Official Star Wars Mafia Thread

[Jim Force]

Originally Posted by mjdgoldeneye

Wow... Lost's role is the SECOND that needed to be blurted out...

We aren't doing good at keeping things on the down-low that maybe should...

If things should be a secret then people should stop role claiming. Your level of defensiveness is interesting.

[mjdgoldeneye]

Change Vote: No Lynch

Whatever...

I would like to ask the following things, and obviously don't respond and don't expect that I expect you to follow them:

Investigate me... I'm townie through and through...

DO NOT kill me...Stupid to bother saying that, but if you're in this game, you might want to see what I have to say after the next phase is over. I hope, at least, meaning IDK what I'll get!

[Jim Force]

Originally Posted by mjdgoldeneye

Change Vote: No Lynch

Whatever...

I would like to ask the following things, and obviously don't respond and don't expect that I expect you to follow them:

Investigate me... I'm townie through and through...

DO NOT kill me...Stupid to bother saying that, but if you're in this game, you might want to see what I have to say after the next phase is over. I hope, at least, meaning IDK what I'll get!

Why the personal attack? I never suggested you were a mafia or anything of that nature, I just did not understand the defensive response earlier. If people are going to hint hint hint until they finally role claim then that is nothing to get all fired up about. Suggesting I can not follow your statements is nothing more than pure arrogance.

[mjdgoldeneye]

Originally Posted by Jim Force

If things should be a secret then people should stop role claiming. Your level of defensiveness is interesting.

Defensive of what/whom?

BigJosh blurted out Wallbangers role, and you weren't clever enough to pick up on Lost's, so he linked you to detailed info of who he was...

There's a difference between dropping hints that you hope SOME people get, and flat-out roleclaiming.

I'm basically saying that if you know who someone is, and you're a townie, it might not be pertinent to yell it out...

IER said roleclaiming isn't a good idea himself!

[theoutlaw321]

Originally Posted by Jim Force

If things should be a secret then people should stop role claiming. Your level of defensiveness is interesting.

I agree. If you are going to come out and hint and be cute then you can't be upset when 1)other players don't believe you
or 2)push for more info

[mjdgoldeneye]

Originally Posted by Jim Force

Why the personal attack? I never suggested you were a mafia or anything of that nature, I just did not understand the defensive response earlier. If people are going to hint hint hint until they finally role claim then that is nothing to get all fired up about. Suggesting I can not follow your statements is nothing more than pure arrogance.

That post wasn't a response to you, I hadn't seen your post prior to it yet. My post above this one is a response to you.

[Midnightnick]

Originally Posted by mjdgoldeneye

Change Vote: No Lynch

Whatever...

I would like to ask the following things, and obviously don't respond and don't expect that I expect you to follow them:

Investigate me... I'm townie through and through...

DO NOT kill me...Stupid to bother saying that, but if you're in this game, you might want to see what I have to say after the next phase is over. I hope, at least, meaning IDK what I'll get!

I see your logic, even if you are a little defensive about it. Arrows, that means you'll get your vote off of you, because we've had enough info this day.

Change Vote: No Lynch

Originally Posted by Jim Force

If things should be a secret then people should stop role claiming. Your level of defensiveness is interesting.

Mmhm, if you don't want info known. Don't roleclaim. Simple as that.

[Jim Force]

Originally Posted by mjdgoldeneye

BigJosh blurted out Wallbangers role, and you weren't clever enough to pick up on Lost's, so he linked you to detailed info of who he was...

You might want to recheck that whole situation. He was NOT responding to my post, it was someone else he quoted. So drop the personal attacks against me unless you are trying to come off as arrogant and defensive. Perhaps you are merely roleplaying!

[mjdgoldeneye]

Extension of prior post:

It was in response to whoever said we got enough info this phase. BigJosh I believe...

[Jim Force]

Originally Posted by mjdgoldeneye

That post wasn't a response to you, I hadn't seen your post prior to it yet. My post above this one is a response to you.

Ok, I am not trying to start something with you, but it just seemed you were coming at me a bit.

[Jim Force]

In general I do get the point you are making.

[Arrows]

Originally Posted by Midnightnick

I see your logic, even if you are a little defensive about it. Arrows, that means you'll get your vote off of you, because we've had enough info this day.

Change Vote: No Lynch



Mmhm, if you don't want info known. Don't roleclaim. Simple as that.

MAN. WHEW.

*Wipes sweat off forehead.*

That was so close to being lynched.

[mjdgoldeneye]

You said I was defensive, but before I saw the post, I made another post that appeared to be more defensive, but it didn't even take your post into account.

There problem with this game is posts get tangled up sometimes.

I wasn't posting those "instructions" to make you look unable to draw conclusions, they were serious and directed to everyone in the game, not you.

I stand by what I said before: You CAN hint and NOT roleclaim. Remember: Not everyone on here saw/recalls everything Star Wars that is out there!

[Jim Force]

Originally Posted by mjdgoldeneye

There problem with this game is posts get tangled up sometimes.

I agree with that 100%.

[mjdgoldeneye]

Originally Posted by Arrows

MAN. WHEW.

*Wipes sweat off forehead.*

That was so close to being lynched.

There you go again... You're not making it easy for me to trust you, and if you take the stance that you don't know I'm town/I'm only one person so it doesn't matter, it's only day 1, and you have 2 people willing to vote for you.

I'd hold off with the sarcasm...