The Official Medical Mafia Game Thread

[Crychon]

Change Vote: No Vote

I'm think they're both lying, and scum, but as has been said, there's plenty of time left on the clock, so let's not go rushing anything.

[Imarevenant]

Night 4 I tried to send Banger somewhere, that target is still alive, unless he or I were blocked I don't think he's the killer. However he could very well be scum and so I wouldn't take what I'm telling you as clearing him.

Vote: Masterded

I won't be around except for very late tomorrow. I just spent the day in ER for my daughter when she was supposed to be in a parade. She's doing great now but needless to say this week off from work that I have would be better spent babying her than putting too much thought into mafia. I'll keep up just won't be any type of priority. And actually if Two or DB think it better to replace me I won't complain.

[Zeel1]

Originally Posted by Imarevenant

Night 4 I tried to send Banger somewhere, that target is still alive, unless he or I were blocked I don't think he's the killer. However he could very well be scum and so I wouldn't take what I'm telling you as clearing him.

Vote: Masterded

I won't be around except for very late tomorrow. I just spent the day in ER for my daughter when she was supposed to be in a parade. She's doing great now but needless to say this week off from work that I have would be better spent babying her than putting too much thought into mafia. I'll keep up just won't be any type of priority. And actually if Two or DB think it better to replace me I won't complain.

.....Hmmm...

This..is admittedly a fleeting chance, but here's a thought.

It says that you only redirect people when they go out, with emphasis on the if, in your Role PM..right? But you redirected Peck when he said and he didn't go out..and I'd like to assume that wasn't a lie. What if..and this is pretty much just a what if..it was the other way around? What if you only redirect people when they don't go out?

Admittedly, putting a little bastardness into it, like telling you the opposite of how it works, would be a weird thing to do for the Heart of all things..but hey, can't put anything past these mods, right? This would effectively explain away both the Peck and WB situations, wouldn't it?

[moon_lit_tears]

Three things then I'm out.

1. Rev hope your daughter gets better soon.

2. Zeel if you think it's who I think you are thinking I wil call b.s right now

3. Whose to say the killer opted to not kill last night and claim a protector?

We had a kill night 4, no?

[Zeel1]

Originally Posted by moon_lit_tears

2. Zeel if you think it's who I think you are thinking I wil call b.s right now

So, I take it by this that you still don't buy Pet's claim?

[moon_lit_tears]

Originally Posted by Zeel1

So, I take it by this that you still don't buy Pet's claim?

I am not sure. At this point it doesn't matter.

[Zeel1]

Hm.

It's just that, the main conclusion I came to was that scum planned to get her lynched today - only for that to be foiled by all the evidence against WB and Mded coming up so very quickly after the start of the phase. Which, if my theory is right, doesn't particularly make you look good. Not accusing you though - seeing as she did promise to give us her roletitle as soon as she could, I saw little wrong with trying to make sure she came through, after seeing some delay. And her responses weren't exactly the townieist of sorts - although I guess I'm one to talk..

This conclusion may clue you in more on who I think our Leftie is, though.

And,

...Hmmm...

This..is admittedly a fleeting chance, but here's a thought.

It says that you only redirect people when they go out, with emphasis on the if, in your Role PM..right? But you redirected Peck when he said and he didn't go out..and I'd like to assume that wasn't a lie. What if..and this is pretty much just a what if..it was the other way around? What if you only redirect people when they don't go out?

Admittedly, putting a little bastardness into it, like telling you the opposite of how it works, would be a weird thing to do for the Heart of all things..but hey, can't put anything past these mods, right? This would effectively explain away both the Peck and WB situations, wouldn't it?

^As I said, this is simply a theory to toss around - one that, I feel, would effectively explain all of the confusion that all three of Rev's redirections caused. Having said that, this does make me a good deal less sure of WB being a killer..although, to take a page out of your book, Rev () - I roleblocked him on a night in which their were no kills..hard to believe that was just a coincidence.

[moon_lit_tears]

What doesn't make me look good?

I put a vote on Banger. I took it off simply because I don't want to end phase to quickly. I'm the one who started asking simple questions of M-ded. If he comes up scum and your theory is correct that makes me scum. Ok so I just outed my partner?

I don't get it.

I asked for a title because she claimed like day phase 4 so I wanted a title because quite frankly I didn't believe it. It has been done many times before.

She was never in any danger of being lynched today to be honest about it.

Now with that I am off for a few hours got stuffs to do.

[petrija]

Here's the thing I don't get.

If there's a left, I don't know what the ability would be.

[The Two]

It is now Day Phase 6. With 13 players remaining, it is 7 votes to lynch.

You have until 1pm BST / 8am EDT on Tuesday, May 25th to reach a majority. If a lynch is not achieved, a No Lynch will be declared.

Masterded (4): Wallbanger, Jman2k3, Destiny, Imarevenant

Wallbanger (2): Zeel1, Petrija

[moon_lit_tears]

Originally Posted by petrija

Here's the thing I don't get.

If there's a left, I don't know what the ability would be.

So you were not told there is a left?

[moon_lit_tears]

Ok random thought time then back to laundry.

IF Bossman was redirected N4, the person is still alive, yet there were 2 deaths. That doesn't add up.

I'm curious why 2 deaths N4, but none last night. I know one was a delayed kill. So that leaves the one kill we are missing. I know that it looks bad with Bossman being blocked, and not jack aligned.

Now we have M-ded who has lied about a few things.

1. Not sending a pm in. We know that can't be right because phase ended early. Nice catch Bak.
2. His role. When he hinted at cells I honestly thought he was hinting something else. Way to go on the catch Jman.

So time is gong I think we are down to about 17 hours left in phase.

We have two directions to take here. I honestly like Zeels idea.

The only problem with that is, who's to say scum won't kill knowing Zeel is going to block Bossman.

Zeel I have an idea if you want to hear it out. Ok?

[petrija]

I already said. I don't know who the other is, or if the other even exists. For someone so insistent you're not keeping your facts too straight.

[moon_lit_tears]

Originally Posted by petrija

I already said. I don't know who the other is, or if the other even exists. For someone so insistent you're not keeping your facts too straight.

It was more of a rhetorical question.

I'm just not sure about it that's all.

Besides I think we have other paths to travel right now anyway.

[petrija]

Originally Posted by moon_lit_tears

So time is gong I think we are down to about 17 hours left in phase.

We have two directions to take here. I honestly like Zeels idea.

The only problem with that is, who's to say scum won't kill knowing Zeel is going to block Bossman.

Zeel I have an idea if you want to hear it out. Ok?

Like I said before, Zeel's idea is a good one, but we can't be sure scum won't mess with it, so it's pretty well void by now.

Originally Posted by moon_lit_tears

It was more of a rhetorical question.

I'm just not sure about it that's all.

Besides I think we have other paths to travel right now anyway.

I don't blame you for being uneasy about it, it's a silly role. The ability fits though.

I'm just frustrated because amongst trying to keep up on my phone, I felt like all I kept reading was constant reminders for me to post a title, and the frustration only escalated from there because I wasn't able to do so. I apologize if I came off as rude, as that wasn't my intention at all. Purely frustration talking.

-----

So based on what I said before, I really think Banger is our best bet for today.