The Official Mafia Discussion Thread

[moon_lit_tears]

Originally Posted by Gabbo

... and the fun begins.


Half tempted to try it as an experiment. Maybe micro mafia. I just had an idea how to slightly balance it too...

Maybe give a limit to once per game per ability?

[d_w_w]

Make it speed mafia, IMO.

Everyone sends a list of the top 3 roles/targets they'd like to have. First come, first serve. If all 3 of your roles are taken, you do nothing.

[Gabbo]

Originally Posted by d_w_w

Make it speed mafia, IMO.

Everyone sends a list of the top 3 roles/targets they'd like to have. First come, first serve. If all 3 of your roles are taken, you do nothing.

This was kinda my thinking. I was just gonna do the first three to send in PGO succeed, first three to send in a kill, etc - to counter everyone wanting the same role. Think I'd have to have a list of 15/20 abilities in the first post that anyone can use at night, to prevent people making roles up. Needs alot of tweaking but there's potential there, IMO.

[moon_lit_tears]

Originally Posted by Gabbo

This was kinda my thinking. I was just gonna do the first three to send in PGO succeed, first three to send in a kill, etc - to counter everyone wanting the same role. Think I'd have to have a list of 15/20 abilities in the first post that anyone can use at night, to prevent people making roles up. Needs alot of tweaking but there's potential there, IMO.

That is a rather good idea. If you do this I am so in.

[d_w_w]

I think it'd be fun

[eayragt]

Originally Posted by Comradebot

Also... I've never been a tracker. I'd love to be one of thems some time.

I was a tracker once. Survived quite a long time... tried to track lots of different people... none of which did anything. Worst tracker ever.

[The Shape]

Gabbo, if you run that game, save me a spot And reply to my last pm about family guy damnit. At least I think you haven't lol.

[BHK1978]

I would like to be a Serial Killer once and Scum once (does not matter what Scum role). But if I had to pick one it would be a Serial Killer. It just seems like such a fun role to have. Granted SK's tend to get killed off quickly but who cares! You still get to kill people!

[Waghlon]

I would just like to be scum more often. Its enjoyable.

[Imarevenant]

Would like to be a serial killer again, that was fun.

Would also like to be an investigator. Been one 3 times, twice was paranoid and thus useless, and the other, the town vig killed me night 2 for one of the dumbest reasons I could remember lol

[BHK1978]

Originally Posted by Imarevenant

Would like to be a serial killer again, that was fun.

Would also like to be an investigator. Been one 3 times, twice was paranoid and thus useless, and the other, the town vig killed me night 2 for one of the dumbest reasons I could remember lol

I never want to be an investigator or anything like that again!!!

Pokemon, Host, Futurama, and Invader Zim. All four of those games I have been either an investigator, watcher, or tracker. When I got the role in Zim I thought Glot was messing with me.

[moon_lit_tears]

I don't know exactly what you would call it, but in south park I was Mr Hanky (don't laugh) My ability was that I could hear extra stuff. Just little tidbits of stuff that wasn't in the write-up. That was kind of fun too.

[i effin rule]

I don't think I've ever been a SK, would be nice though. At my age it is hard to remember what I have and haven't been though. There are so many cool roles that I haven't really been. I think I've been a JOAT at least twice and a Don twice. A mason twice also, I think. Both times I got killed because the town was determined that one of the mason's was bad.

[BHK1978]

Okay this is going to sound dumb but what is a JOAT?

[i effin rule]

Originally Posted by BHK1978

Okay this is going to sound dumb but what is a JOAT?

Jack of All Trades


Someone who has multiple abilities, but they are usually one shot. Different variations though.