Originally Posted by GDS1MAFIACOUNCIL
While discussion about any topic concerning this community is a good thing and is encouraged; please refrain from doing it here in the signup thread. Please use the following thread
Again all discussion is welcomed and encouraged, but let's do it in the proper place.
My apologies to Arrows
, I was going to post down here but I did not know if anyone came to this part of the site anymore with everything else being posted in the Dog Pound.
Originally Posted by Paws7297
BHK, we are trying some new things out to see what works and what doesn't. What makes the games more active. What keeps more people around.
If you don't try it, and see how it goes, how are you helping improve anything?
These rules aren't completely permanent. We are trying to gauge how the rules go and who does and doesn't like them.
Trying it out won't kill you. what if you end up liking the change in activity?
Well I really do not see how forcing people to play a certain way is going to make them more active or keep them around. I think it will end up doing the opposite, granted I could be wrong.
Look I am only one person, it does not matter if I play or not. I just wanted to say why I would not play because of the factors that I previously stated. Forcing a lynch every phase is not improving anything, in fact it makes the game far less enjoyable to play if you are a member of the town (Which I usually am).
By the time day two comes around there is a very high probability that the Town will be down three people right out of the gate. Sure the Town might get lucky and lynch Scum on the first day but the chances of that happening are not high.
Also, you run the risk of taking out a powerful role. After reading Rev's summary about being gutted, I can only imagine how much it would suck as a mod to see it happen more often.
There is no way I could possibly enjoy myself if the first rule remains intact. I do not need to play in a game to know that because I already know it. Therefore, there is no way if I tried playing in a game I would end up liking it.