this game was definately fun to follow along.



Most Improved Player
Big Josh. He went from someone people would mock to being a real force in the Gotham Game.


Most Underrated Player
Gonvick. I think some of it may be his style, he doesn't get bogged down in debates so you don't see him around as much. But what he does, he's effective at it.


Hall of Fame

Two most likely candidates, imo, are Arrows and DJ. That they've gotten killed early on in plenty of games isn't a strike against them, its an admission of the respect players have for them. The only knock on Arrows is his temper. It doesn't bother me because hell, I am often one to seek out confrontations, but I certainly understand why some people disprove of it.

[BlueStar]

I'll be honest here, Anti, from the start of R&B mafia I was looking for an alibi. My first idea was to claim Jay Ward and give myself a Beloved Princess role. D1 NickC claims that exact role, N1 he gets offed and his role is proven.

So I start Wikipedia-ing, find Maybe Dick and put it on our board. I get blocked or tracked the next day and Slim & I try to pull off the double claim gambit (I think we killed you as the protector in the process).

I get bussed for the claim, almost the next post Crychon shows up and says: "Oh by the way, Maybe Dick is not an actual character". :mad:

[The Shape]

Anyone care to post the sylar role from heroes? Had a quick look and couldn't find it, but interested to see how it worked xD

[BlueStar]

Anyone care to post the sylar role from heroes? Had a quick look and couldn't find it, but interested to see how it worked xD

Sylar was the SK who cumulated all the abilities of the people he killed. So he became more and more powerful as long as the game lasted.

[nZane]

When the hell did I get added to the HOF ballot? That's a surprise, for sure.You've been a fixture around here since the very beginning. You've modded two of the best games we've had. You've both won and survived a good number of games. You've easily proven yourself as one of the better players around here. You have a Scummie named after you and are nominated for a few more this year. Yeah, you've earned it.

Having said all of that, I haven't decided if I'm actually going to vote for you or not. But I can easily be bought off for cheap. :p

[theoutlaw321]

You've been a fixture around here since the very beginning. You've modded two of the best games we've had. You've both won and survived a good number of games. You've easily proven yourself as one of the better players around here. You have a Scummie named after you and are nominated for a few more this year. Yeah, you've earned it.

Having said all of that, I haven't decided if I'm actually going to vote for you or not. But I can easily be bought off for cheap. :p

Check is in the mail.:cool:

[mjdgoldeneye]

I call shenanigans on not being a choice for Most Prolific Player...

Sure, the other guys there are great players and deserving of the award, but surely they've been nominated elsewhere/have a nomination under best contribution to mafia discussion!

I've been involved in every game here (except South Park for the most part) and I figure I guy at least deserves his freakin' green participation ribbon if he doesn't get an actual award... :rolleyes:

Mostly joking, but come oooooooooooon... :(

[Arrows]

Anyone care to post the sylar role from heroes? Had a quick look and couldn't find it, but interested to see how it worked xD

Welcome to the game. You are Sylar, Self Aligned Power Stealing Killer. While your god given ability may not seem like much, it turned out to be one of the single best abilities possible. Thanks to your ability to understand the way anything in the world works, you can take the powers of those you kill and use them as your own.

Each night phase you must send me the name of one person you wish to attempt to kill. If you are successful in this attempt you will not only kill them, but will also be given their ability to use in the place of your kill at any time.

Some abilities may be automatic, while others may combine to make even greater abilities.

You win when everyone else is eliminated.





He went from that, to being a bomb, future painter(Would get random info about the night an hour before it ended), 50/50 chance of avoiding all abilities(The night he got busted).

Who thinks I should post the entire role-list in the Heroes thread, now that I've found a copy?

[Imarevenant]

Who thinks I should post the entire role-list in the Heroes thread, now that I've found a copy?

LOL, I keep thinking that IER and I should go back one day and finish posting the roles for SWM2 as well. But then I get lazy.


I say, be lazy Arrows.

[Arrows]

LOL, I keep thinking that IER and I should go back one day and finish posting the roles for SWM2 as well. But then I get lazy.


I say, be lazy Arrows.

Would only take like..20 minutes to post the full role list.:p

[The Shape]

You should both not be lazy :o

[Arrows]

You should both not be lazy :o

Seems the thread didn't get moved here, so, 'eh.

[masterded]

Seems the thread didn't get moved here, so, 'eh.

Wonders how many post dj would have if all the past mafia games got moved here.

[theoutlaw321]

Wonders how many post dj would have if all the past mafia games got moved here.

Eventually you will know.:cool:

[Arrows]

Wonders how many post dj would have if all the past mafia games got moved here.

There...are no breaks, but previewed, there are. amusing.

76941341524213545641456414654321454657468473145467 44898974564776341676874614147464746876746547745656 55635335113646366164836837453316436947687531365468 73644361368794351365436879774477487

[Wallbanger]

Eventually you will know.:cool:

We shall truly understand infinity then.

[Tha Black Phenom]

LOL, I keep thinking that IER and I should go back one day and finish posting the roles for SWM2 as well. But then I get lazy.

Post them, damn you.

Also, glad on getting a nom somewhere. GruntMark is a solid scum partner.

[Lostrelms]

Some very deserving folks in there, but ive got to lobby for myself in the cult award.

while Crychon's dancing robot was a great play by a cult...

i was able to build a very good cult group as well.

That, and ive never won a scummy :-/

[Actarus]

We shall truly understand infinity then.

Mein Gott! Please don't encourage him!

Actually, reading along in Simpsons mafia, he seems to have reined himself in. Wish I knew that in advance, but c'est la vie.

[djthefunkchris]

Flattery will get you no where everyone.:cool:

[GruntMark]

Post them, damn you.

Also, glad on getting a nom somewhere. GruntMark is a solid scum partner.

Back at ya buddy.

Im thinking we are in the "It was great to be nominated" category.

Though had we actually pulled it off, we shoulda been handed the award in a landslide.

Cause come'on, that was a rough start and a scum group with a very transparent method of recruitment. And we still managed to way out perform the "primary" scum group.

[Wallbanger]

Just a quick update:

We have received 15 ballots so far, and while you have another whole week to get them in, don't forget to take care of it! I want to see maximum participation from the voters. :D

[Antithesis]

Fixing to send mine in. Encourage everyone else to do the same.

[theoutlaw321]

Just a quick update:

We have received 15 ballots so far, and while you have another whole week to get them in, don't forget to take care of it! I want to see maximum participation from the voters. :D

I have 17 as of now. I will list them when I get a chance so that there is a way for any that have slipped thru the cracks to check.


Vote people!

[Prophet]

Vote: People

Like that? :D

[theoutlaw321]

Vote: People

Like that? :D

/slaps Prophet on the head repeatedly until he is in a fetal position in the corner

[Prophet]

/slaps Prophet on the head repeatedly until he is in a fetal position in the corner

OWWwwwWWWwww!

Ya big meanie poopie head! :p

[Imarevenant]

Vote: People

Like that? :D

LOL

[Wallbanger]

Vote: People

Like that? :D

OWWwwwWWWwww!

Ya big meanie poopie head! :p

Ah Prophet, the John Ritter of GDS Mafia.

And look, he's a nominee for Funniest Player! Imagine that. :D

[theoutlaw321]

Ah Prophet, the John Ritter of GDS Mafia.

And look, he's a nominee for Funniest Player! Imagine that. :D

Didn't I throw his name in? :cool:

[Prophet]

Ah Prophet, the John Ritter of GDS Mafia.

And look, he's a nominee for Funniest Player! Imagine that. :D

By the end of Springfield, I'm gonna go old school, and hit Outlaw with a pie. ;) Nyuck, nyuck!

Didn't I throw his name in? :cool:

As a matter of fact, you did. :D

[theoutlaw321]

As a matter of fact, you did. :D

Just mention it in your acceptance speach.

And forget that not so smart idea about the pie. K? :cool:

[Librarian]

By the end of Springfield, I'm gonna go old school, and hit Outlaw with a pie. ;) Nyuck, nyuck!






Bah! It's frying pan or a half-brick.

[Prophet]

Just mention it in your acceptance speach.

And forget that not so smart idea about the pie. K? :cool:

If I win funniest player, you will definitely get an acknowledgement. As the pie covered little people. :D

Bah! It's frying pan or a half-brick.

Or a shovel, or a wrench ... the Stooges give me a so many options. Nyuck, nyuck!

[theoutlaw321]

I have 17 as of now. I will list them when I get a chance so that there is a way for any that have slipped thru the cracks to check.


Vote people!

18!

[Wallbanger]

18!

Not enough!! More ballots!!! We crave more ballots!!!!

[masterded]

I will fill mine out on sat when I am at work. You may want to send me a pm on sat reminding me I said this.

[Wallbanger]

Deadline for ballots is quickly approaching! Get your votes in if you haven't yet!

[Wallbanger]

Voting is now closed. Ballots received after the timestamp on this post will be discarded.

[djthefunkchris]

Seriously, thanks to everyone that voted for me... Both for the award, and for the other election held in Forum Wars:cool:.

Wallbanger, I made a suggestion about next year's award I think should be considered. There are three games right off the bat I would like to be considered as "Game Breaking" awards (by the Mods of those games).

nZanes Barebones, for showing us that a "Typical" game can be SO MUCH MORE.

MJD's Cartoon Chaos, for giving us something completely different, and thus giving mods a completely different way of how to set up games (My Gotham, loosely based on Chaos and DOTT, for example)

Outlaw's Forum Wars, for giving us the "GDS Kingmaker" version, that is also being used loosely in an ongoing game right now.

I think MJD's was the most different/unique/game breaking/newest idea, and thus the award should be named after him. He wasn't able to do it exactly like he wanted, but everyone that played understands what it was he was trying to achieve for that.

I think that's a great idea for next year's awards: Thoughts?